3 ms·
OK, I am not very deep into the Kindle vs publishers thing, but isn't it a bit dangerous to root for Amazon to build their monopoly? As an avid reader, I am not
by Tichy 17y ago
OK, I am not very deep into the Kindle vs publishers thing, but isn't it a bit dangerous to root for Amazon to build their monopoly? As an avid reader, I am not sure I want one company to be in control of "my drug".
Not saying the publishers are necessarily the good guys (probably aren't). But this isn't about loving books, this is about market dominance and control. Not exacty the thing that inspires me to write a love letter to Amazon (though I usually buy from them and I like their service).
Ultimately, do we really need Amazon for a proper ebooks distribution? It seems to me in theory every author could put their books on a web site right now, using whatever payment system he likes. The Kindle seems more like a Trojan horse to me - we let it into our lives, and then we can't get rid of it anymore, unless we are willing to let go of the 1000 books we bought, too.
I, as a reader, don't want to be held hostage, neither by Amazon nor by book publishers.
- patio11 17y agoPersonal anecdotes incoming: I live in a Japanese apartment. Like many Japanese folks, I read a lot and cannot possibly keep all the books I read here. Most go in the garbage when I'm done. I have no particular desire for ownership but, if I did, I own the bits on my Kindle in a much more durable fashion than I own the atoms in my trash bag right now. (Thirty volumes just got evicted.) It seems to me in theory every author could put their books on a web site right now, using whatever payment system he likes. This has been true in ten of the last ten years, and I have never bought a single book through it. The experience matters, and the Kindle is an amazingly better experience for me than reading on my screen is. (Amazon also beats the stuffings out of Google for book discovery, which is what I'd have to do to get to your website if you sold it directly. I can't very well Google [sci-fi I would enjoy], but Amazon will give me four titles fitting that bill on my front page. And they're pretty good at it, too -- Amazon probably has a better handle on my tastes than anybody except my siblings.)
- Tichy 17y agoI have nothing against the Kindle or eBooks. But just because Amazon currently has the best reader doesn't mean I desire them to become a monopoly. Also, while OT, I have found Amazon pretty useless for discovering SciFi. Your argument seems to amount to "Amazon is so good, I'll never need anything else in my life". Maybe, maybe not (as I said, I tend to buy at Amazon, too - but lately I feel a bit uneasy about it).
- jbm 17y agoJust out of curiousity, why don't you just give them to Hard-Off / Book Off or donate them to the local library? (I only ask because I was having the exact same conversation with my girlfriend yesterday)
- frossie 17y agoI often suggest people donate unwanted books to the local library, and they say "oh it's not library material". Just to be clear, libraries don't put books that you donate on the shelves - they sell them and use the money to fund their programs. So (at least in the US) they're just as happy to take your "low-brow" stuff. Perhaps things are different in Japan (where the up-thread poster is)
- patio11 17y agoNeither will take books in English. The best option I have is giving them away to friends, and I can't do that fast enough to keep pace with my buying.
- ErrantX 17y agoI hear what your saying. However at the moment, for me at least, Amazon offer such a great package for the consumer - both in ebooks and hard covers - that I can't help but support them ( within limits).
- Nogwater 17y agoHere's why I'm not worried about an Amazon monopoly (I'm open to changing my mind on this). 1) It's not really a monopoly as long as the authors/publishers sell through other vendors too. Will I buy eBooks from Amazon, Apple, Barnes and Noble, Sony, or someone else (Wal-mart has to be at least thinking about it)? They're not here yet, but I expect to see eBook readers that work with multiple stores. I'm sure the iPad will through apps like the Kindle app for the iPhone. 2) Lock-in through DRM isn't nearly as much of an issue as it is with music because I don't re-read books more often than one book per decade. I have a handful of books that I re-reference every once in a while, but it's rare. I can switch my supplier very easily if someone comes out with a better device. I have a lot of freedom to choose both the store and the reader (not complete, but a lot). As long as the stores don't require exclusive contracts, I think we'll be OK.