4 ms·
Huge win for the publishers. If Amazon accepts, then the publishers (And I disagree with Amazon, once they conceed with Macmillan, the rest will want the same
by ghshephard 17y ago
Huge win for the publishers. If Amazon accepts, then the publishers (And I disagree with Amazon, once they conceed with Macmillan, the rest will want the same deal) will be able to leverage this agreement to get the same from Barnes and Nobles and other eBook sellers - I'm sure Apple will, likewise, agree - if they haven't already.
This will restrict (prevent?) Amazon, B&N, Apple from discounting eBook prices to get people into their eStore. It hurts the reader, in that they can't get cheap eBooks until a year after they are released. I wonder if the publishers will try to extend this to the "Physical" book market, or whether that's a different ballgame altogether. (If Walmart is the Amazon in the physical book market, who is the Apple? I'm sure B&N likes being able to flexibly price books to get traffic in the store. As does Target. For that matter, so does Amazon. Is there an odd man out there with enough volume to make a difference?)
From a competitive landscape perspective - Steve Jobs knew that providing an agency model as a negotiating tool to Macmillan was valuable - I'm wondering what he got back in return?
All in all, a very exciting weekend of developments in the eBook economy. All started with the iBook store negotiating between Apple and Macmillan, I'm sure.
- adamc 17y agoInteresting. If it has the effect you postulate, I would expect to see reduced demand for ebooks, and more "piracy" (copyright infringement).
- tokenadult 17y agoInteresting analysis. Yet I think over the next several years authors (who, after all, produce new content) and readers will be thinking about these trade-offs from their own perspectives, and it's not necessarily so that all publishers will agree with Macmillan. High prices produce business opportunities for sellers who offer lower prices.
- mikedouglas 17y agoConsidering the immaturity of the ebooks market, price variability seems like a good thing. Increased margins (whether the result of higher or lower prices) will let publishers experiment with better typography, lesser known authors and more interactive works. The last thing most of us would like to see would be the ebook market turned into a numbers game such that only mass market paperbacks, poorly converted public domain material, and amateur self-publishers ever get access to the market. How would we have reacted if Apple had announced a $0.99 ceiling for the AppStore?
- pyre 17y ago> amateur self-publishers If amateur self-publishers have access to the market, then how do you figure that non-'mass market paperbacks' don't?
- petercooper 17y ago(And I disagree with Amazon, once they conceed with Macmillan, the rest will want the same deal) But who cares? The big publishers aren't the only publishers out there, and it leaves a lot of scope for smaller, more agile publishers to steal business from the bigger ones selling the overpriced e-books. If Amazon had "won" this one and the big publishers' e-books were all under $10, it'd have done more to hurt entrepreneurs and small publishers since they'd find it a lot harder to compete. Macmillan winning means that, ultimately, they lose. The longer "established" publishers keep high prices on their e-books, the more opportunities there are for top writers to self publish to these new e-book stores. Wouldn't that be great? More money for the authors and a steadily reducing influence by the publishers. It's started to happen in the music industry..
- mechanical_fish 17y agoIt hurts the reader, in that they can't get cheap eBooks until a year after they are released One of the lessons I have learned from this debacle is that I should be careful what I wish for. It turns out, according to my favorite authors, that time-sensitive pricing is a huge part of what makes the economics of their business work. After all, an author's hardcore fans are willing to pay more, and time-sensitive pricing -- with books costing more on the day of release, then gradually getting cheaper -- is the established mechanism for extracting that premium. The "hardcover" vs "softcover" vs "remaindered" thing is the industry's way of signalling the different price points. I've suddenly started looking at hardcover buyers with more respect. These people aren't suckers, or at least they aren't mere suckers. They are the patrons, the hardcore fans, that are keeping my favorite writers in business. It would be the height of irony if I eventually got what I used to think was my wish -- flat-rate ebooks at, say, $5 per copy, no premium pricing -- only to see my favorite authors either go out of business or figure out some other way -- exclusive early releases by subscription, the street performer protocol, selling T-shirts, product placement -- to recover the equivalent of the cost of a hardcover book! We're all going to save money in the e-book era, but I'm not really sure it's going to be that much money: Writers and editors and marketers still need to be paid. We'll save on printing and shipping, but that may be about it. There just aren't tons of excess profits sitting around in book publishing: The audiences are too small. I might not even save money on bricks and mortar: I like visiting bookstores or the equivalent, even if just to sit and drink tea while surrounded by media.
- ja30278 17y agoThere may not be tons of excess profits, but there are certainly tons of efficiencies to be gained by eliminating the print/ship/warehouse model of distribution. I simply don't accept the argument that ebooks can't be sold drastically more cheaply than paper books. To me, there's no reason for the publisher to exist at all (not that the various functions they provide don't need to be done, just that they don't need to be provided by a single large entity). Not to mention that, as sold, Ebooks represent a drastically _worse_ value than paper books. They aren't lendable, they're often linked to a single device, and the right to read them can even be revoked remotely. Publishers are offering a worse product for nearly the same price, while simultaneously crying poor.