51 ms·
Hacking inclusion by customizing a Slack bot
- placeybordeaux 11y ago> This ensures that every person feels comfortable to be themselves at work, and it improves the quality of work our team produces. Interesting thesis, has this turned out to be true? An okay (not great) way to test this would be to only turn that on in certain channels.
- js2 11y agoI am sensitive to this and never use "guys" when sending an email. So you can imagine my surprise a few years back when I overheard a female teenage soccer player address her female teammates during a scrimmage with "hey guys...". edit: just asked my 14 y/o (going on 30) daughter. She regularly uses "guys" to address her girl friends and went so far as saying "what am I supposed to call them? Gals? Girls? That sounds wierd." edit 2: wife states she'd use "guys" to address a group of women. Background: raised in Miami by northern parents, currently residing in NC. Wife raised all over (airforce brat). I'm not immune to using "y'all," but "all y'all" is a bridge too far.
- ivl 11y agoI was going to say, I've seen it used as a casual alternative to people so much that I consider it a fairly inclusive term. Then again, it may be a regional thing, where it wouldn't be seen as such if it's not commonplace.
- petercooper 11y agoIt's very common here in the UK to use "guys" with zero connotation of gender. My daughter's gymnastics teachers (an entirely female class) uses it, my daughter's dancing teacher (ditto), my wife with my two daughters, my female employees with our group as a whole.. I veer towards "folks" to play it safe and in respect of people I know who feel strongly about it, but it's quite a modern American concern in my experience. I find "gang" an odd alternative to suggest in language delicate contexts (i.e. where "guys" is already causing offense) considering it relates to crime.
- britta 11y ago"Guys" as a fairly neutral term for a mixed-gender group of people or group of women is a very very informal usage; it makes sense that a group of really close friends might choose to use it with each other in a casual and affectionate way. The idea of the bot is to be mindful of gendered language when talking to your coworkers in your workplace, which is a different and slightly more formal context.
- js2 11y agoNo disagreement there.
- mgraczyk 11y agoMaybe it's a regional thing, but I certainly don't consider "guys" to be gender specific. If I were talking about a group of exclusively males, I would say "boys" or "men".
- archimedespi 11y agoOr, in some regions and in colloquial conversation with a group of male friends, "dudes".
- pshaw 11y agoI heard three young women refer to each other as "dude" in the Portland airport a week ago. It seems to be a generational thing.
- lfowles 11y agoIt's interesting, I don't consider it gender specific either, but it does sound more fitting when directed at an all male group or to single out the males in a mixed-gender group.
- trynumber9 11y agoThis is stupid to people from the Midwest. We've been using "you guys" as the plural of you for quite some time and, in the examples listed, most of us would say it has no gender.
- archimedespi 11y agoInterestingly enough, people tend to think that "guys" as referring to a group is gender-neutral: http://jvns.ca/blog/2013/12/27/guys-guys-guys/ http://jvns.ca/blog/2013/12/27/guys-guys-guys/. disclaimer: this is probably skewed by the particular cohort that Julia Evans was able to survey.
- douglance 11y agoHow is publicly shaming someone for using a colloquial term inclusive?
- Buetol 11y agoWould be more efficient as a private message from the bot: No public shaming, no noise.
- pionar 11y agoInterestingly enough, if you look up guy in a dictionary[0], definition #2 is: > Usually, guys. Informal. persons of either sex; people: > Could one of you guys help me with this? My former (female) boss used to address the mixed-gender team as guys quite often. [0]http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/guy http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/guy
- kruffin 11y agoAs an additional data point, a former client (female) addressed our mixed-gender team as gals. This is something the article explicitly calls out as taboo. It didn't bother me (male) at all nor did it seem to alienate anyone on the team. Disclaimer: I use "guys" as mixed gender a lot and this slack bot would really piss me off; the opposite of "valuing, respecting, and supporting the needs of every individual".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- brandonmenc 11y agoJust about every single female I know uses "guys" gender-neutrally. Most insidious.
- pixelkicker 11y agoThese guys are wasting taxpayer dollars.
- wslack 11y agoI work at 18F, but am speaking for myself. It takes about a minute to add a Slackbot response, and posting the article helps us attract better candidates by showing our commitment to a good working environment.
- kookiekrak 11y agoI would argue that this article may actually harm your efforts at attracting better candidates. The slackbot responses are equivalent to public shaming for using a widely accepted gender neutral phrase to address a group of people. This makes 18F seem like a highly PC environment to work in.
