15 ms·
Why clean energy is now expanding even when fossil fuels are cheap
- systems 11y agois it posssible fossil fuels are becoming cheaper because clean enegery is expanding
- eliben 11y agoIt's probably not the main reason (technology improvements in oil extraction is), but it sure doesn't hurt!
- toomuchtodo 11y agoNo, the two are disconnected. Oil is getting cheaper because the House of Saud is attempting to drive out frackers in the US. Jokes on them though: That oil is always going to be profitable around $50-60/barrel. Once the Sauds lower production to raise the price of oil back up, frackers will fire right back up. It'll take 12-18 months, but it'll still happen. Almost no one burns petroleum for electricity mind you (nat gas, yes, but not oil) except Hawaii and parts of Alaska, and they're moving as fast as possible to renewables because of price spikes that occur occasionally. So you're going to see this seesaw effect. Oil shoots up, more oil comes onto the market, oil goes back down, etc. Renewables. Oh how I love me some renewables. There's this legislation, the production tax credit [1]. It generously subsidizes the installation of renewables in the US. There's always been this quagmire though, as Congress would only extend it 1 year at a time (hard to plan capital expenditures worth billions when the legislation you're relying on is always up in the air). But things changed in December of last year. At the end of 2015, in a landmark deal, Congress extended it for 5 years, and in return, the US lifted export restrictions on crude oil. That means that solar and wind is going to roll out faster than ever. Natural gas will push out the remaining 30% of coal fired generation in the US, and wind and solar will fill the gaps (this is good; natural gas is cleaner, and produces much less CO2 per MWH produced). As more wind and solar comes online, along with utility scale battery storage, we'll reduce our reliance on natural gas (protip: don't invest long-term in generators who own substantial nat gas generation assets). China is deploying wind at an astonishing rate, faster than even nuclear [2]. They're heavily subsidizing electric vehicles now as well [3]. The price of coal is plummeting (which is good!) [4]. The best case scenario is whatever is left of it is left in the ground. If you can afford it, elect to get renewables from your utility. The premium should be ~1-3 cents/kwh. If you can afford to get an electric car, and it makes sense for your lifestyle, do so. If it doesn't, use a carshare program. Collective effort can change the status quo. [1] http://energy.gov/savings/renewable-electricity-production-tax-credit-ptc http://energy.gov/savings/renewable-electricity-production-t... [2] http://www.earth-policy.org/data_highlights/2015/highlights50 http://www.earth-policy.org/data_highlights/2015/highlights5... [3] http://www.ibtimes.com/chinese-consumers-bought-nearly-300-more-electric-cars-year-compared-2014-2222591 http://www.ibtimes.com/chinese-consumers-bought-nearly-300-m... [4] https://www.quandl.com/collections/markets/coal https://www.quandl.com/collections/markets/coal
- sliverstorm 11y agoCoal mining is also rather destructive, so I suppose it would be nice to leave some in the ground. I do wonder if there will be other uses that don't release carbon, as coal is a big carbon sink.
- noobiemcfoob 11y agoThanks for this post! well reasoned and well written!
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThank you!
- krschultz 11y agoI agree with your facts but disagree with your assessment. I believe that the drop in clean energy prices is what drove the crash in oil prices. The reason the Saudis are trying to drive the frackers out of business is because the Saudis no longer believe that we're going to get all the oil out of the ground before clean energy takes over. Previously they were fine cutting their own production in order to maintain a particular price because they were certain that eventually ALL of the oil in Saudi Arabia would get sold on the global market. If that took 100 years, that actually was even better for them. If you believed in peak oil, then being the last one standing with reserves actually would be awesome. With clean energy beating projections it looks like we're not going to burn every drop of oil in the Earth. Given that, the Saudis are no longer patient. If they hold back their reserves to maintain a particular price it's very possible we'll get off oil before we run out of oil. Thus the Saudis would have left money on the table if they didn't shift strategy. It seems like their new strategy is to extract every dollar they can for their oil reserves. In the short term that means fighting off the frackers, but the broader picture looks like a race to the bottom for all oil producers. The good news is I don't think we're going to burn all the oil on Earth. The bad news is low oil will slow down the rollout of clean energy because it makes ROI worse.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago
- Spooky23 11y agoMaybe the lack of volatility in pricing is a big factor? I know for me, swings in natural gas prices for heating is a real drag. One year I pay $500/mo, one year $150. Making a big capital investment with high fixed or financed cost would be awesome if I could do it.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoYou should not see swings that big at the retail level. I'd say whoever your supplier is isn't very good at managing price contracts.
- legitster 11y agoI wish some politicians would take note: Right now is a perfect alignments of the planets for a carbon tax. Get on it before the window closes.
- mac01021 11y agoWhat is the coming event that is going to close the window?
- Sideshow_Boob 11y agooil price rebound
- throwappp 11y agoOil prises rising again.
