4 ms·
I've had that same dialog and result across a wide variety of diciplines. The yacht people came to mind from the comments here. I'm not really going to equate
by ddingus 11y ago
I've had that same dialog and result across a wide variety of diciplines. The yacht people came to mind from the comments here.
I'm not really going to equate Web pages in the way you are attempting. The parallels are far too coarse and fail to be inclusive enough to make for meaningful discussion.
The idea of, it's worked before, so do it again is a good idea. But there are a lot of limits to doing that safely that are just not being considered here.
In a vacuum, "I need this thing", or even, "this building" doing that can make sense. I know a guy who has applied roughly these kinds of ideas to things like parking garages. My experience is more electromechanical, but there are strong parallels.
I will agree we may be closer on the AEC side of things. Design can often be less of a factor, but there still is all the analysis and verification on significant structures. For minor league things, are we not mostly there? A lot can be done without CAD and that's fine.
I will argue effective CAD can still improve on many of those cases. Making CAD accessible still seems to me the better path, and that's due to the fact that we really can't responsibly ignore the process.
CAD is a whole lot more than making plans, or defining shapes. There is descriptive and analytic geometry, two cases made difficult to employ on some CAD systems that were simplified to maximize more common use cases. Engineers and designers, who understand how and why one would use geometric methods, pay easily for capable CAD software that delivers great returns to all involved.
I also helped with a FAB, where everyone involved wanted to improve on the reams of paper drawings needed to communicate the work. There also needed to be a means to communicate variances from the plan too. Stuff happens, and is it cheaper to go with it, or rip it out and do over?
I modeled the whole FAB, and output the result as a 3D view, measure, section, etc... dataset. The guys could go on site, locate themselves and then see the work, to scale, measure, etc... they could also send back differences and errors in 2D and get fresh models to work from.
And we took a TON of cost out of that one. Pre construction bids were much closer to realities, there was far less error, far less overall comms between everyone, etc... I've been on a few other projects that are similar and can't say much. There are a few people in the world out there who are applying a lot more of the mechanical CAD capabilities with great results.
Because that was done in CAD, I have a ton of options. It's a great template for another FAB. I could add rules and constraints and limits to enhance that too. I have, as an exercise and now know I could make an 80 percent fab start model... the dataset is proprietary, so no sharing, but recent advances in CAD API options as well as how and what parametrics and rules can be input bring a lot to the table.
Yeah, making prtery stuff is a distraction. Management and culture problem. We have an education problem too. The things I mention here are mature, work well, but just not taught to the degree they should be. There is huge industry inertia holding things back in the AEC space that does not exist in the same degree in, say mechanical and entertainment. Entertainment and games have few human impacts, and we do see computational means being applied. Some of that has trickled into mechanical too. More will come.
And, it's not so practical to express these things in a purely computational way. Honestly, the barrier to entry on that is even higher! If you dislike vendor pricing on CAD, the sticker shock on those kinds of datasets will be brutal. Open ones won't be trusted, they will need to be evaluated, and closed ones will work, be supported, liability compliant, etc...
Even the basic input to a computational type system will need to be a sort of CAD, due to the difficulty we have in communication geometry, sans visual means. Should that system result in something viable, nobody would ethically bill with it, until after a professional does an analysis.
You mentioned scaling... well, applying high end CAD to stuff like this, and doing it the way the mechanical people have done it for years can scale! It's the CAD that can bring the scale to the table. It's been going on for years and we ate at the point of digitally simulating entire vehicles, factories, etc... and that stuff brings us better, faster, less expensive things and the automation needed to make them too.
2D rats nest drawings are going away. Delivering robust 4d and 3d to people is pretty awesome and a smaller planning, design, compliance, engineering group can do the work of many people and across multiple projects too.
Honestly, I think a lot of what you are getting at exists, and CAD enables it. Human input can be distilled down to a Web page. Design rules, template parts, intent and other compute driven inferences take people out of the equation now too.
In the mechanical case, the ongoing changes continue to add a lot of value. It's not just a business model. If anything, the AEC side of things could learn a few things from the mechanical people, who by the way, do take liberally from appropriate AEC ways and means where they make sense.
Both teams could benefit from software ways and means, and I know of at least one new, free to use on your phone or computer cloud type CAD tool doing exactly that.
There is a really ugly gap between small CAD, low complexity, and major efforts involving a lot of integrated systems.
Design reuse in this space holds a lot of value potential. It absolutely will not displace high end, real CAD (Siemens, Dassault), but could very well dominate a lot of the market, should it end up out there, possible for mortals to use, etc...
On a vendor specific note, Auto desk finally sees this and is building some nice stuff. They may be like AMD, always a bit behind for failing to build when others did, but maybe not. We shall see over the next 10 years.
The position of drafter or CAD jockey is on the decline. CAD will eventually settle into something most people can and want to do.
Maybe reaching that point will also mean enough days and expertise being captured to take steps in the direction you find appealing. It's gonna be a bit of a wait...
