3 ms·
Charles Stross! I flew to America to buy a copy of Merchant Princes. Well, OK, not really: I tried to buy it in Japan from my Kindle with the intention of rea
by patio11 17y ago
Charles Stross! I flew to America to buy a copy of Merchant Princes. Well, OK, not really: I tried to buy it in Japan from my Kindle with the intention of reading it on my annual trip back, and I was denied because of some licensing agreement your publisher had. I eventually bought it while passing through Detroit Airport.
Despite the fact that this is ridiculously convenient for argument I am about to make, I am actually telling the truth: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1002315 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1002315
When you say"rent-seeking intermediaries" I think of a different player than you do. See, Amazon makes my reading experience awesome. Your publisher? They have not made my experience awesome. I know they spend a lot of money on, e.g., typesetting and wood pulp. That must suck. I am having a hard time mustering up sufficient sympathy to back your publisher's attempt to charge me more so that I can subsidize the continued practices which result in 50% of print runs getting pulped.
Is Amazon's contribution to total awesomeness worth 70%? Eh, I don't know. I'm a software vendor. Google takes fifty cents out of the last dollar of sales for me (for advertising), despite the fact that I do all the "actual work". I use the scare quotes because if the last couple of years have taught me anything it has taught me that making the sale -- which is what Amazon does for you -- is a non-trivial bit of the business equation.
I don't see my profit split with Google as a moral issue -- I see it as a fairly simple business decision. To whit, I sure like getting that last fifty cents. I think I managed to get about $20 of your books on my trip to America. Now, I don't know whether you see $1 or $3 of that at the end of the day, but either is a darn sight better than $0, which is what your publisher is pushing hard for you to get from me.
- cstross 17y agoThe publisher's contribution is invisible, but awesome. Trust me, the books wouldn't be the same without them. Amazon's visible contribution is ... well, there's something rather nasty happening behind the stage curtain. Agreed, the mass market channel for paperback distribution must die -- everyone in publishing agrees on this (the 50% wastage is grotesque) ... just not until there's a replacement way for injecting cheap books into readers' eyeballs.
- Poiesis 17y agoWhat am I missing here? Ebooks aren't fitting the bill? Because of low adoption?