2 ms·
The midpoint fallacy is that the truth lies directly in the midpoint. Typically it lies SOMEWHERE in the middle, but the fallacy is meant to point out that it'
by rconti 11y ago
The midpoint fallacy is that the truth lies directly in the midpoint.
Typically it lies SOMEWHERE in the middle, but the fallacy is meant to point out that it's just as likely to lie very close to one end or the other, as directly in the middle.
Of course, if you construct a total straw man argument where we already know the god-given truth, you can show that a second argument will take you further from the truth.
- rz2k 11y ago"Somewhere in the middle" is one of three possibilities if you reduce everything to a one-dimensional line and pick two points. Even in the rare cases where an oversimplified single continuum expresses the best solutions to address a problem, there is little reason to assume that two point alternatives aren't together in being the wrong direction away from the optimum. However, I really think golemotron was just referring to when a trend becomes a default that no longer needs to have its case made in new situations. Like assuming middlegrounds are implicitly correct, or cargo culting, it's just a form of assuming there are shortcuts that make understanding the mechanisms of success or doing actual analysis are unnecessary.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoYour understanding of the middle ground fallacy does not accord with the rest of the world's: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation The middle ground fallacy is the idea that given two ideas, the truth lies somewhere in between them.