5 ms·
Won't happen, vendors just won't be able to sell in NY, so residents will have to buy elsewhere. And when the NY 1% can't buy their iPhone because Apple protec
by tracker1 11y ago
Won't happen, vendors just won't be able to sell in NY, so residents will have to buy elsewhere. And when the NY 1% can't buy their iPhone because Apple protects their privacy, I think any such law wouldn't last long.
- vinceguidry 11y agoI want the bill to pass for this reason. I want to see how the courts interpret it. Just how much pull should local jurisdictions be able to exert on a corporation's business practices? Say the major vendors just decide to pull out of the NY market, yanking devices off of shelves. How exactly does NY think they can enforce the law?
- sbuttgereit 11y agoI'm not a lawyer or an expert on the commerce clause, etc. But is seems like these issues have passed muster before. Consider that California has stricter environmental regulations concerning the cars that are sold there than many other states. The manufacturers simply make cars that meet the California standard and sell them pretty much everywhere (at least I'm pretty sure that use the be the case, haven't kept up with it though). If that local regulation has passed any and all legal tests, then I would be surprised if New York couldn't act independently in this case. And I think the manufacturers would simply do something similar: you'd end up with compromised security on all devices that come under the law even in states where that law didn't exist.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> The manufacturers simply make cars that meet the California standard and sell them pretty much everywhere (at least I'm pretty sure that use the be the case, haven't kept up with it though). Many manufacturers still distinguish cars with "California emissions".
- baddox 11y agoAnother example: big name-brand beers have different alcohol percentages in different states.
- sathackr 11y agoI buy equipment all the time that is not legal for sale in California. But I don't go out of my way to do such. With the emissions argument, lower emissions is generally accepted as a positive feature, though some may dislike the reduced performance or increased cost associated with it in some instances. Backdoored encryption is not something generally accepted as a positive feature, and I suspect many people will specifically seek out non-backdoored devices if the law is passed and manufacturers start making devices for the lowest common denominator. But since this is a software feature, I see no reason why a single device couldn't serve both markets, with a fused bit somewhere permanently enabling the backdoor. But, as said previously ad nauseam, the law would stop criminals about as effectively as the anti-radar detector laws keeps radar detectors out of Virginia. The widespread use of instant-on radar and LIDAR has done far more to curb the widespread use of them, in all states, by simply making them ineffective.
- sbuttgereit 11y agoMany people would seek out such devices... but many people can still be a small minority of your target market. If the economics makes sense to have two different builds they'll do it, if it doesn't then you'll get one size fits all. Also, consider how many people that buy these devices also use cloud services available for these devices where even fourth amendment protections are likely null/void. In some ways/shapes/forms it makes the device encryption backdoor already moot for many.
- sathackr 11y agoYes...I'm curious to see how 'things stored in the cloud' will eventually work out with the 4th/5th amendment protections. Seems most of the current law applies to them as electronic communications, but I think they are becoming more and more like a safe deposit box, which I think has fared a bit better. It's unfortunate that it will likely take a few guinea pigs with a lot of money and the right type of case to force the judicial system to work this out. Of course, the prudent criminal would encrypt anything, using non-backdoored encryption, before it left his/her control thus making LEO/Government access to their cloud storage ineffective.
- cmurf 11y agoSchadenfreude fan, huh? The courts will likely treat it the way they have wiretapping. That is, unless a skilled defense shows that unfunded and indefinitely key escrowing is impractical or unfair somehow, which is probably hard to do seeing as Apple used to offer a key escrow service (opt-in) on OS X's FileVault 2, and Microsoft offers one (opt-out after they have the key escrowed) still today. This is what China wants, so if Apple isn't going to stop selling in China on principled grounds, then why would they stop selling in NY or anywhere else that decides to go down this path? As for enforcement, every state has its own rules for merchants. NY State has the business license and if you don't follow their laws they can withdraw the license and now the company can't sell product in the state. The thing that irks me is this transparently targets average Joe User and below average crook. Because only those two groups will end up with either weaker encryption (breakable encryption, including backdoors) or keys being escrowed. Anyone who understands this, including the above average crook and far worse, will just get some other product that uses escrow-free strong encryption that isn't subject to that state or that country's laws.
