5 ms·
I have a manual thermostat, no batteries required. It has worked flawlessly for over 30 years. It has a simple intuitive interface: a switch for "heat" or "cool
by ams6110 11y ago
I have a manual thermostat, no batteries required. It has worked flawlessly for over 30 years. It has a simple intuitive interface: a switch for "heat" or "cool" and a dial with a pointer to set the desired temperature.
Why make things more complicated than they need to be?
- djcapelis 11y agoBecause people derive value from it. It's that simple. You don't have to, and that's fine, but having the temperature settings for the house happen on a schedule that makes sense and depends on the time and day of the week can be quite useful. And having the ability to change the temperature from my bed is nice too.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoSure, but we've had that level of automation for decades. My Honeywell programmable thermostat has time/day scheduling with several phases per day, and different phases for the weekend. It runs off a 9V battery and I can't tell you how long the battery lasts but I _can_ tell you that it's at least 15 years.
- greenyoda 11y agoIt would be pretty rare for a 9V battery to last for 15 years of continuous operation. In my thermostat, which has features similar to yours, the battery is just for backup in case the power goes out, and the thermostat normally runs off the 24V power from the furnace circuit (it works fine if you remove the battery). It's possible that your thermostat works the same way and your battery has been dead for many years.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoThat could be, but even if the battery is dead or leaking the thing trucks along and works fine.
- ceejayoz 11y ago> Why make things more complicated than they need to be? My energy bills dropped about 30% with the Nest. It does a number of neat things to save money, including running the AC fan through the chilled ducts for a period of time after stopping the active cooling. For a forgetful person like me, it's also very handy to be able to turn the house into vacation mode the day after I left for vacation.
- post_break 11y agoBecause when you forget to change the setting to heat and wake up to a 60 degree house you rush around hoping the pipes didn't freeze. Or when you set the AC to 70 because you were warm and leave to go to work and forget to set it back.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jonathankoren 11y agoIf your house is 60 degrees. It didn't freeze.
- engi_nerd 11y agoI've always heard that if you're leaving your home for an extended period of time in winter, you should set the thermostats to 55F to prevent freezing. So 60F is surely fine.
- jacalata 11y agoIf it's 60 degrees then it isn't freezing now, but it could have been lower overnight.
- stephencanon 11y agoHeat loss is proportional to the temperature difference across the boundary (walls and windows and roof). Even when it's quite cold outside, heat loss slows down as the house gets colder, and then you still have all the phase change energy to dump before pipes freeze. This will not happen overnight except in the most extreme cases, and it certainly will not then warm back up to 60. Anecdotally, I was once without central heat for three days in 0-20F, and nothing froze. The basement got down to 38.
- kale 11y agoA lot of that depends on where your house is built. I have a house in an area that can go an entire winter without getting much below 40F. No one builds with "freeze-proof" faucet design, which recesses the valve to the outside water faucets within the wall. I had two pipes freeze and burst after 3 days of freezing temperatures (first time anyone can remember being more than 24 hours below freezing). One was an outside faucet, properly protected and insulated. The other was frozen inside the slab, near the wall.
- bitmapbrother 11y agoWhy heat or cool an an empty house?
- thrownaway2424 11y agoIn a cold climate you want to heat the place to some minimal level such that everything in the building doesn't freeze. In hot humid climates if you don't run the AC everything will mold.
- knz 11y agoThey aren't necessary but they are convenient. Being able to adjust the temperature in the middle of the night is great but being able to to adjust the temperature when on vacation is awesome. It's also flexible (will automatically adjust down if people are unexpectedly away for the day) and allows you to track energy usage more easily. Does everyone need one? No. But for some people the convenience is worth the money.
- psutor 11y agoI bought my smart thermostat (Ecobee) for a couple reasons - 1. Economic - it easily paid for itself in one summer by not running the A/C when no one is home. I have geofencing set up to do this automatically. 2. Comfort - my office/bedroom temperature is all I really care about as it's where I spend all my time. My thermostat was not wired to there, and temperatures fluctuated wildly in my office. Ecobee has remote sensors so that I can set the rooms I care about to the correct temperature. Overall, it has certainly made my life a lot less complicated; I never have to touch the thermostat again to get comfortable in my office, and I save a lot of money too.
- foobarian 11y agoBefore the Nest there was exactly one excellent thermostat user interface: the oldschool rotary GE type like you probably have. I waited many years for a good programmable equivalent, and had to endure the endless stream of crap with hard to see LCD screens and tiny confusing buttons with tiny labels so you never knew which one made the heat go up. (And which one turned off the thermostat or changed some critical setting). Nest finally delivered that, and now look at all the copycats. It's kind of similar to what happened with the iPod and iPhone. I don't really care for the "learning" feature but the 2 other features I find critical are 1) ability to schedule, and 2) remote control. It's nothing you really need, but it's nice to have. I can program the temp to go 10 degrees lower overnight, and have the heat ramp up 30 minutes before we get up. I can have the blower run 15 minutes every hour without heat or cooling to make sure air circulates around the house. You could do that by hand but it would be more manual and cognitive work.
- jpollock 11y agoBecause unless the house is occupied 24/7, there are substantial savings to be had. While I don't have a Nest, I put a similar timer on my water heater and saved a lot of money ($20/mo).
- Symbiote 11y agoWhen I was a child in, my parents had a mechanical thermostat with a timer. So did my grandma, and her system was even older. You could set two pairs of heating times, and control which (or both/none) were used. There was an override until the next set point. This was 1980s stuff, or maybe even earlier. The interface was far easier to use than any digital one I've seen.
- __david__ 11y agoYeah, even my mid 90s built house had that. It was easy to see how it worked, too—a big spinning wheel that represented the 24 hours in a day. There were little plastic arrows you'd snap onto the outside of the ring at the appropriate time. Red ones and blue ones. Each color had an indentation in a slightly different place so as the wheel spun past the "now" marker, it would flip one of two switches. The switches controlled energy saving mode. It actually wasn't super intuitive (in cooling mode it inverted the sense of energy saving mode, if I recall correctly), but it was easy and never failed me once I set it up.
- Outdoorsman 11y agoImportant household functions--HVAC, refrigeration--depending on internet connectivity to function properly...? Doesn't make sense, unless you're willing to live with the potential failure of those functions...
- superuser2 11y agoIt costs quite a bit to maintain an empty house at a comfortable temperature. It also takes a good while (order of hours) to converge on that comfortable temperature if you haven't run the HVAC in a long time and the weather is extreme. The ubiquitous programmable thermostats do different things at night, in the morning, during the workday, and in the evening. The idea being that the temperature is allowed to drift when no one's home, but is brought back in line by the time someone is in the house again. However they are a PITA to program (tiny cryptic LCD, 4 buttons) and basically useless if you don't follow a consistent daily routine on the weekdays. Nest's value proposition is to be smarter about when the house is actually occupied/going to be occupied. Also when you're traveling (or if you have it in a rarely-used property) you can remotely start the heat/AC when you're several hours away so that it's comfortable by the time you get there. I have none of these problems, so I don't have one, but they do solve a problem that some people really have.
- alextgordon 11y agoWe are talking about a manual dial here, not a programmable thermostat. "Hey it's too cold right now, better turn it up." In fact you will save money & energy with manual control because the heating will not turn on when it's cold but you are wearing enough layers.
- superuser2 11y agoI know, and I'm explaining why programmability is desirable for some people.