- JBReefer 11y agoYeah, I would never work there after reading this. This makes it look like a place where passive-aggressively policing behavior is common. I'm not even one to say racist or do sexist things! This just smells ... bitchy I guess?
- wslack 11y agoI appreciate the feedback, and I don't consider 18F to be "highly PC" (at least to other places I've worked). I guess personally, while "guys" is a common term, it doesn't seem like a truly gender neutral phrase - I wouldn't ever call a woman a "guy," so why would the plural work? In reading further about this just now, one interesting note is that "guy" is not neutral, and "guys" in the 3rd person is not neutral, but "you guys" (the second person) is used more generally. Here are some links: http://english.stackexchange.com/questions/11816/is-guy-gender-neutral http://english.stackexchange.com/questions/11816/is-guy-gend... https://www.quora.com/Is-the-word-guys-gender-neutral https://www.quora.com/Is-the-word-guys-gender-neutral http://www.economist.com/blogs/johnson/2012/10/slang http://www.economist.com/blogs/johnson/2012/10/slang https://www.reddit.com/r/genderqueer/comments/2kr0m0/is_the_phrase_you_guys_genderneutral_xpost/clnww2v https://www.reddit.com/r/genderqueer/comments/2kr0m0/is_the_...
- nitsky 11y agorobots enforcing political correctness. scary.
- JBReefer 11y agoGovernment built robots, at that
- jamescun 11y agoI would say it is an inclusive term, and in my experience, used frequently as such by people of all genders. There is a lot that can be done in tech to progress towards gender inclusivity, however publicly calling out use of words which historically conveyed exclusivity yet nomoreso detracts from more effective means.
- farnsworth 11y agoSpecifics about 'guys' aside, I like the idea, and there's a library that would probably help to implement more rules - http://alexjs.com/ http://alexjs.com/. There are a few text editor plugins using this library to basically lint your document with suggestions like using 'their' instead of 'his' in ambiguous situations and so on.
- redwards510 11y agoWhen I was a teenager back in the 90s, one of the first people I met online was a bulimic girl from Indiana with a distorted view of her body. I was interested in programming and taught myself to write scripts for the Windows IRC client mIRC. She would constantly mention how "fat" she thought she was. I would always dutifully respond "No, you aren't fat", naively thinking that might help her condition. One day I decided to automate this process. I created an event handler when the word "fat" was said that would perform /msg $$1 "no, you aren't fat". However, I failed to add a variable delay in seconds, so it was quickly obvious to her that it was automated. She was a smart woman, so she wrote a simple loop like: while(1) { /msg redwards510 fat } and executed it. This would cause us both to instantly get disconnected due to "Excess Flood". I decided to disable it after that.
- placeybordeaux 11y agoI am strongly in favor of switching over to y'all, but then again I came from the south.
- throwaway999888 11y agoI would find such a bot REALLY annoying. And I have a hard time imagining how others would not, unless they had already tried to put themselves on a guy-less diet. Since this is a post about "how we work", I would imagine that I would initially get really annoyed, and then be reminded by how it is just a front for social pressure from colleagues/higher-ups. Then when someone asks about how such a reminder has been working for me, I'd just say Great! Really kept me on my toes, such an effective reminder. ... Not that I even use "guys" that much in any case (or English in daily life!).
- a_puppy 11y agoThis is mostly about social signalling. The presence of the bot conspicuously telling people not to use the term "guys" signals to both men and women on the team that influential people on the team are feminist. So what matters isn't whether or not "guys" is technically a valid term for a mixed-gender group; what matters is that the ban on "guys" will be interpreted as feminist.
- bobthechef 11y agoYou see, some people are so small and have nothing more important going on in their lives, they engage in activities such as these. Nevermind that the author fails to grasp that guys is not necessarily of masculine gender, much like the pronoun "he" as in "he who...", or "man" as in "man is an animal that...". You may as well get worked up over the recent singular "they". I mean, I'm an individual, not a "we", so I take offense (grammatically, I do dislike singular they, but that's a grammatical quip not a seething ideological piece of nonsense).
- DanBC 11y ago> recent It's not recent.
- dang 11y ago> some people are so small and have nothing more important going on in their lives, they engage in activities such as these. Personal attacks break the HN guidelines, which require you to post civilly and substantively or not at all. Please (re-)read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html and do not do this again. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10912417 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10912417 and marked it off-topic.