5 ms·
But Amazon pretty much, right now, has a monopoly on online bookselling. They’re huge. As a result, this becomes nearly a form of de facto price fixing. This i
by patio11 17y ago
But Amazon pretty much, right now, has a monopoly on online bookselling. They’re huge. As a result, this becomes nearly a form of de facto price fixing.
This is not a reason to prefer Macmillan over Amazon. Amazon might arguably have something that is almost a monopoly on online bookselling, allowing them to de facto dictate the price of books purchased online (though not offline, except to the extent that price wars dictate that competitors charge less).
Macmillan has an actual monopoly, guaranteed by Congress, on producing Macmillan books. Macmillan is telling Amazon to engage in actual price fixing. Macmillan has told Amazon that if Amazon does not set their prices to exactly what Macmillan says they should be, when Macmillan says this should be, Macmillan will use its actual monopoly to forbid Amazon from distributing their books.
Macmillan is doing this to avoid channel conflict -- i.e. establish actual price fixing backed up by the power of law to forbid there to be price-based competition among the various outlets who sell their books.
It turns reality on its head to portray Macmillan as the pro-consumer champion of a vibrant, competitive market here.
- ErrantX 17y agoThat's the best summation of this whole thing I've seen so far today. Thanks.
- cgranade 17y agoAt the same time, it also turns reality on its head to portray Amazon as being pro-consumer in this case (where's the good old Amazon that helped force Apple out of music DRM by launching Amazon MP3?). In this struggle, it seems that both sides are trying to price-fix, but to different prices, and without much concern for either the consumers or the authors that are so directly affected by their falling-out. Other good perspectives: * http://scienceblogs.com/principles/2010/01/the_amazon_kerfuffle.php http://scienceblogs.com/principles/2010/01/the_amazon_kerfuf... * http://whatever.scalzi.com/2010/01/30/a-quick-note-on-ebook-pricing/ http://whatever.scalzi.com/2010/01/30/a-quick-note-on-ebook-... * http://malkingrey.livejournal.com/577241.html http://malkingrey.livejournal.com/577241.html
- felixc 17y agoThe difference is that Amazon is trying to price-fix a ceiling, whereas Macmillan is trying to price-fix a floor.
- cgranade 17y agoThe question of which is ultimately better for the consumer is non-trivial to my mind. Not to mention that, because publishers tie author royalties to the physical cost of production, the authors stand to lose a lot in this struggle.
- Retric 17y agoHow can any price greater than 0 be the best price for a consumer.
- alex_c 17y agoIf something won't be profitable to make, it won't be made. The best price for the consumer is the lowest price at which the item desired by the consumer can still be produced.
- Retric 17y agoIf something can't be made it's price is infinity. If it's custom but possible to create it's price is high. If it's mass produced it's price drops. If it's pubic domain it's free. PS: Saying people will not make it at some price just means it's actual price is higher.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- cgranade 17y agoMy point with the parenthetical note is that Amazon is not acting in a consistent manner. With music, they trumpeted the virtues of going DRM-free and allowing for dynamic pricing, while with books, they're sticking to DRM and not allowing dynamic pricing. As for price-fixing, if there were multiple vendors for e-books on Kindle readers, then yes, I would agree that Amazon is not at all price-fixing. Since they are, however, the sole provider of e-books for the Kindle (more or less-- you can convert other formats to Mobipocket with mixed results, and the Kindle 2 and DX versions have limited PDF support), their insistence on uniform e-book prices can reasonably be seen as a kind of price fixing. This is part of why I opined over at Chad Orzel's blog (http://scienceblogs.com/principles/2010/01/the_amazon_kerfuffle.php http://scienceblogs.com/principles/2010/01/the_amazon_kerfuf...) that an upshot of this falling-out should be that in order to keep their platform viable, Amazon should drop DRM and support ePub or some other standard format. If they followed their own example of Amazon MP3, then they really would be consumer advocates by taking issue with Macmillan.
- shabda 17y agoFor a different perspective on it. You have a guaranteed monopoly on the price of Bingo Card Creator. I am not sure you would appreciate it if Paypal/(Insert other card processors here) said that they will only let you sell via them if you sold it for 9.99$. I don't that not fair either. You should be free to set the price of your goods, it is not a question of pro-consumer, its a question of using near monopoly to get a power which the market enabler should not have. (Sorry if the last para reads like a personal attack, as it uses a personal example. That is to use an example which you and other hacker news readers are familiar with.)
- jey 17y agoIf patio11 gets paid the same, and Paypal eats the difference, then why would he care?
- shabda 17y agoI would because I would be losing the power too set prices for my goods, which has always been the producers right.
- jey 17y agoThe producer is still setting a price and getting paid that price. If you're saying that nobody should ever be able to resell at a different price, then you're outlawing free giveaways, promotions, markups, etc... basically neutering the whole "free market" concept.
- tallanvor 17y agoThat's not really right, though. Amazon is a store. They should have the right to purchase books at the rate they can negotiate and sell the books for the price they feel the market can support. MacMillan, on the other hand, is trying to force retailers like Apple and Amazon to sell them for the same price, eliminating competition and create artificially high prices (aka price fixing). And really, trying to argue that price fixing is good for consumers is a very difficult position to defend.