2 ms·
> Before we get wildly over-optimistic, as every HN thread on AI becomes, realize that neural networks have basically nothing to do with actual biological neuro
by dahart 11y ago
> Before we get wildly over-optimistic, as every HN thread on AI becomes, realize that neural networks have basically nothing to do with actual biological neurons.
Yes. I think I was already fully agreeing with you, and suggesting the same but in softer language. Maybe you meant that for the parent or more generally the thread, but I think that I should add something: I may have unintentionally conflated the discussion on neural nets and the biological research my friend was talking about.
My limited understanding of what he said - and I'll go ask him for a reference - is that we (as in scientists somewhere, not me personally) have come to a more or less clear and complete understanding of the chemical and electrical processes in the neural functioning of these simple life-forms, from top to bottom. (I don't know that's true, but that's what I think I heard.) They then tried to put together a complete simulation of this simple lifeform's neurons. This simulation, as I understand it, is not a neural network per se, but something trying to be much closer to a biological simulation. And when they turn it on, apparently, it doesn't work.
That story, if true, tends to confirm what you said; we're missing something in our understanding of biological neurons. Which, I think, lets me say more confidently that we can't suggest we have the building blocks for AI yet.