4 ms·
I wish some politicians would take note: Right now is a perfect alignments of the planets for a carbon tax. Get on it before the window closes.
by legitster 11y ago
I wish some politicians would take note: Right now is a perfect alignments of the planets for a carbon tax. Get on it before the window closes.
- mac01021 11y agoWhat is the coming event that is going to close the window?
- Sideshow_Boob 11y agooil price rebound
- throwappp 11y agoOil prises rising again.
- mac01021 11y agoIf the tax takes the form of a fee-and-dividend (I think it probably should anyway), then higher oil prices shouldn't make it less politically viable (I think). Under such a policy, the average consumer of fuel will break even on the tax regardless. Google "carbon fee and dividend" or see this (http://www.skepticalscience.com/CCL-pushing-for-US-fee-and-d... http://www.skepticalscience.com/CCL-pushing-for-US-fee-and-d...) for more.
- legitster 11y agoIn the short term I would worry about consumers adjusting to the lower prices and start buying more gas guzzling vehicles. In the long term, once the supply glut for oil is over the prices should normalize. Right now oil producers are basically playing chicken to see who can outlast the others, but I would expect prices to creek back eventually as the competition clears out.
- nickff 11y agoHow confident are you in this belief? Are you shorting a diverse set of oil company stocks and/or buying oil futures, or just posting on the internet?
- throwappp 11y agoShorting profitably requires having a specific timeline for when oil stocks will be priced lower than today. You can't (profitably) just short something you think will be lower at some point in the future. You have to know when.
- nickff 11y agoYou can short sell over a term of years, usually at interest rates of ~1% (but varying depending on the company).[1] If you believe that there is even a 20% chance of a company going bankrupt over the course of the next 5 years, placing the bet will only cost you 5%-6% of your potential winfall, so your expected ROI is 15%. Commodity futures can also be purchased a few years out, as can options. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Short_(finance)#Short_selling_terms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Short_(finance)#Short_selling_...
- _yosefk 11y agoI don't know if a guy "putting his money where his mouth is" is more or less trustworthy than a guy who isn't: * If I have a position, I'll want to convince everyone that I'm right because it'll make me right (if everyone thinks energy stocks are worthless, they will be.) That's why most people with lots of skin in the game, long or short, are very happy to publicly argue that their bet is correct. * Someone very risk-averse can think, correctly, that he's likely right, but loathe the 10% probability to lose money. Conversely, someone can be near-addicted to gambling and make bets based on very little, or someone can just be wrong regardless of their risk preference. Overall, a random commenter's arguments seem more interesting to me than their claim to have bet on being right, even if I trust this really hard to verify claim.
- 11y ago
- roymurdock 11y agoThe problem is that cheap fossil fuels are a good platform, but not a call to action for a carbon tax. A carbon tax would force additional costs on energy companies, who are already scrambling to lay people off in the face of low oil prices. Some would probably be hired back into the renewables/green sector, but it would probably have the net affect of getting a substantial number of people laid off. No politician wants unemployment to increase in their voter base. If enacted at the federal level, it would increase the price of all forms of energy. The average consumer, who sees the low price of oil as a small silver lining on a large post-recessionary cloud, would be loathe to pay more and would blame the government for trying to take away the one "advantage" they've recently received. No politician wants unhappy voters blaming them for higher gas prices and electricity bills. Not to mention the enormous and protracted legal battle that big oil and coal companies would be sure to wage against a federal carbon tax. The only thing that will get enough of the population concerned about unsustainable carbon emissions is when they see the things closest to them - food, water, housing, clothing - decline in quality or increase in price due clearly and demonstrably to carbon emissions. They need to believe that carbon emissions are the fundamental, undeniable cause of rising sea levels, a decimation of crops or livestock due to strange weather patterns, an increase in natural disasters, etc. Nobody cares about an intangible and "scientifically debatable" issue like global warming due to carbon emission until their house is underwater, especially when pollution is great for the economy in the short term.
- frandroid 11y ago> force additional costs on energy companies, who are already scrambling to lay people off in the face of low oil prices The aim is exactly for no one to work for greenhouse gas-producing energy companies, when there are no more greenhouse gases. Also, they successfully and gradually implemented serious taxes on oil in Europe during the post-oil crisis period, when people had gotten used to high prices. It can be done.