4 ms·
We Will End Disability by Becoming Cyborgs (2014)
- oneJob 11y agoSure, end disability and exacerbate inequality. Additionally, I don't see us all being the same type of cyborg. If anything, becoming cyborgs we'll realize that there is more than one way to become "physically functional" and so stop labeling everyone that is not typically physically functional as disabled.
- snake_plissken 11y agoI love the idea of having augmentations and neural implants but the potential social ramifications, which the article gets slightly into, scare the living daylights out of me. From the Deus Ex alternative universe, year 2022: Antoine Thisdale, an un-augmented oil rig worker sues for the right to have both of his fully functional natural arms amputated and replaced with cybernetic arms in an effort to compete with mechanically augmented workers in his profession. The Supreme Court rules in his favor, clearing the way for elective augmentation. In response to the ruling, William Taggart creates Humanity Front, a political organization that opposes augmentation.
- Vraxx 11y agoI agree somewhat with you, I think this could easily be a hotbed of controversy moving forward. At the same time though, maybe that era would simply be akin to the early industrial eras when workers unionized and fought for better working rights. I agree that the fallout for this type of advancement could be chaotic, but when has that stopped human progress before? Would it be better if we could avoid the whole disaster and navigate this advancement nimbly and with as little disruption as possible? Sure, but I don't see it as being very likely.
- Qantourisc 11y agoI would not worry about that specific case to hard. If you can make an arm, sure you can make an exoskeleton ?
- emblem21 11y agoCybernetics will just change disability insurance into hardware insurance.
- smacktoward 11y agoThe wrinkle here is that not all people with disabilities agree that their conditions are actually a bad thing. Among those who are deaf, for instance, there has been a long-standing debate over whether deafness is actually a medical problem, or just a different kind of human experience. The latter group would argue that a campaign to restore hearing to the deaf would actually be a kind of genocide -- a coordinated campaign to wipe out a distinct culture, with its own languages and traditions, just because it is physically different than the majority. That may sound wild, but the more you think about it the more troubling questions it raises. Well-meaning people would never consciously try to shame deaf people for being deaf, for instance, but the viewpoint embedded in the idea of ending deafness is that the deaf are broken people who need to be fixed by being made more like the rest of us. Do we actually agree that deaf people are broken, incomplete? If we do, does it follow that deaf people who refuse our cure should be compelled, in some manner, to accept it? How far are we willing to go to eradicate deafness? Is "eradicating deafness" even a morally legitimate thing to aspire to? I'm not deaf myself, so I won't pretend to have an authoritative perspective on any of these questions. I just raise them to note that the standard tech-centric view of these things (here's a problem, let's create something that solves it!) isn't the lens through which everyone sees the lives they live.
- noir_lord 11y ago> The latter group would argue that a campaign to restore hearing to the deaf would actually be a kind of genocide. Only if it's not optional I think, where ethics get really interesting is when deaf parents want a deaf child, that's one that still isn't settled due to cochlear implants which are already a kind of cyborg. I'm able bodied (apart from a degenerative spinal condition) and I'd happily swap that part out if I could, wouldn't even think about it for more than 5 seconds.
- stcredzero 11y agoWhat of multiply resistant strains of bacteria and the end of the antibiotics era?
- 11y ago
- stcredzero 11y agoSort of an inversion of Harrison Bergeron, except instead of the natural superman having inert blocks of metal attached to him to bring his abilities down, everyone else will have high tech stuff attached to enhance their abilities. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harrison_Bergeron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harrison_Bergeron
- greggarious 11y agoHow can robot augmentations cure, say, depression? Sounds like a pretty narrow definition of "disability"
- epimetheus 11y agoI'm guessing you didn't read the article and are just responding to the title? From the article: "One promising experiment targets depression with deep brain stimulation (DBS), in which electrodes implanted in the brain send steady pulses of electricity to certain problematic neural areas." and "Neuroscientists discovered years ago that this existential dread can be treated by using electricity to alter the activity of neurons, and they are now putting that knowledge to use. DBS, one of the most exciting experimental treatments for depression, uses an implanted “brain pacemaker” that sends steady pulses of electricity to certain brain regions. It’s a technology that was pioneered to stop Parkinson’s patients’ tremors, but it’s now being explored for a dizzying array of neural and psychiatric disorders, including depression, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and PTSD."