11 ms·
As someone with an economics background, I'm surprised you think the biggest problem is the statelessness of Bitcoin. The biggest economic problem to me has al
by slg 11y ago
As someone with an economics background, I'm surprised you think the biggest problem is the statelessness of Bitcoin. The biggest economic problem to me has always been an unintelligent control of the money supply. You can criticize some of the actions that many central banks do to manipulate the economy, but I have a hard time buying the answer to bad management is no management.
- supster 11y agoThe money supply is fixed to 21 million. Fortunately, the coins are basically infinitely divisible, so as the coins become more valuable (assuming over the long run that coins are used for larger and larger amounts of commerce rather than speculation), small transactions simply happen at smaller units. In other words the system is steadily deflationary instead of the highly volatile inflationary system we currently have with fiat currencies.
- Hupriene 11y agoThe theoretical maximum money supply is 21 million. The actual amount of money in circulation can still vary wildly as keys to wallets containing bitcoins are lost (resulting in a permanent reduction of the maximum money supply) and as speculators cash out (resulting in a temporary increase in the effective money supply).
- dragontamer 11y agoMore importantly however, is the rent-seeking by BTC enthusiasts. BTC hoarders don't "deserve" any more wealth than later adopters, and yet wish to create wealth from nothingness and basically a giant Ponzi scheme. At least with stocks and companies, the stock actually means something: typically a vote for the board, or access to a dividend.
- Freak_NL 11y agoIt seems strange to consider a currency as a viable alternative for other currencies, when a sizeable chunk of the total available sum of it is owned by a single person or group simply because they came up with the system, and another large part is in the hands of speculators. There is nothing fair about a currency that is so volatile in value by design and is essentially speculative in nature. It is sad to see that this side of Bitcoin is not stressed more often.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoYou literally described the US dollar, maybe every currency.
- dragontamer 11y agoActually the US Dollar is inflationary, which means those who hoard US Dollars lose out in the long term. You lose approximately 2% to 3% depending on how well the Fed actually hits its benchmarks. BTC on the other hand is inflationary, due to the (artificial) cap of 21 Million BTC. In any case, inflationary vs deflationary is a moot point. Too much of either side is bad. The important part is price consistency, which everyone can agree is relatively fair. 2% to 3% inflation (loss of value) is much more consistent than anything that BTC has accomplished... with wild swings of 100% to 1000% on some years. ------ I'm intrigued by DOGEcoin, explicitly because it adopts an inflationary model with infinite supply. I think that sort of model is more fair in the long term, and certainly more fun.
- bdhiehihhd 11y agoYeah, people don't hoard us dollars, they hoard T bills and other obfuscated forms of us dollar debt.
- dragontamer 11y agoConsidering that T-Bills have a return of 0.2% right now, that still loses to inflation. IE: If you actually want to make money, you have to go equities or start up a company.
- pbreit 11y agoWhen it comes to volatility, bitcoin is at one end of the spectrum and every other currency at the other.
- bdhiehihhd 11y agoThis is an ignorant view. Bitcoin is tiny, its measured in billions. How much did the Canadian currency just lose in the last view weeks? That amounts to hundreds of billions of vaporized wealth.
- saalweachter 11y ago> How much did the Canadian currency just lose in the last [few] weeks? Huh, that is a really interesting question. It's not as trivial to calculate as it is for Bitcoin, where you can multiply the moneys held by the change in exchange rate -- essentially no prices as denominated in BTC, while most prices most Canadians deal with are denominated in CAD. For most Canadians, the ratio of their income and rent or groceries will stay the same, so in some senses they haven't lost anything. But the price they pay for imports, like computers and oranges, will go up, so they have definitely lost something. I wonder what the balance comes out to.
- esun 11y agoMany domestic products become more expensive as the currency adjusts downwards as producers take advantage of higher foreign prices. In the long run, this can depress foreign prices and even increase manufacturing demand here due to lower labour costs. But these changes don't happen overnight.
- pbreit 11y agoThat is an ignorant view. Percentage matters much more than absolute when it comes to currency.
- iSnow 11y agoThe Canadian Dollar lost about 5% over the last weeks. That's about as much as BTC wins or loses on a single lucky or bad ay.
