4 ms·
> But ordinary, everyday people don't want to infer how a system works. They don't want to think scientifically, and they won't invest any effort in building a
by bad_user 17y ago
> But ordinary, everyday people don't want to infer how a system works. They don't want to think scientifically, and they won't invest any effort in building a mental model of how the device really works.
That's not true ... "everyday people" (whatever that means) always have a mental model of how something works (be it a computer, a car or a washing machine) ... that's how humans think, the problem is that their mental model is usually different from reality.
And you can almost always put blame for this on the interface or on the education given to them.
It's like you're saying I should know how the internals of my car works (lots of science in there too). Well I don't ... all I know is how to drive it, and I've had problems because of that ... but it's not like I care. If it ends up bugging me so much, I'll search for a smarter car.
Regular users are lazy indeed ... some of them just don't get it, others are doing just fine for their day-to-day needs. Those that are doing fine, like my wife, tend to have a good teacher nearby ... so the only meaningful way of countering their laziness is through proper education.
- wtallis 17y agoI know that people always have a mental model of how something works. But it's rare that somebody actually stops to consider whether their mental model is accurate or logically consistent, and unless they do, it is neither. If your mental model of a piece of software is self-contradicting, then it obviously can't reliably tell you how to use the software. There's a lot you can do in designing a user interface to try to make sure that the user develops an accurate mental model, but it gets harder as the software gets more complex and more powerful. A car's controls are a pretty good abstraction of it's drivetrain, but most of the complexity of a car exists for the sake of efficiency and increased power, and it's a physical, observable system anyways. I think that once a piece of software becomes Turing-complete, it is impossible for user interface affordances to lead a lazy user toward an accurate mental model. After all, to program, you have to be developing a mental model of what you're creating, within the context of the programming environment. That's two mental models that both have to be accurate, and one of those can't be anticipated at all by the user interface designer. Programming is inherently harder than almost any other thing we do with computers. If a piece of software is Turing complete (and thus subject to tinkering), then the mindlessly-easy-to-use subset of it's capabilities can't be Turing complete.