3 ms·
To be clear, Mike Hearn's unilateral fork doesn't switch over to the new rules when 75% adoption is achieved, or even when 75% of mining is done by supporters -
by makomk 11y ago
To be clear, Mike Hearn's unilateral fork doesn't switch over to the new rules when 75% adoption is achieved, or even when 75% of mining is done by supporters - it switches when 75% of the last 1000 blocks indicate support, which can quite easily happen with less than 75% support just by random chance. This is an astonishingly aggressive threshold, and if he succeeded it's almost certain that Bitcoin would fork into two different, conflicting versions of the transaction history for a substantial length of time.
- LukeHoersten 11y agoYes good point. Thanks for the clarification.
- gus_massa 11y agoThe random chance is very very low. For simplicity, let's say that 50% of the hashing power agree and 50% of the hashing power disagree. Then the probability of getting 750 blocks is 7*10^-59 ( http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=binomial+distribution+n%3D1000%2C+p%3D0.5%2C+at+least+750+success http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=binomial+distribution+n... ) There are approximately 50000 blocks in a year, so the expected time is a lot of millions of years. This changes when most of the hash power agree. If the 74% agree then the chances are 24% ( http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=binomial+distribution+n%3D1000%2C+p%3D0.74%2C+at+least+750+success http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=binomial+distribution+n... ). The calculation is more complicated because the intervals may overlap, but this would take less than a year. So, when more than 70% of the hash power agree, it's time to upgrade, but 70% is a clear majority. (Just for curiosity: With 75% hash power you get a 52% chance. With 76% hash power you get a 78% chance.)
- badgar 11y agoThank you for taking the time to run the numbers. Your parent poster stuck out as obviously wrong based on high-school math.
- someguydave 11y agoThis calculation doesn't address the arbitrary nature of the threshold.
- someguydave 11y ago>it switches when 75% of the last 1000 blocks indicate support, which can quite easily happen with less than 75% support just by random chance. I was astonished when I read this 'consensus' code in the Bitcoin repository. I recommend removing it or deploying an old version of the Bitcoin server. It is a reckless and deceitful (how many users actually understand the tacit consent they are granting by running this code?) > conflicting versions of the transaction history for a substantial length of time. Indeed if a new block size is 'forced' with a fork, it essentially creates a new currency. I doubt the new big-block Bitcoin will stand on its own.