- kobayashi 11y agoIf BTC become more valuable, then how is that deflationary?
- rsutphin 11y agoThe thing being inflated in inflation is prices. If a currency becomes more valuable, things cost less in that currency. An appreciating currency leads to deflation, all else being equal. (This assumes you are treating BTC as a currency, which appears to be the OP's intent.)
- kobayashi 11y agoOh right, of course. Inflation means that the value of currency becomes less valuable. Just a brain fart on my part. Thanks!
- gavazzy 11y agoIt's all about trade-offs. Bitcoin may have trouble competing against a "stable" currency like USD or EUR, but would have a huge benefit over a heavily manipulated one like in Venezuela, where inflation sits at ~60%. If Bitcoin could become stable, then it would offer the freedom of converting wages into a more stable form. A Venezuelan would expect the purchasing power of today's wages to be 4% lower in just one month!
- supster 11y agoExactly, this is why the stateless-ness is such a drawback to adoption. Because Venezuelan gov't knows that its people would prefer to transact in a more stable currency and try to convert from the bolívar to btc. And the gov't will try to do everything in its power to prevent the exchanges from happening.
- jsprogrammer 11y ago>You can criticize some of the actions that many central banks do to manipulate the economy, but I have a hard time buying the answer to bad management is no management. Why is active, central, management necessary? >The biggest economic problem to me has always been an unintelligent control of the money supply. The Bitcoin paper [0] lays down the rules of control and many have been able to follow it; In what way is that unintelligent? [0] https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
- rhino369 11y agoBecause it ignores the velocity of money and total amount of transactions. If the USA suddenly adopted bitcoin as the official currency, you would see insane deflation. If people stopped using bitcoin as much, you'd see strong inflation. Central banks manipulate money supply to keep prices steady. That's why I can sign a loan for a house in dollars. But you would be insane to sign a loan for a house in bitcoin. The federal reserve will keep inflation from 0-2%. We can count on it. Bitcoin who knows.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoWhy would I need to sign a loan for a house in Bitcoin? With Bitcoin I can just buy the house outright. Debt currencies are used for signing loans. Anyway, there is probably a way to add an inflation metric over the blockchain based on it's length (or #transactions, or avg. transaction value, etc.), where some value equivalence can be drawn between older coins and newer coins, if it's really desired.
- AndrewKemendo 11y ago>I'm surprised you think the biggest problem is the statelessness of Bitcoin. In fact it's the opposite I think that's its biggest strength. If no one else sees it that way however, then it will not live up to it's potential because there is no reason for them to move over to it. Adopting bitcoin is a political decision because money is as equally political as it is economic. It's super complex because the vast majority of people have no clue the power and complexity that sits behind the money they hold in their hands. They just see it as the next bag of groceries, or electricity payment.
- maaku 11y agoI can assure you the Bitcoin Core developers see it the same way as you. But it seems that view is not universal among the userbase.
- slg 11y agoI can understand your argument that it might be a strength of the idea behind Bitcoin (I personally disagree), but I believe it becomes a clear weakness because it is such an impediment to wide scale adoption. A system can have a great theory behind it, but it is nothing more than a good thought experiment if a real world implementation is impossible
- bduerst 11y agoExactly. The Fed or CBRC may not be perfect with their policies, but at least they're beneficially aligned with the future and stability of their currency (rather than a group of rational self-interested actors).
- dnautics 11y ago"they're beneficially aligned with the future" how's that divide between the rich and poor going? The fed has been upwardly redistributing wealth especially dramatically for the last 40 years since when the Nixon closed the gold window. I suppose if you think creating a kleptocratic state is beneficial for the future, then your statement rings true.
- bdhiehihhd 11y agoIt's amazing the amount shit people will write about government, either they are a shill or brain dead.
- iSnow 11y agoHuh, the rich/poor divide in bitcoinland is way worse than in the real world, so I am not sure which point you are trying to make.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pjojojje 11y agoI honestly have no clue how someone can claim to be schooled in economics and yet be so wrong. Have you been hiding away for the last 7 years? There are so many objections to central banks its difficult to know where to start, but just one question, you truly believe any group is capable of making gross monetary decisions that affect billions of people didn't we go with capitalism because markets beat kings?