- drdaeman 11y agoMore likely "immediately worse present for a better future". It just seems that humans rarely learn unless they experience a painful failure (and sometimes a multiple ones are required) and get some reminders by the scars left. This, of course, doesn't work if worst is introduced gradually (it's how we got where we are) - only acute cases work. The idea is, governments would never cease their attempts just because there are some objections and counterpoints. But after a grand fuck-up they won't dare to try it - and if they do they'll be told "you want another New York, eh?" and that will work.
- kec 11y agoThis sort of thing isn't exactly without precedent. Look at gun laws in CA: there are many types of firearms and firearm accessories which are legal in most of the US but cannot be sold or possessed in California. Gun manufacturers have responded over the years by either pulling out of the state entirely, or producing California compliant versions of their products.
- TillE 11y agoDon't forget the loss of sales tax. It's a poorly considered way of achieving some poorly considered goals.
- philipov 11y agoThis is just politicians pretending to work. Someone's probably using this as a bargaining chip for negotiating their real goals, or to show they're a team player, or pander to their constituency.
- peterhadlaw 11y agoI think more of what @CamperBob2 is alluding to will happen to be honest... Unfortunately.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mc32 11y agoJust wait till China, Russia and India get the itch for this. Just one of them have enough market and potential markets no vendors will leave money on the table and give up market share. It has a good chance of happening in one of those markets if not here and then, it's just a matter of time till many nations demand the same.
- krasin 11y agoApple came to Russia relatively late (near iPhone 4, I think). People did buy lots of iPhones before that anyway. They would just buy in the USA and have it delivered via post (sometimes unofficial post). And Apple understands that. I don't have any data on China and India. They might be more lucrative markets due to the size.
- csydas 11y agoI don't think there are official Apple Stores in Russia, just retailers that carry the products. All the stores I see selling Mac stuff are usually under the name re:Store [1] and while they have certainly imp'd the Apple Store look, they very clearly are not Apple. I know they have an online presence for Russians, but the majority of sales either come through these reseller stores or through people buying online from abroad and having someone send the device. That being said, the number of old ladies I see on the metro with iPhone 6's makes me somewhat envious. [1] - http://www.re-store.ru http://www.re-store.ru
- mirimir 11y agoThat, or residents who want secure devices will just buy them elsewhere. It's very common now for people to have cellphone accounts from other states.
- kazinator 11y agoThat or someone actually communicating with others with regard to illegal activities will install non-backdoored encryption software rather whatever came with their device. The cops will backdoor the phone and decrypt it, only to find a file called "my-awesome-terrorist-plot.doc.aes".
- hobs 11y agoI would be interested to see the cost of losing The Apple Stores in NYC. Some of the highest valued retail that there is from what I remember reading, but I guess real estate in NYC is super valuable in any case.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoTurn them in to Tesla-style showrooms, where you can't actually buy a device directly.
- threatofrain 11y agoMost people just buy their phones without thinking, and would find this encryption debate a little technical. They probably also think that they won't be personally inconvenienced, and that only criminals would be specifically targeted by the authorities. I think only an effortful, informed, and motivated individual would buy their phone out-of-state. Plus, I'm pretty sure NY won't be the only place enacting such anti-encryption measures. Eventually, those who advocate for encryption and privacy will be out of the moral mainstream, and will have a tough PR road ahead of them.
- mikeash 11y agoPeople buy phones out of state all the time, when they buy them online. I don't think that would be a particularly notable impediment.
- kabdib 11y agoWhen a voter can't go into a phone store / Apple store and buy a shiny new thing: Boom, recall election. Presumably assemblyman Titone knows this, and is expecting the bill to do nothing other than provide the usual security theatre. That, or he is dumb as a post. Could go either way :-) I expect to see congressional level legislation like this very soon. That'll be significantly more interesting.
