6 ms·
Why federal government needs to invest in this? I mean, when people say "government support is necessary for fundamental research which can not be financed by p
by smsm42 11y ago
Why federal government needs to invest in this? I mean, when people say "government support is necessary for fundamental research which can not be financed by private means", ok, there's an argument there. But companies like Google - not exactly short of money - already investing into this. Why feds need to intervene? Of course, every company would gladly take gifts from feds to advance their private research - but why do it? There are a lot of fields that could use $4B and are not a focus of attention of a half-trillion-dollar corporations.
Also, they claim simultaneously that self-riving cars are safer and that they would be exempt from safety rules. How that works? If they are already safer, they should be able to satisfy more safety rules, not less?
- bliti 11y agoAutonomous operation might require updating infrastructure. That falls under the scope of government.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- circlecrimson 11y agoDid you read the article? Such a monumental change in behavours is going to bring in massive changes to the legal framework, safety standards, insurance practices and road markings and upgrades to name a few aspects.
- humanrebar 11y ago$4B seems like a pittance if that's the goal.
- smsm42 11y agoLegal framework is what the Congress and the state lawmakers are supposed to do anyway, and they don't need $4B from federal budget to do this. As for insurance practices, etc. - that's the business of insurance companies, and I'm sure once Google contacts them offering the opportunity to insure world's first self-driving car, insurance industry would be more than happy to jump on that, and they are not the poorest industry either.
- jackvalentine 11y agoIt sounds to me like the funding is being allocated as a response to private investment. Companies are going to create self-driving cars - the feds want to be ready for them instead of a roadblock.
- purpled_haze 11y agoYes, but that much money could be used to feed, clothe, and take care of a lot of people. Why can't they instead spend 1B on buses, which would serve more people than support for driverless cars, and 3B on the homeless?
- user9982 11y agoBecause that's not how funding works. This is research money, you can't just move money around willy nilly.
- enraged_camel 11y ago>>Yes, but that much money could be used to feed, clothe, and take care of a lot of people. You could make this argument for literally anything that isn't feeding, clothing or taking care of people, which means it is a silly argument.
- horsecaptin 11y agoNot a silly argument at all. Every time we say, "lets spend $x on y", it is fair to question whether that money can be used to feed and clothe... or defend.. or fix the infrastructure, etc.
- euyyn 11y ago> whether that money can be used to... Of course it can, there's no reason it couldn't. That doesn't make it a proper challenge. One would be "instead of $4B, $X should be invested on this, because of such and such". X == 0 without details is a big red flag.
- 11y ago
- jessaustin 11y agoWhy federal government needs to invest in this? Generally I agree with the sentiments you express here, but I just remembered the murderdeathwar on which many in the federal government would prefer to spend $4B. Compared to that, even if this is a total waste, it's not that bad.
- caseysoftware 11y agoThat's the thing.. government never chooses A instead of B, they choose to do A, B, and then C just for good measure. This isn't going to take money from other wasteful or bad areas. It's just going to be more debt.
- euyyn 11y agoThat's naive. The government, like any big entity that handles money, prepares a budget choosing to do A instead of B.
- outlace 11y agoDid we read different articles? It doesn't read at all like the US Govt is investing in developing self-driving car technology, of course plenty of private automakers are already doing that, it looks like US Govt is investing in self-driving car public infrastructure and guidelines.
- blennon 11y agoReally? "U.S. Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx said the president's 2017 budget proposal includes $4 billion over 10 years for pilot projects, including a program to test self-driving cars by investing in technologically connected roads. He provided few other details on how the money would be spent if it comes to fruition." That sounds to me like they are try to pick technologies to invest in. If that's the use of funds, I think it's a waste. Let the market choose the best tech.
- jonnybgood 11y agoYou think investing in improving infrastructure tech is a waste?
- oldmanjay 11y agoThe government is incapable of spending money wisely. The best we can hope for is that the chosen contractor who receives the funds doesn't find it offensive to actually perform the duties contracted.
- outlace 11y ago"...including...investing in technologically connected roads" The private sector can't install a network of communication technology to wirelessly link roads and self-driving cars on public property (plus you probably need to coordinate with the FCC). From my reading, it seems like they're investing in things that only the government has control over and at the request of private sector companies like Google who want clear national guidelines formed and are probably pushing for a new "connected road" infrastructure. But if you still can't see that reading of it, then let's just agree that there aren't enough details released yet so let's just wait for more.
- jostmey 11y agoAnd wait! Government officials will be glad to take credit for the driving revolution that is about to happen :-) For some reason, people in power think that it was by their hand that the world turns.
- melted 11y agoBecause cars by themselves are NOT GOING TO WORK anytime soon. Rain, fog, sleet, snow, road work, garbage on the pavement, etc — all those things can't be handled by today's self driving car tech. One way to get around some of those things is make the roads assist the cars with things like machine readable guidance markers in the pavement, rfid, and so on. Those things will need to be developed and deployed on federal roads for there to actually be viable autonomous cars. That costs money and takes time. I'm just as pissed about the government throwing away taxpayer money on all kinds of shit, but let's face it, this is less than four days of our military budget.
- jack9 11y ago> all those things can't be handled by today's self driving car tech Some "can't be handled". Just because Google or Honda's implementation (based on a camera) is geared toward a specific implementation, doesn't make it the best. Cruise Automation has the right idea with sensor arrays that make fog and rain a non-issue. There are lots of options.
- melted 11y agoNo, it's an issue. Heavy rain and fog are even problematic for humans. Current systems use image of the pavement for precise vehicle localization. Pavement not visible? You're fucked. Pavement markings unclear? You're fucked. Road crew painted on temporary markings alongside existing? You're fucked. And so on and so forth.
- mod 11y agoIf the pavement isn't visible, I'm fucked if I'm driving myself.
- gambiting 11y agoBut you can at least try. You can make slow progress. You can get out, have a look around and continue slowly if needed. An automatic car will just go "no sensor reading, not moving amigo". Bird shat on your lidar sensor? Sorry, have to call assistance to get it professionally cleaned, otherwise the car is not moving. One of the lighbulbs burnt out? Sorry, the car is legally not fit for driving so you are not going anywhere, or alternatively the only destination you can enter is an approved garage. I personally think this is going to be a huge problem with self-driving cars. They can't go anywhere if any of their sensors are faulty. And they need to have hundreds of them to work in all conditions. Ideally, you would want to have sensors in every wheel to tell you the pressure, sensors that tell you if there is ice on the road, sensors in literally every part of the suspension to monitor if you haven't suffered a broken coil or damaged bearing that could cause an accident - and those things break. Even such a simple thing as pressure monitors in modern cars are notorious for breaking down. Anyone who has driven a 5-10 year old car will know that there always is something broken. In cause of automatic cars pretty much every problem is a breaking problem that immobilizes the vehicle completely, and I think people will get tired of that pretty quickly.
- Aloisius 11y agoIt should be noted that the Federal government has been investing in autonomous research for decades.
- z3t4 11y agoWhen you hear stories about dudes building self-driving cars in their garages, you might think the "market" will solve it. But we're no way near having self driving cars.