5 ms·
I suppose you could do that, though given the nature of medical records, keeping everything locked up so tightly that only the (potentially impaired) patient ca
by Silhouette 11y ago
I suppose you could do that, though given the nature of medical records, keeping everything locked up so tightly that only the (potentially impaired) patient can give access seems unwise.
I was more thinking that those organisations who do process medical records on your behalf -- your doctor, hospital, etc. -- could and should take steps to prevent the often very large number of staff they have from accessing an individual's records without proper authorisation. This would limit the ability for anything sensitive to be accessed by anyone without a reasonable clinical need for it or to be readily transferred to other systems, as well as creating a robust audit trail of access to sensitive data as well.
- mikeash 11y agoThat sort of system isn't DRM. Limiting access to data is just regular access control, which is common and works decently well. The unique thing about DRM is that it provides access to data but attempts to limit what you can do with that access, for example allowing you to view it only on certain devices. That's much harder and less useful. I can see how it could help prevent bad actors from causing trouble here, but it's secondary to having proper access control.
- Silhouette 11y agoThe unique thing about DRM is that it provides access to data but attempts to limit what you can do with that access, for example allowing you to view it only on certain devices. And that sort of thing is what I'm talking about. There are numerous applications where someone has a legitimate need to access certain data under certain conditions and for certain purposes, yet that same person does not need and should not have the ability to do other things with the same data. And if you think that's not useful, I would remind you that a very substantial proportion of all white collar crime is based on inside jobs.
- JupiterMoon 11y agoSo you mean what happens already in sensible systems?
- Silhouette 11y agoYou'd think so, but unfortunately many, many systems that deal with sensitive data are not "sensible". Just look at the leaks from some of the most security conscious organisations in the world in recent years.
- icebraining 11y agoI was more thinking that those organisations who do process medical records on your behalf -- your doctor, hospital, etc. -- could and should take steps to prevent the often very large number of staff they have from accessing an individual's records without proper authorisation But that's not DRM! That's regular access control! The whole idea behind DRM is to control what users who are allowed to access the content can do with it. Otherwise, even UNIX file permissions would be DRM.
- Silhouette 11y agoPreventing access at all is regular access control. The technologies that let someone access the data from their PC at the hospital but not, for example, save a copy to a USB stick, are much closer to what others use for DRM purposes.
- mikeash 11y agoThe best technology to prevent copying data to a USB stick isn't DRM, it's epoxy. (Or, for a more mundane approach, disabling USB storage devices at the OS level.)
- Silhouette 11y agoWhat happens in your version when someone needs to get data onto their system from a USB stick?
- mikeash 11y agoThat shouldn't ever be necessary. Why does a medical records system need information loaded from USB sticks by random workers? Edit: if it is for some reason necessary, it's actually easy to allow. Have separate "import" computers set up with accessible USB ports and write-only access to the system.
- Silhouette 11y ago