3 ms·
I come from a family of police officers, so I'm keenly aware of the risks police officers take, and I'm very appreciative of their service. But. I am tired of
by mattzito 11y ago
I come from a family of police officers, so I'm keenly aware of the risks police officers take, and I'm very appreciative of their service.
But.
I am tired of the automatic assumption that police officers and fire fighters are to be lionized because they "risk their lives". It's true that there are police officers and firefighters and EMTs who work tough beats and have extremely dangerous lives. But by and large, these jobs are significantly less dangerous than many other jobs that pay less and don't come with the public respect of being a firefighter/PO/etc.
In NYC, for example, sanitation workers have higher rates of injury and death than police officers do by 2x[1]. Convenience store clerks and commercial fishermen also have much higher death and injury rates.
None of that means that we shouldn't respect and appreciate those who work hard to keep us safe. But it's also reasonable to recognize that these positions pay well and have excellent benefits relative to jobs with much higher risk and much lower social respect.
1. http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2013/04/the-secret-world-of-garbagemen/274536/ http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2013/04/the-secr...
- bootload 11y ago"I am tired of the automatic assumption that police officers and fire fighters are to be lionized because they "risk their lives"." Just answering the original poster. Farming and construction are also dangerous and the risks, aside from random bad luck can be managed, while pay and conditions may vary. But that's not what was being discussed. The OP was complaining about first responder over-time and pensions, while the most risk involved in well funded companies and startups is probably getting a paper cut. The distinction I draw is between the types of risk and reward being experienced.
- mattzito 11y agoYour point was about their risking their lives in exchange for overtime and pensions. My point is that there are many jobs that have more risk and no overtime or pensions and maybe those are the jobs we should be talking more about.