4 ms·

No response articles, please.

by elinchrome 11y ago

sdegutis 11y ago
He's not wrong though.
- bliti 11y ago
  Yes, a business focused on the things that make it money. Thats the purpose and the OP is not wrong on that. What he is missing is the immense power the open source community as whole has. They can boycott github and turn it into a ghost town in a manner of months. Github will then lose part of the appeal it sells to enterprise customers.
  - minimaxir 11y ago
    > They can boycott github and turn it into a ghost town in a manner of months. The last paragraph in the OP rhetorically mocks that idea. Boycotting GitHub would negatively impact said projects since there is no competitior as robust, which is a worse outcome.
    - bliti 11y ago
      Indeed. Though it would not take that much convincing to have those people turn gitlab into what they want and host it themselves with a container based image. Plus they could simulate the social aspect of github by using a general index of projects.
    - throwaway999888 11y ago
      1. Move code and related (issues etc.) to GitLab/Bitbucket 2. Mark GitHub repo as "Mirror Only" 3. Unsubscribe from all GitHub Issues and notifications (see 2.) 4. No more low-effort spam, only the occassional medium-high effort questions and issue reports. Sweet relief! If the choice was between piece of mind and stars on GitHub, I think I'd take the first.
      - bliti 11y ago
        Stars can also be ported over. You could even go one step further and create star similar to reddit's "gold". A "gold" star would contribute to the development of the project.
        throwaway999888 11y ago
        Then it's truly a win-win! ;)
        bliti 11y ago
        If only this were a forum where the right people could read about it. ;)
minimaxir 11y ago
Yes, the amount of response articles about the Paul Graham essay was silly. However, this is a topic that's not frequently discussed and lots of room for argument.
trjordan 11y ago
Why not?
benjamincburns 11y ago
Lets let the mods worry about it.
smt88 11y ago
I don't see much difference between a comment on Reddit/HN and a response article, except that the response article is platform-agnostic and (sometimes) more thoughtfully assembled.
- RubyPinch 11y ago
  because its practically a long comment on the original. If it has to be platform agnostic with formatting, then that is why comments are allowed to have links to other sites. Otherwise we really should all start writing response articles and post those instead of comments, because there are only positives yeah? 70 comments for this post alone, all articles so people can use their own variant of formatting languages or whatever

No response articles, please.

sdegutis 11y ago

He's not wrong though.

bliti 11y ago
Yes, a business focused on the things that make it money. Thats the purpose and the OP is not wrong on that. What he is missing is the immense power the open source community as whole has. They can boycott github and turn it into a ghost town in a manner of months. Github will then lose part of the appeal it sells to enterprise customers.
- minimaxir 11y ago
  > They can boycott github and turn it into a ghost town in a manner of months. The last paragraph in the OP rhetorically mocks that idea. Boycotting GitHub would negatively impact said projects since there is no competitior as robust, which is a worse outcome.
  - bliti 11y ago
    Indeed. Though it would not take that much convincing to have those people turn gitlab into what they want and host it themselves with a container based image. Plus they could simulate the social aspect of github by using a general index of projects.
  - throwaway999888 11y ago
    1. Move code and related (issues etc.) to GitLab/Bitbucket 2. Mark GitHub repo as "Mirror Only" 3. Unsubscribe from all GitHub Issues and notifications (see 2.) 4. No more low-effort spam, only the occassional medium-high effort questions and issue reports. Sweet relief! If the choice was between piece of mind and stars on GitHub, I think I'd take the first.
    - bliti 11y ago
      Stars can also be ported over. You could even go one step further and create star similar to reddit's "gold". A "gold" star would contribute to the development of the project.
      - throwaway999888 11y ago
        Then it's truly a win-win! ;)
        bliti 11y ago
        If only this were a forum where the right people could read about it. ;)

minimaxir 11y ago

Yes, the amount of response articles about the Paul Graham essay was silly. However, this is a topic that's not frequently discussed and lots of room for argument.

trjordan 11y ago

Why not?

benjamincburns 11y ago

Lets let the mods worry about it.

smt88 11y ago

I don't see much difference between a comment on Reddit/HN and a response article, except that the response article is platform-agnostic and (sometimes) more thoughtfully assembled.

RubyPinch 11y ago
because its practically a long comment on the original. If it has to be platform agnostic with formatting, then that is why comments are allowed to have links to other sites. Otherwise we really should all start writing response articles and post those instead of comments, because there are only positives yeah? 70 comments for this post alone, all articles so people can use their own variant of formatting languages or whatever