15 ms·
I'm not saying anything about why they engaged in this observed behavior other than "good" and "bad", the meat of the point is that they have vastly different s
by hga 17y ago
I'm not saying anything about why they engaged in this observed behavior other than "good" and "bad", the meat of the point is that they have vastly different standards for what they consider to be evidence worth citing in their reports.
The real key is how they treat unfavorable serious research, not what they pick and chose from un-peer reviewed anecdotal sources. And how they're willing to use the latter, but made a big deal about how the research of their critics wasn't peer reviewed or in a blessed journal ... when they were conspiring to arrange just that outcome.
I think it's clear where the real selection bias is.
Look, the essence of science (that doesn't first start with experimental data) is that you put forward a theory, marshal evidence in its favor and answer all the criticism and evidence not in its favor. If you hide, obfuscate or destroy your evidence and refuse to answer your critics you aren't doing science.