3 ms·
You're engaging in some very slippery semantics. To say Gautama was an atheist is to push onto history a distinction that had yet to be invented. He was very m
by vinceguidry 11y ago
You're engaging in some very slippery semantics.
To say Gautama was an atheist is to push onto history a distinction that had yet to be invented. He was very much a participant in the spiritual / religious frameworks of the time, and rejection of certain aspects of those frameworks does not necessarily make you an apostate or unreligious or atheistic.
> There was no one ordained by him or any religion proclaimed by him on his name.
Jesus ordained nobody either. Nor did he ever proclaim a religion. All that came later.
If Buddhism isn't a religion, Christianity isn't either. Buddhism has teachings, mythology, places of worship, specific means of prayer, (meditation, anybody who says meditation isn't prayer has never really prayed) holy books, priests, and a thriving metaphysical dialogue. It walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, water rolls down its back like a duck.
- knodi123 11y ago> Jesus ordained nobody either Well, catholics say differently. "And I tell you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church." So, Jesus ordained 0 or 1 people, depending on your choice of tradition.
- vinceguidry 11y agoA brief search also pointed me to a thread where Catholics believe Jesus ordained all 12 apostles. To me it seems like after-the-fact justifications, but you have to learn to live with this kind of non-rigor when studying religion.