Yes, that was deliberate. You objected to ethanbond's comment because you regarded it as straw man example. I restated ethanbond's objection to show real-world

Yes, that was deliberate. You objected to ethanbond's comment because you regarded it as straw man example. I restated ethanbond's objection to show real-world examples where your statement "When people say it must all be X and not Y, you can bet that there's a sweet spot between X and Y" does not apply. Therefore, it is not a strong rule for inductive logic, which is our point.