4 ms·
Why do you think that inequality is driven by the Laffer curve? (I'm not a fan of laffer curve arguments either) Prior to 1920 there was basically zero income
by dnautics 11y ago
Why do you think that inequality is driven by the Laffer curve? (I'm not a fan of laffer curve arguments either) Prior to 1920 there was basically zero income tax, and it's hard to argue that in the preceding era, especially 1850-1920, inequality was on the rise. Hell, one segment of the population OWNED another segment of the population.
If you ask me, inequality is generated by the regressive theft of wealth from the poorest segment of the population by a state-run policy of increasing the cost of living. This artificial increase also drives the middle class into various forms of asset-based investment which effectively socialize corporate risk, while disproportionate amount of the gains go to the "capitalist" classes.
- danmaz74 11y agoJust to clarify: I don't think that "inequality is driven by the Laffer curve". But I do think that lower and lower taxation on the rich since Reaganomics has greatly contributed to the growth of inequality; thus the (joking) reference to Laffer. Also to clarify, I'm against punishing marginal rates like there were at some point also in the USA, but also find crazy that Buffet's secretary pays a higher rate than Buffet's.
- dnautics 11y agoTaxation on the rich doesn't change inequality very much, after all, its effects are linear. What's the difference between 1 billion and 1.2 billion? Look to see where there are compounding effects. Taxes on the rich have increased since Obama has come into the presidency, and yet income inequality still rises.
- beat 11y agoTaxes on the rich have changed very little since Obama took office. During the 2012 election, one of the things that eventually came out was Mitt Romney's effective tax rate - 14%. This is less than half the effective tax rate of my own upper middle class family that earned 1/100 as much in the same year. Not much has changed since then. This is a big problem.
- dnautics 11y agowhy is this a big problem? And why is 'not taking from the rich' a bigger problem than 'actively stealing from the poor'?
- beat 11y agoIt's a social justice issue. Why does a very, very rich person like Mitt Romney pay far less in taxes than the middle class (or even the poor)?
- dnautics 11y agoI am pretty sure that Mitt Romney paid more taxes than most people in this country. He certainly paid far more than me. Could you please give a concrete definition of 'social justice'? How do we know when we have achieved it, and what benchmarks do we have for accountability on those matters. Also, who gets to set these benchmarks?
- beat 11y agoI'm not going to debate the meaning of "social justice" with you, because I suspect you'll just keep moving goalposts. That said, fairness matters. Taxes as a percentage of income should be, at bare minimum, flat. It's generally accepted that they should be progressive - that the wealthy should pay a greater percentage than the poor, because they are more able to afford it, and because the high-velocity money of the poor and middle class boosts economic growth more than the low-velocity money of the rich. So when someone as wealthy as Mitt Romney is paying less than half the effective tax rate of people who actually have to work for a living, it's unfair. And this tax break to someone so rich - a break of well over a million dollars - has to be made up by the taxes of others. His cut increases the tax rate on hundreds of working families. That's terrible social policy.
- randcraw 11y ago??? I't VERY hard to argue that inequality wasn't on the rise in America between 1850 and 1920. Why did unions first arise ca. 1910? Why did the progressives and antitrust policies also start then? Indeed, 1850 to 1920 was the heyday of robber barons and the worst corporate excesses in America. With the new century, it soon became evident to everyone that economic inequalities were wildly out of control and something had to be done. Not unlike the rising tides of Trump and Sanders in 2016... As to the end of human ownership as a benchmark for the rise of equality... in practice, the Civil War did little to end the inequalities that arose from slavery in America. Jim Crow reigned in America for another hundred years, at least.
- dnautics 11y agoYou're making assertions without any evidence. There are other reasons why progressive policies took hold, as in, basic awareness of alternatives to social inequality due to a decrease of it in general. It's not like a plutocratic equivalent of "robber barons" did not exist prior, they were just aristocrats, and so their theft of capital from the lower classes was accepted as a social norm, a part of the "social contract", if you will. If you look at economic indicators, you will find the numbers do not support your assertions. The best compiled data on this can be found in Schumpeter's "Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy" - income inequality in the US was relatively static if not improving over this time period, and this is in spite of also receiving many many economic refugees from abroad in several waves of immigration.
