3 ms·
Well yes and no. This tech is SUPER cool. It can find strength / weight combinations that are very difficult to arrive at via the standard analytic means. Th
by ddingus 11y ago
Well yes and no.
This tech is SUPER cool. It can find strength / weight combinations that are very difficult to arrive at via the standard analytic means. That's worth a lot in some contexts.
However, these structures do not map well to existing manufacturing. They do map extremely well to additive manufacturing, of which ordinary 3D printing is a core component.
CAD continues to segment:
The very high end of CAD is serving the major vertical markets, and typically what happens there is tech like this will get licensed, reverse engineered, duplicated, whatever and integrated into a greater whole ecosystem that goes well beyond geometry create.
Middle, or ordinary CAD, is being used for all sorts of stuff, and people don't mind a bit longer workflow, or missing out on some features. They want an effective tool at a great price, and their access to manufacturing tends to be as mainstream as the CAD is.
On the low end, CAD is being used for maker / hobby tasks, and a whole lot of experimental type work. This tech is something to come out of that, and it's currently being supplied to the mid or mainstream CAD market by a vendor looking to move up and own more of the stack.
Whether that's successful or not remains to be seen. There is a lot of legacy data, operations, systems that just can't be ripped out. Users of those systems may well adopt this feature in whatever system it's present in, and simply move the resulting geometry to the larger system, perhaps automate doing that too, and move on.
- DennisP 11y agoThe article briefly touches on the manufacturing issue: "lets designers describe the forces that act on an object and then lets computers go off and make it. These forces can be structural loads or even manufacturing methods."
- ddingus 11y agoIt does, and not the scale of things, this is early, with really great advances to come. New manufacturing methods will help too. Additive is very well matched. I'm watching this closely. Additive, weaving, composites, nano scale, all are converging into a space that looks a lot more organic than what we do for the most part today.
- blacksmith_tb 11y agoAgreed. But since one of the goals that can be provided to a system is ease of manufacturing, I expect we'll see a lot of blobjects that are optimized for cheapness as much as elegance, strength, etc. - likely more, in fact.