- brudgers 11y agoThe AEC side is limited by economics. An architect's business is one project at a time. Landing and completing a project only has indirect long term value as marketing. Everything is a one off because every piece of land is unique if for no other reason. Or more realistically, when the client doesn't pay but says, "but you've still got the design" it misses the fact that AEC designs have no value for some other site. It isn't that AEC is full of idiots that can learn from the world of product engineering. The circumstances are radically different because real-property is different from chattels and goods. Anyway, relative to a multi-core CPU, buildings are dumb simple. And people in the loop makes the hard part of projects, managing and coordinating humans, worse. In particular because piece work means that success equates to a backlog. So each person has one and backlogs are not conducive to quick response to changes or commitment to deadlines.
- ddingus 11y agoIndeed. However, it's my observation that a very significant economic gain is there to be had with a better, up front investment. Not just drawings and models. Intent. It's entirely possible to package up a ton of stuff that can be used to assemble a project, and when that's done, those packages can drive all the info needed by the contractors each day, if desired. This technique was applied to a major airport we probably both know, and it was done on mechanical CAD for those reasons. The bid was more accurate, and the project ran much closer to on time and on materials. Buildings are sort of dumb and sort of simple too. Of course, in the one time, forward create kind of way, sure. It's just a pile of simple geometry. On the other hand, if one actually wants to move up a level, add intent, build in design rule checks, etc... suddenly, you've got a class of buildings possible, those buildings largely derived from set pieces, with the real design effort being more centered on the unique aspects of a given site. Couple this with a bid process that is driven off that same intent, and doing prospective designs starts to change. Not only do they get a realistic idea of the design outcome, but they get bids, materials, etc... that are closer to real, and derived from a team with a history of doing that. I never classified anyone as idiots. I see it more like being too conservative. Happens in mechanical spaces too. It's just process pieces that are laying around waiting for people to make better use of them. Many are fat 'n happy, so they don't. Others, particularly in the strategic project space, really are looking for better ways to get things done, and done on time and on budget. Real property has it's own set of requirements to deal with, but in the end, they are just requirements. Employing more of what the tools can do really can have an impact. I've been a part of a couple of those, and the results were pretty impressive. Coordinating those humans, once you've got a dataset that is live, real time, able to iterate based on variances that just happen with property, doesn't look a whole lot different from that same process in the product space. Manufacturing, and the product space in general, struggles with this same thing, and there have been significant improvements in overall communications in the last 10 years that are just now really starting to see wider use. All electronic shops are here now. 10 years ago, there were a few, and some concept places, but most everybody was slogging through the piles of paper and high latency, high labor means and methods. Ugly stuff. Today, it's possible for a CAD dataset to drive all of it. And parts of that are still ugly, but improving. AEC can do this too. Again, it's being done by a few progressive groups out there, and that's direct experience. I happened to be one of the Mechanical CAD guys willing to work with them and translate techniques, and understand their scenario, language, requirements, etc... Hey, this also ties in with boats... So, when a yacht gets made, it's custom. They do ungodly hacks during actual construction. The less up front planning and visualization work they do, the more hacks there are. "Just make it fit, and send the result back to engineering..." Fine. Each boat ships with a document set that basically attempts to detail what happened and why. Tons of books. One artifact of the CAD process was planning more of those hacks away. Another was packaging up core bits where intent can be well defined. And the docs were derived from all that, then more lightly marked up. All electronic, with a paper back up, just because the sea. The sea is toxic. But, it cost a lot less to do just a little bit more up front. Forward 5-6 years, I ended up in a scenario where it worked the same way with a building. (I have a dataset of a library in SF that I helped figure out how to work on.) They got their site study docs, and then drove the CAD from there, building in options, expressing intent, etc... On the prospect walk through, they were able to make real time changes and sell that deal. Potent stuff. I heard a lot about "client didn't pay" and being able to work directly with them, real time, can change that equation. And each project, sold or not, does produce a lot of great stuff that can be used on future ones too. One example might be that parking garage I mentioned. Property varies a lot. However, it is possible to build a parking structure with a lot of flexibility and design rule checks that can fit into a lot of scenarios. Worst case, it's an 80 percent basis, for the 20 percent real work of dealing with that particular site. When site construction began, a computer went to live there and all the coordination, handling of problems, documenting variances, distribution of materials, measure, etc... happened on it. Sometimes drawings got output, maybe for the more device toxic tasks (and that gets tossed when work is done), and a lot of people read 3D data and worked from it directly on a laptop or pad. Walk on site, pull up model, expose the relevant bits, compare, measure, do. When the building is done? Computer stays there. It's the living record of the thing. Employing these means can yield the ability for doing more than one project at a time too, or at the least, more projects, faster, with fewer people. Right now, cars, airplanes and other big things also have those living records too. What I'm trying to get at here is the clusterfuck of CAD (and it's often just that) has a lot to do with how connected and fluid and accessible the data is to people. When the people can work from the data, and that data is derived from the model and the intent in that model, a whole lot of that clusterfuck goes away. I think, after having this very interesting chat, the desire to realize a more compute oriented approach has some elements in common with just making the CAD more widely and directly usable by most people, not just CAD people.