3 ms·
> If copyright law actually respected a balance between creators and the public Even talking about a "balance" suggests that we should acknowledge some inheren
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
> If copyright law actually respected a balance between creators and the public
Even talking about a "balance" suggests that we should acknowledge some inherent right of copyright holders for its own sake, rather than just as a means to an end. We shouldn't. We simply have a tradeoff between two desires of the public: getting more works produced, and getting those works into the public domain (to allow reuse/remixing/etc).
https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/misinterpreting-copyright.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/misinterpreting-copyright.htm...
The difference between a life+70 year copyright versus a lifetime copyright seems unlikely to lead to the creation of any additional works. The difference between a lifetime copyright and, say, a 30-year copyright, might result in some additional creation of works, but probably not as many as the works suppressed by the inability to reuse/remix 30-year-old works. So if we want to use copyright as an incentive, why do we increase it without bound, without thinking about how many more works we'll get?
- ddingus 11y agoBecause Disney. They drew from the works of The Brothers Grimm, and once established, refused to contribute their own works back in like kind.