4 ms·
You have that backwards. Everyone who has ever died had previously lived. Besides that, all people still currently living have not died.
by logfromblammo 11y ago
You have that backwards. Everyone who has ever died had previously lived.
Besides that, all people still currently living have not died.
- coldtea 11y ago>You have that backwards. Parent didn't put it in time terms. Just noted that everyone who ever lived, has also died ("A && B", as opposed to "A then B"). >Besides that, all people still currently living have not died. Yes, though one could say that those people are still "living", not yet in a state having "lived" (past tense), as parent put it.
- mejari 11y agoI've lived. I'm currently living, but I used to, too.
- coldtea 11y agoYou haven't "lived" (period) until you're dead, and it's settled. You might have e.g. "lived in London" (if you don't know, so it's a settled thing and a specific period of your life). Or "I've lived in poverty", etc. But "I've lived", period, without such a qualifier is not that common or useful when one is still alive.
- logfromblammo 11y agoIf you truly want to argue that the verb tense chosen means "Everyone who ever lived [and then died] has died," then the statement becomes a tautology: "Everyone who has died has died."
- coldtea 11y agoAll true equivalency statements are tautologies -- since both sides "resolve" to the same thing. That doesn't mean they are useless. In this case, though, it's not "Everyone who has died has died", but "To have lived means you're dead". The same way that "to be a corpse means that you've died". That's not a tautology (it's not "to be a corpse means you're a corpse"), just informs us of a prerequisite for the other thing to happen.
- logfromblammo 11y agoI think that you lack consensus on the meaning that can be drawn from use of the past tense. Either way, the statement as given does not support the unstated implication that everyone now living will eventually die.