- mac01021 11y agoIf the tax takes the form of a fee-and-dividend (I think it probably should anyway), then higher oil prices shouldn't make it less politically viable (I think). Under such a policy, the average consumer of fuel will break even on the tax regardless. Google "carbon fee and dividend" or see this (http://www.skepticalscience.com/CCL-pushing-for-US-fee-and-d... http://www.skepticalscience.com/CCL-pushing-for-US-fee-and-d...) for more.
- legitster 11y agoIn the short term I would worry about consumers adjusting to the lower prices and start buying more gas guzzling vehicles. In the long term, once the supply glut for oil is over the prices should normalize. Right now oil producers are basically playing chicken to see who can outlast the others, but I would expect prices to creek back eventually as the competition clears out.
- nickff 11y agoHow confident are you in this belief? Are you shorting a diverse set of oil company stocks and/or buying oil futures, or just posting on the internet?
- lettergram 11y agoWhen I saw the title, my first thought was: "Because fossil fuels won't always be cheap, and will be gone in a couple hundred years" It seems pretty obvious that renewable energy is going to be the way of the future, so of course there will be large investments in it. This really isn't surprising either, because "clean energy" doesn't usually pollute the air (as the article pointed out).
- Eric_WVGG 11y agoFrom a money/self-interest perspective, most of the fortunes in carbon have already been made. The people who get rich off renewables today will be creating new dynasties.
- brockers 11y agoThat was the general wisdom back in the late 70's but the reality now is we have found WAY WAY more carbon based fuel sources than we ever thought could be captured. Updated global estimates for oil are somewhere between 50 and 250 years and most estimates (other than those by left leaning not for profits) estimate 100 to 180 years worth of coal.
- Eric_WVGG 11y agoNo I get that but nobody is going to get on the ground floor of oil. Remember the old James Dean / Rock Hudson “Giant”? or “There Will Be Blood”?
- tgb 11y agoSo did the article answer the question lithe than a passing remark that they were getting more cost effective?
- beatpanda 11y agoAnother part of the equation is the efforts of companies like mine, Genability, that are working to drive down the "soft costs" of clean energy. If you want to help create software to make clean power cheaper, you should join us -- we're hiring: http://genability.com/careers/work_with_us.html http://genability.com/careers/work_with_us.html
- mooreds 11y agoCool company and concept. Wish you allowed remote work. Oh well. Best of luck!
- ape4 11y agorenewables: pay once. fossil: pay per barrel.
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoNo. We've had financial instruments sophisticated enough (basic securitisation) for a long time to remove the difference between mere pricing models (lumpsum vs monthly payments.) That simply isn't the reason that explains why renewables do well. Further, renewables aren't pay-once, they're pay a lot once every 20 years or so, with various relatively low-cost maintenance fees on somewhat regular intervals, and probably a decent sized payment for a new inverter midway.
- barney54 11y agoNot true. If you want to have electricity, only when the wind blows or only when the sun shines, that is true. Otherwise, you need thermal (coal, nat gas, nuke) generation to produce electricity when you want it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- greendesk 11y agoNot 'Not True', if you don't mind my double-negative. I can have some electricity from renewable sources and some electricity from your selection of thermal (coal, nat gas, nuke). This results into an energy mix, not a binary value of renewable-vs-thermal. Even if a renewable sources are predictably intermittent, they can still play a positive role in an energy mix setting. Furthermore, this role can be very valuable from an investment point. For example, one pays for installation of solar arrays and gets some electricity every day until its life cycle expires. It might not reach 100% of one's consumption - but there is some electricity every day. Compare this to constructing a thermal power plant - who knows what its operating costs will be 20 years down the line.
- barney54 11y agoThe article is a bit misleading with it's focus on "generation capacity" as opposed to "production." Consider the situation in the U.S. The latest data shows that natural gas increased it's share of electricity generation from 27% to 32%. Solar increased from 0.4% to 0.7%. Wind held steady at 4.3%. http://www.eia.gov/totalenergy/data/monthly/pdf/sec7_5.pdf http://www.eia.gov/totalenergy/data/monthly/pdf/sec7_5.pdf Yes there's a lot of spending on renewables and they are building a lot of capacity, but that overlooks actual generation.
- josefresco 11y agoStill... "Overall, the addition of 121 gigawatts of solar and wind globally (also a record) means that roughly half of new electricity generating capacity installed last year was in these two technologies." Also, Biomass = 1.7%
- pm90 11y agoWhen considering investments in power generation, the price of coal/natural gas is likely a better indicator than the price of oil. And it does seem like the price of both have been decreasing. Its highly likely that the investments that happened in 2015 were planned before, when the the prices were higher.
- jessriedel 11y agoYour comment and barney54's comment pretty much invalidate the interpretation offered by the author.