- threatofrain 11y agoI thought that businesses would simply create a NY-compliant version, just like I'm sure they create many variations of their existing products for compliancy around the globe. I also don't expect this to stay NY-specific. This sounds like something that would be generally desired by many nations. Customers need not experience inconvenience if this is done right. There are obvious reasons why the police would actually want this beyond security theater (PR). It actually makes their job easier.
- Bud 11y agoIt makes their job far too easy, which is of course precisely the point. It also makes doing things that are not "their job" at all quite easy, which is the other part of the point.
- ryan-c 11y agoReally? I'm pretty sure that when CA passed the smartphone kill switch law all smartphones got kill switches.
- tzs 11y agoOne big difference with that was the phone makers were moving toward kill switches anyway. Apple touted theirs as a feature long before that law was introduced in California. The main opposition to kill switches came from phone carriers because they make a lot of money selling (1) replacement phones to people whose phones are stolen and (2) theft insurance to people who fear their phones will be stolen, and from some privacy and civil rights groups that (1) misunderstood the bill due to not reading it carefully and/or (2) were basing their opposition on completely ridiculous scenarios [1]. [1] For example, some claimed that police could use the kill switches to quickly and without a warrant shut down all the phones of protestors to stop them from reporting and filming police brutality. That was a ridiculous scenario for several reasons. First, the kill switch involves sending a targeted command to each specific phone to be killed, so the police would first have to bring in something to identify all the protestor phones. Then they would have to go to the phone maker or the carrier (which depends on how the particular kill switch works for that phone) and get them to send the command. There is no particular reason to believe that the companies would have a procedure for that, so this could be very slow...and there is also no reason to believe it is even possible, because nothing in the law requires that the company can kill the phone without the cooperation of the owner. By the time they do all this, the protest is likely to be long over. Furthermore, the law only applies to smartphones. People with feature phones would be free to report and record unfettered, as would people using tablets. On top of that, the law allows (and as far as I know every implementation implements) the phone owner to turn off kill switch capability, so the "use the kill switch to cover up police brutality" plan only works if none of the protestors are smart enough to turn off the kill switch before joining the protest. If the police actually, in the real world, were going to try to block protestors from reporting and recording with their phones they would do it by trying to get the cell towers in the area shut down, or by using Stingray-like devices in active mode to intercept and block communications.
- 11y ago
- sathackr 11y agoAnd of course, criminals will certainly only purchase/steal device compliant with the law, because, you know, they want to obey the law. And they won't install any apps or use any other means to hide their illegal goods/communications. Just like the ones with violent felonies/intending to commit violent felonies will only lawfully acquire guns to commit violent felonies. Can someone explain please what I'm not seeing? I give you our politicians are sometimes not the smartest, but it doesn't take even an average IQ to see the logical failure here. That being the case, these elected officials must know that this won't solve the problem. So what is their ulterior motive in spending so much time chasing after a law that will do very little to stop real crime? Just so they can look like they're doing 'something?'
- Umn44 11y ago"That being the case, these elected officials must know that this won't solve the problem. Except your not understanding why this is happening. You and most americans really are out of the loop about what is going on in the world... right now world leaders fear political awakening of the masses of the planet. The (mass surveillance) by the NSA and abuse by law enforcement is just more part and parcel of state suppression of dissent against corporate interests. They're worried that the more people are going to wake up and corporate centers like the US and canada may be among those who also awaken. See this vid with Zbigniew Brzezinski, former United States National Security Advisor. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n7ZyJw_cHJY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n7ZyJw_cHJY Brezinski at a press conference https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VWTIZBCQ79g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VWTIZBCQ79g Snowden on terrorism/spying. http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/video/2015/sep/25/edward-snowden-treaty-glenn-greenwald-mass-surveillance-terrorism-video http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/video/2015/sep/25/edward-... Democracy Inc. http://www.amazon.com/Democracy-Incorporated-Managed-Inverted-Totalitarianism/dp/069114589X/ http://www.amazon.com/Democracy-Incorporated-Managed-Inverte... Intereference in other states when the corporations dont get their way https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8mxp_wgFWQo&feature=youtu.be&list=PLKR2GeygdHomOZeVKx3P0fqH58T3VghOj&t=724 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8mxp_wgFWQo&feature=youtu.be...