3 ms·
One of my friends includes line breaks in his iMessages, which I find strange because it takes extra effort to accomplish the same effect of sending multiple me
by chatmasta 11y ago
One of my friends includes line breaks in his iMessages, which I find strange because it takes extra effort to accomplish the same effect of sending multiple messages. But it also allows me only one chance to respond. I can't respond to his first paragraph while he's typing the second, because he sent them both at the same time.
This makes me think that the critical difference between the "Chat" and "Full" case is the number of messages, not the UI. I would expect similar results if the "Full" case was three separate messages as opposed to one message in multiple paragraphs. A better "Control" case would have been a single message in the chat UI, with line breaks (i.e. shift+enter while in FB chat), in order to eliminate text density as a variable.
Dividing one message into multiple creates anxiety for the reader by obscuring when the writer expects a response. Each individual message could stand on its own, but the writer does not expect a response to each. When three messages are condensed into one, the reader has an easier time inferring that the writer expects only one response to the whole message, not one to each individual paragraph.
This seems to relate to the feeling of sending two highly coupled messages in quick succession, only to lose service just after the first one says "Delivered."
- riffraff 11y agoI had the same thought. The "neediness" of the sender is enhanced by the idea that Alex sent _4_ messages rather than 1. Geee, how desperate is this person to get a response, that she gets to send 4 messages with no reply?
- wingerlang 11y agoI had almost the opposite thought. When I see the full message/control it looks like "too much". The chat window is how people normally write, so it felt more casual. The other ones looked more "formal"
- lazaroclapp 11y agoOr worse: having only the second message delivered and being then asked to re-send the first one, which will now show after what logically was supposed to be the second part.
- WaxProlix 11y agoBasically Hipchat.
- whytaka 11y agoI agree wholeheartedly with what you say but let's not forget that the Enter/Shift+Enter difference is a UI decision.
- simonswords82 11y agoInterestingly I apply different techniques to messaging depending on the platform. When I'm sending an SMS I'll add line breaks because I don't want to bombard the receiver with multiple messages. My human interaction to date has taught me that sending more than one SMS before receiving a response it at best, weird? At worst it can be annoying and desperate. Whatsapp changed all of this for me. I'll happily write a string of individual messages to somebody or a group of people with absolutely no fear that I'm being weird, annoying or desperate. I think the fact that they can see I'm still writing helps with this? There's also just something more "joined up" about the Whatsapp environment which makes me more comfortable taking this approach.