3 ms·
What if your email correspondence from companies was entirely handled through DRM that you controlled? What if you could revoke the right for a company to use y
by stcredzero 11y ago
What if your email correspondence from companies was entirely handled through DRM that you controlled? What if you could revoke the right for a company to use your email? Basically, if such infrastructure were widespread, no company would actually have your email, unless they were to circumvent the DRM. Furthermore, such circumvention would then be covered under the DMCA, and mass circumvention would open up companies to class action lawsuits. (If properly implemented, either lawbreakers could be tracked, or the company that let the protected address fall into the wrong hands would be identified.)
You could not say that such a circumstance would be unfavorable. Typically, people come up with an argument saying that DRM doesn't work, and that such tools wouldn't be available in a true and trustworthy form to individuals anyhow.
Also, email isn't such a great example anymore, but having such control over one's medical records would be desirable.
- mikeash 11y agoWhat you describe would be way easier to implement by handing out unique tokens to each company, and then revoking tokens on my end. You can even do that right now by using a catch-all address, or the pretty common username+companynameandwhatever@example.com technique.
- stcredzero 11y agoI do say that email isn't such a good example anymore. Medical records would be a better example. But such tokens would be included in DRM protected addresses, and their circumvention harder to deny. (Tokens by themselves are deniable.)
- bad_user 11y agoFirst of all, you're talking about a doubly edged knife. You wouldn't "actually have" the received email either. Now imagine you're sexually harassed or blackmailed, but couldn't prove it, because your email vanishes just after you've read it. But more problematic is that you're forgetting about the analogue loophole. As long as I can take a photo of your crappy email, you only have the illusion of safety. Add to that the fact that currently there is no such thing as unbreakable DRM, mostly because it's a fundamentally flawed concept that can't work. DRM is security theater at best. > having such control over one's medical records would be desirable One thing that always bothered me is that programmers have the arrogance to think that technology can fix a broken society. Given that DRM is a broken concept, it wouldn't stop global adversaries like the NSA from mining your medical records. And then when your insurance company demands whatever records they want to do however they please, including selling that data to the highest bidder, threatening to reject your contract or claim, good luck explaining them about DRM and control.
- stcredzero 11y agoYou wouldn't "actually have" the received email either. That's a straw man. The contents of communication would be proof from repudiation, but permission to send would be subject to revocation. Given that DRM is a broken concept, it wouldn't stop global adversaries like the NSA from mining your medical records. Begging the question. Our experience so far of DRM is broken. And there are plenty of adversaries below the capability of the NSA people need protection from.
- icebraining 11y agoBegging the question. Our experience so far of DRM is broken. No, DRM as a concept is broken. The whole idea rests on giving someone the encrypted content and the key to decrypted, while obfuscating the way the two are combined in a machine the user controls. That's why most DRM has been broken, often mere days after release, despite the many millions buried in its development.
- snuxoll 11y agoThis is really less useful of an example than say, medical records. With AD RMS I can ensure every document floating through an organization is protected with RMS, allowing only users with the proper permission access to the document. If someone tries to be sneaky and exfiltrate PHI out of the network it is useless, since nobody outside of the organization can open the file even if they have it. I can also revoke access to specific individuals or groups of people, so even if they had access at one point they can't use it any more. DRM for documents is more about preventing sensitive data from escaping than it is securing communications between parties. The analog loophole always exists, mind you, so it still only makes life more difficult - but it does prevent mass transmission to a large extent.