3 ms·
In general, a scientific review does not cite nonexistent/non-peer reviewed/advocate sources [1]. It's entirely invalid to say that because they came to a cert
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
In general, a scientific review does not cite nonexistent/non-peer reviewed/advocate sources [1].
It's entirely invalid to say that because they came to a certain conclusion and the majority of the cited studies support that conclusion, they picked the citations to support it.
The argument is being made that because they eschewed the normal practice and included unscientific citations only in support of their thesis, we can conclude cherrypicking was going on. You can't apply it to a normal review, since a normal scientific review doesn't normally base their claims on anecdotes from mountaineering magazines.
[1] Such sources are occasionally cited as novelties or as evidence of importance of the topic. E.g., "as evidenced by recent media attention \cite{NYT, FOX, NBC, CBS} my topic is important".