7 ms·
I've enjoyed watching the Bitcoin experiment. It's been enlightening in a variety of ways, from technically to socially. I've been fascinated and appalled in e
by Nursie 11y ago
I've enjoyed watching the Bitcoin experiment. It's been enlightening in a variety of ways, from technically to socially.
I've been fascinated and appalled in equal measure at the fanboy community, at the intolerance of criticism that sprang up very quickly, and how strong feelings ran (likely because of financial investment in the tech).
It's also been interesting watching it go from simple CPU mining, to multiple GPU rigs in dorm rooms, all the way through FPGA and then to massive installations of custom ASIC miners.
But I've always hoped it wouldn't go mainstream for two reasons - limited supply with weighting in favour of early adopters, and the massive electricity costs of the 'mining' and transaction validation process. Scalable, competitive proof of work systems for a widespread currency are an ecological disaster in the making, and deflationary currency with a handful of early users controlling a huge proportion of the total currency supply... these aren't "features".
I'll be very interested in what happens next, and for the reasons given I hope it's not just a BTC clone with better governance.
- koheripbal 11y agoThe root problem with Bitcoin isn't the program, it's the money supply equation. Deflationary currencies fail exactly because they are too volatile, which is the anti-thesis of designing a currency to be held as an asset. Imagine currency like the oil in an engine. Someone needs to create a coin that rewards mining by giving them futures contracts on the currency and still deflating it.
- return0 11y agoI 'll also notice what the whole experiment proved: That money can perverse moral incentives. The electricity/wasted energy issue you mention is just one of them. The amount of time spent on building and specializing the hardware is another. All this was in the hope of the abstract goal of creating money, not wealth. People weren't so zealous in building specialized hardware for, say, protein folding. Bitcoin advocates usually put forward "the good of humanity" argument, yet the product by design puts individual interests above all other interests.
- nebw 11y agoIn that vein, I'd like to point out Gridcoin[1], a crypto-currency that rewards you for throwing your computing power at a BOINC project (basically scientific data crunching) [2] instead of wasting it on pointlessly solving crypto problems. It's certainly not perfect, but an interessting idea nonetheless. [1] http://gridcoin.us/ http://gridcoin.us/ [2] http://boinc.berkeley.edu/ http://boinc.berkeley.edu/
- Nursie 11y agoThat's quite cool, I like that idea a lot more. I think I'd still rather a currency that didn't rely on burning power as fast as possible, but using that power for good is, well, good :)
- STRML 11y agoWell, there needs to be some proof of work, something that is hard to do at scale but easy for individuals. To that degree, Bitcoin has failed, because massive SHA256 crunching is now easy to do at scale and hard for individuals. More varied challenges, like BOINC, or PoW that is bandwidth, connectivity, latency, or disk-space based, will provide a lot more value to the community and make it easier for individuals to contribute. I eagerly await the day that one of these alternatives becomes mainstream.
- Nursie 11y agoAlternatives are good but.... well, disk-space based would push up the price of hard drives. Bandwidth connectivity and latency could again be owned by big players... I don't know. What I do know is that in a centralised crypto-currency system you don't need any of this as the issuing authority merely signs the transactions and we're away. I hope that some bright spark comes up with a way to make a decentralised one almost as simple...
- mywittyname 11y agoThe current system for USD is pretty close to ideal. Short term money is creating through lending, long term money through bonds. It's a great mechanism and could be readily adapted to digital currencies. Have a group of banks that may issue loans in the currency and have a central authority that will issue bonds and pay interest on them in the currency. Set the lending rate to under the bond rate to "bootstrap" the initial currency flow, then manage it from there. Management could be automated by computers to constantly find the optimal rates for loans and bonds.
- saalweachter 11y agoIt's made me a little down on digital stamps, which was an idea I used to like. Back before spam filters got good, one of the proposed solutions to the spam problem was to require everyone to compute an easy to verify, difficult to produce hash for their email message and bounce everything which didn't come with an attached hash. The idea was that a regular user could spend 1 or 10 seconds hashing each email, but a spammer couldn't spend the time hashing millions of spam messages. Now I suspect that we would have just ended up with data centers full of highly efficient hashing hardware cranking out signatures for spam messages.
- throwaway7767 11y agoWe didn't need bitcoin to know that HashCash and the like wouldn't work to prevent spam. The existence of botnets already means spammers won't be impacted. No need for expensive specialised hardware when other people are paying for the commodity hardware and electricity. And since a regular user on a not-so-powerful mobile device needs to be able to compute the hash in a reasonable time, that puts an upper bound on the processing that's guaranteed to not be an obstacle to a spammer with 3000 botnet slaves.
- 13of40 11y ago> since a regular user on a not-so-powerful mobile device needs to be able to compute the hash in a reasonable time I would assume this would be implemented at the SMTP level, so when I connect to gmail with my phone, it's their servers that need to generate the hash before they send it through SMTP.
- throwaway7767 11y agogmail handles a lot of mail, which again puts an upper bound on how difficult the puzzle will be. I don't think this changes anything. And if you make it too hard, "free" (ad-supported) email will no longer be possible because the costs are simply too high for the financial return.
- saalweachter 11y ago
- ywecur 11y agoFrom the bitcoin.org FAQ: >Isn't Bitcoin mining a waste of energy? >Spending energy to secure and operate a payment system is hardly a waste. Like any other payment service, the use of Bitcoin entails processing costs. Services necessary for the operation of currently widespread monetary systems, such as banks, credit cards, and armored vehicles, also use a lot of energy. Although unlike Bitcoin, their total energy consumption is not transparent and cannot be as easily measured. Bitcoin mining has been designed to become more optimized over time with specialized hardware consuming less energy, and the operating costs of mining should continue to be proportional to demand. When Bitcoin mining becomes too competitive and less profitable, some miners choose to stop their activities. Furthermore, all energy expended mining is eventually transformed into heat, and the most profitable miners will be those who have put this heat to good use. An optimally efficient mining network is one that isn't actually consuming any extra energy. While this is an ideal, the economics of mining are such that miners individually strive toward it.
- cwyers 11y agoIt uses vastly more energy than payment processors that have vastly more throughput. And the ideal miner that finds a valuable use for the waste heat is a fantasy, and it's an incredibly inefficient way of generating that heat.
- acdha 11y agoAlso we have no reason to believe that the trend will change away from advances in hardware efficiency just buying more of them - the ratchet mechanism doesn't reward stable capacity.
- saalweachter 11y agoI think at the end of the day there's an important axiomatic difference. Are you willing to trust any central authority? Maybe a government, maybe a set of independent businesses you can chose among, maybe a specifically selected advisory committee, one really cool dude. Just anything. If you are, then burning coal and compute cycles is just insane and wasteful. If you aren't, then you might be willing to admit that from some angles it is an inelegant solution, but it is a solution. Taking Bitcoin on its own terms, as a solution to a problem you may not personally care about, the wastefulness of the process isn't really a problem. If anything, I agree with what someone else said down thread -- it would be better if mining for Bitcoin wasn't profitable, and it was a lottery people played at a loss (wasting even more resources!). That would discourage the centralization of mining power. IMO the biggest problem Bitcoin faces is that it put voting power in the hands of miners instead of users, and then encouraged those miners to coalesce into a relatively small coalition of big-money players.