- bobwaycott 11y ago> There are other reasons why progressive policies took hold, as in, basic awareness of alternatives to social inequality due to a decrease of it in general. You cannot be serious. Progressive policies did not emerge in late-19th-century America, much less take hold, because there was a decrease in social inequality in general. This is the exact opposite of what the historical record shows us. Progressive policies emerged out of an increasingly wider recognition of social, political, and economic inequalities nationwide in the latter 19th century. This is what prompted farmers to band together with the labor movement to fight the railroads and banks, movements that were inherently critical of capitalism itself, and not just inequality of condition or remuneration. It wasn't a decrease in social inequality that fueled the drive for expanding suffrage. I simply cannot understand how one can hand-wave progressive achievements away when each of them were, sometimes violently, fought for and only secured after years, sometimes decades, of effort. America has been very reliable in making people work very hard to gain equality. > It's not like a plutocratic equivalent of "robber barons" did not exist prior, they were just aristocrats, and so their theft of capital from the lower classes was accepted as a social norm, a part of the "social contract", if you will. I'm beginning to wonder if you've studied much history at all. In what periods of modern history have aristocrats and "their theft of capital from the lower classes" been "accepted as a social norm, a part of the 'social contract'..."? Definitely not much since the 17th century in many Western nations. And always shakily before then, requiring either a balancing act on behalf of the aristocrats, or blatant displays and threats of force to protect it. Even when it wasn't subject to outright rebellion against its existence, it has always been a problem, and never been simply accepted. > If you look at economic indicators, you will find the numbers do not support your assertions. The best compiled data on this can be found in Schumpeter's "Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy" - income inequality in the US was relatively static if not improving over this time period... This is absolutely false. There are a plethora of historians and economists one can read further to understand these historical trends--Claudia Goldin, Thomas Piketty, Emmanuel Saez, Robert Margo, Simon Kuznets, Wojciech Kopczuk, Tony Judt, and many more. Until the interwar decades of the 20th century, income inequality was shown, as far back as a century, to have done little but rise. It's not even a fact disputed by any serious economist or historian of the period.
- bobwaycott 11y agoYour arguments in this thread seem to be a bit all over the place, and not entirely cogent with regard to what specifically you are attempting to say. It sounds like in this comment and others further down-thread, that you're suggesting there was not an increase in economic inequality prior to 1920. This is nonsense. > Prior to 1920 there was basically zero income tax, and it's hard to argue that in the preceding era, especially 1850-1920, inequality was on the rise. Hell, one segment of the population OWNED another segment of the population. First off, just in your chosen period of 1850-1920, slavery only existed for 15 of those 70 years. I don't think it has anything at all to do with evaluating the state of income inequality in the period--except to have drastically increased its relative levels when the whole of enslaved Americans were made free and joined the ranks of the working masses. What happened after 1865 is an indisputably clear narrative of the newly recognized widening gulf between the wealthy and the masses, elevated to the national stage as a critically important civic conversation. Given the history of the post-Civil-War to pre-WWII era, it is really not difficult at all to argue that inequality was rising--and widely recognize as such. In fact, suggesting that it wasn't is almost laughably ignorant of the period's history. The increased wealth of pre- and early-industrial capitalists was widely acknowledged at the time to have deleterious effects on social, political, and economic spheres. It was overwhelmingly part of the national dialogue, and fed into the rise of populist movements, social and political agitation, establishment and positive public reception of unions among the working class, political campaigns, local political machinery manipulations, and so much more. The gulf that separated the wealthy from the masses between the Civil War and WWI was a big fucking deal. This inequality of economic conditions, and the resulting power imbalances, along with the ability to purchase and maneuver the state and national forces to protect capitalist interests led to riots in the streets, creation of new political parties, and overwhelmingly massive changes to the social, economic, and political landscape during this period. I know of no historians of America since 1850-1950 who would, even in jest, suggest income inequality in the late-19th and early-20th century did anything but rise. The only exception to this widely recognized and documented state of affairs occurs after 1918--a notable decrease in the interwar period, a marked plummeting during WWII, a steadying greater equality in the post-war decades, until inequality began rising again in the 1970s. Hell, I'm actually amazed that anyone seriously disputes any of this. It's American history 101--a constant, meandering power struggle between the wealthy and everyone else. This has been a staple of American political, social, and economic life since colonial times. We have, as a nation, had this argument before ... many times.