- dietlbomb 11y agoBecause clean energy and fossil fuels fill entirely different demands. Fossil fuels (and nuclear and hydro) supply useful energy. Clean energy (apart from small niche uses) does not. The demand for fossil fuels is driven by the demand for energy. The demand for clean energy is driven by politics.
- mtgx 11y agoSaudi Arabia must think that if it can only hold oil prices low for a few more years, its competition will be wiped out and then it can go on selling even more oil than it does now and for $100/barrel, too. It's going to be in for a rude awakening in a few years when it tries that, because by then EVs will almost achieve critical mass, and once it tries to raise the prices, the EV sales will only accelerate. This is even more true for solar power, as I think we've already passed critical mass and there's no stopping its growth.
- k__ 11y agoI think it's the logical next step for every western country that has the technology. Russia and the Arabs are considered "the devil", so why give them money for stuff you can do yourself? "But we're also outsourcing our food and tech production?!" Yes but people to do cheap work are everywhere, if China stops "selling" cheap, we can go to the next country. Oil and Gas isn't everywhere and even if it was, it wouldn't be there forever.
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoBecause it's mostly oil that's cheap, and barely any of it is used to generate electricity (electricity being the key industry of renewables). Coal and gas is down, too, but not nearly as much, and don't have a long-term low-cost forecast as strongly as oil does right now. Further, despite the green-energy rhetoric (which I'm largely supportive and in favour of, despite it being a bit disingenuous sometimes), renewable subsidies are huge, or at least have been as of late. Further we're seeing wall street come in with securitisation of renewables, making it a bit easier for renewable companies to finance everything. At the end of the day, you can't be disruptive without capital in a capital-intensive (energy in general, including renewables, have large startup costs) industry. Securitisation allows relatively new entrants like solar city raise financing essentially by factoring 20 years of utility bills, without having to sell out the company. Beyond that, renewables are still tiny and if they weren't growing like they do, it'd be pretty strange tbh. And lastly... they're really getting cheap, and at some point there's a threshold moment you cross.
- wnevets 11y ago>renewable subsidies are huge, or at least have been as of late. relative to what? Fossil fuels in the US still get huge subsidies.
- brockers 11y agoThis is true, but subsidies for for renewable sources is significantly higher on a cost/kw amount (the number consumers care about.) What is more, renewable are not taxed ANYWHERE NEAR the same rate as fossil fuels which in the United States can be crazy high. For example, in California over half the cost of a gallon of gas is State and Federal Taxes. And then, even with the lower taxes and larger subsidies, many places have to put price controls on the sale price of renewable energy like setting the production price on residential solar to the retail price instead of the wholesale price.
- wsc981 11y agoI think parent is European, perhaps Dutch even (judging by his post history). Here in Europe I don't think fossil fuels are subsidised.
- entee 11y agoObviously more expensive carbon-intensive fuels favors renewables, but I wonder what the threshold is to really give a long term incentive for innovation. For a lot of renewable energy technologies, the biggest problem is operating at a large scale. It's fine to show something works in a lab, but will it work at 1,000x, or even 10^6x scale? You can't figure that out without building it at that scale, and you can't build it at that scale unless the probability of the investment paying off is high enough. In practice, having some confidence that you'll be somewhat price competitive through some mechanism (subsidies, favorable tax treatment etc.) over the long term. All the technologies mentioned in this article are to a first approximation old, and are doing well because they've become cheaper. The real problem here is for next-generation technologies which need to be demonstrated at industrial scale.
- neltnerb 11y agoIf I recall correctly, the major difficulty currently is stable financing. The latest budget did a great deal to assist this according to reports (I have not read the budget myself). It's really tricky to deal with the finances when capital costs are huge but operating costs are minimal. Once the plant is built, the low marginal cost of production drives prices down to levels that make roi complicated.
- entee 11y agoTrue, but the marginal cost of oil is cheaper still, and when building a new plant it's even easier to have massive cost overruns due to unforeseen complications in building the plant. As an aside: someone in the oil industry once told me that to a first approximation the marginal cost of a product coming out of a refinery is inversely proportional to the mass in metal of that refinery. The bigger the refinery, the less it costs to produce once it's built. If this is true, then demonstration-scale plants face an even bigger hurdle, because they're in a sort of valley of death of efficiency, not big enough to be cost competitive down the line, but too big to be a (relatively) low-risk investment.
- neltnerb 11y ago
- Animats 11y ago"The addition of 121 gigawatts of solar and wind globally (also a record) means that roughly half of new electricity generating capacity installed last year was in these two technologies." That's impressive. Much of that is in China, which is adding capacity. The US and EU have about as much generating capacity as they need.
- jheriko 11y agoThe things I find much more interesting is why we expect the opposite, and the nature of the political mess that stops us from using the best clean energy solution we have. I'm convinced the only real problem here is keeping people happy in a really superficial way.