5 ms·
Also compared with putting satellite trackers on all planes it may be cheaper. Apparently there are about 20,000 commercial jets and I saw one quote if would co
by tim333 11y ago
Also compared with putting satellite trackers on all planes it may be cheaper. Apparently there are about 20,000 commercial jets and I saw one quote if would cost $120k/plane. (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/travelnews/11325824/AirAsia-QZ8501-why-do-we-still-rely-on-black-boxes.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/travelnews/11325824/AirAsi...)
Then again sat phones seem to cost $300 and up on Amazon so you'd think they could make something cheaper than $120k.
- signa11 11y ago> ... satellite trackers on all planes ... no need for dedicated equipment, afaik. commercial planes already send ADS-B broadcasts to other planes and ground stations. so if those could be received by satellites, you would have satellite-plane-tracking. as long as every nation agrees on reserving a part of spectrum for that :)
- zik 11y agoADS-B signals aren't suitable for satellite communications unfortunately. But you can get one of these satellite trackers for $120 so you'd think they could come up with something for less than $120k. http://findmespot.com/en/index.php?cid=109&refer=FrontpageBanner http://findmespot.com/en/index.php?cid=109&refer=FrontpageBa...
- ju-st 11y agoApparently ADS-B is suitable? https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/ato/service_units/systemops/ato_intl/documents/cross_polar/CPWG16/CPWG16_PPT09_Satellite_Based_ADSB_December2013.pdf https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/at...
- sllabres 11y agoYes, i think this is what is planned with Iridium NEXT. -> http://aireon.com/ http://aireon.com/
- ddalex 11y agoThere is a difference between consumer grade hardware and aviation grade hardware. Just the testing to certify that it plays nice with all the other equipment is outrageously expensive, not to factor in hardware design (it has to live through going to altitude and back 10 times a day, for years), maintenance, retraining the crews, etc.
- jlgaddis 11y agoI think everyone has pretty much agreed on 1.09 GHz for ADS-B. ADS-B isn't required for all aircraft but a substantial number of them are already using it. The other aircraft (that will be required to use ADS-B) still have some time before it's mandatory (2017 in Europe and 2020 in the U.S., IIRC). Wasn't one of the issues with MH370 that some of the transponder equipment had been turned off?
- dogma1138 11y ago>Wasn't one of the issues with MH370 that some of the transponder equipment had been turned off? Yep the pilot according to the reports turned off the transponders and other radio equipment in the aircraft. The only thing that remained transmitting once it went silent was the Boeing diagnostic signal from the engines but that was discovered later and wasn't that helpful to begin with.
- sllabres 11y agoOnly within reach of a ground station within ~350 km, see below
- adrianN 11y agoIt's expensive to put hardware on planes, even if the hardware is cheap, because of all the regulations the hardware has to fulfill.
- mseebach 11y agoThe simplest possible device can be an entirely self-contained GPS and sat modem, just needs a power supply. When you can buy IFE units for $1500 per seat, it should be possible to build and certify such a device for much less than $120k. http://airfax.com/blog/index.php/2015/04/09/lumexis-ipax-and-aix-ifec-booths-not-to-be-missed/ http://airfax.com/blog/index.php/2015/04/09/lumexis-ipax-and... That said, $120k is not an outrageous amount of money in aviation. A 777 costs $8700/hour in fuel and oil alone to operate. http://www.what2fly.com/manufacturer/operating_cost/Boeing/777/1697 http://www.what2fly.com/manufacturer/operating_cost/Boeing/7...
- woliveirajr 11y agoEven that has to be tested that it won't burn, explode, cause some electrical problem to the power supply, the sat modem will not interfere with all other electronic devices (in some unplanned manner, at least), that it can report to be working or not, that it can be turned off in case somethings goes wrong (leaving the problem that it is less usefull if it can be turned off), and how hard it will be to repair it (if it brakes too often and takes time to fix, it costs a lot to the companies)...
- mseebach 11y agoAnd all of that is equally true of the IFE units, thus the comparison.
- akiselev 11y agoNo, it's not. The true cost of IFEs is hidden by other subsystems in the airplane that the IFEs run on, including the fully isolated power they use which costs a hell of a lot more than 1500 per passenger. IFEs are not safety critical, unlike all of the systems that keep those in seat units running including the engine generator hook up and the miles of wiring. Compared to a transceiver which is a high power EM radiator hooked up to main power, IFEs are a regulatory and design afterthought made cheap by the expense put into all of the other parts.
- kuschku 11y agoWell, quite a few airlines already have satellite trackers on all their planes, even if it is just to provide free internet to all users, even over the ocean.
- madaxe_again 11y agoIf it's for aviation, it's incredibly expensive. This is largely down to the monopolistic supply chains that operate - you want a widget for your aircraft, it's gotta come from Lockheed, Boeing, BAE, EADS (Airbus), Northrup, GDC, Raytheon and that's pretty much it - yes, there are other suppliers, but they're the ones that the huge manufacturers pick. Because of the closed nature of the market, and the infinite pockets of their governmental buyers, they can charge whatever they fancy. I spent some time in RAF repair hangers ~15 years ago, and remember being absolutely blown away by the cost of parts (for a Jaguar GR1B in this case). Torch lightbulb? £10,000. Red LED? £25,000. 50cm of 16swg wire, £5,000. Seat cushion? £90,000. So a satellite tracker for £100k is an absolute bargain, in aerospace pricing terms.
- jon-wood 11y agoHow do they justify charging £25,000 for an LED? Is there something special about that LED, or is it literally just that they've got a defense contract, and once the contract is signed nobody is paying any attention?
- pixl97 11y agoWhen you have to keep an enormous amount of paperwork and for that single lead, tracking every single point in the supply chain, things get far more expensive.
- madaxe_again 11y agoThis is part of it, yes. The MOD and others have an incredible filing system that hasn't changed in about 40 years. In essence, it comprises generating an absurd amount of hard-copy documentation for everything (buying a new LED for a fast jet, for instance, is probably 80 pages all said and done), filing that documentation (every department and even hangar have their own way of filing documentation), storing that filed documentation, and then 40 years later destroying that filed documentation without anyone having ever looked at it. It boils down to "cover your ass".
- tkinom 11y ago
- ljf 11y agoOr how else could we do it? If the industry is unwilling to pay for them, why couldn't passengers have the tech, in much the same way the people have dashcams to drive on unsafe roads. Of course this presupposes that flying in inherently dangerous, which if it were I guess far fewer people would fly to start with!