4 ms·
If you watch the unhappy early adopter YouTube videos of Nest thermostats, this outcome is pretty predictable. There's a level of quality control you need to pu
by stcredzero 11y ago
If you watch the unhappy early adopter YouTube videos of Nest thermostats, this outcome is pretty predictable. There's a level of quality control you need to put up a web app, which won't physically affect anyone if it happens to crash for awhile. Then there's a much higher level required when you're controlling things in the real world.
This outcome was predictable from the experience of those early adopters.
EDIT: Why couldn't Nest fall back to being a dumb thermostat? Lots of smart device makers should consider having such a fallback.
- mattbee 11y agoThe Nest comes in two parts - the "smart" bit with the USB charger & battery & wifi, and the Heat Link - the actual radio control for your boiler. The Heat Link has a big button on which lets you turn the heating on and off, overriding what the Nest is telling it. That's not as economical as a regular thermostat, but it means you won't freeze: https://nest.com/uk/support/article/How-do-I-turn-the-heat-on-if-the-Nest-Thermostat-isn-t-working https://nest.com/uk/support/article/How-do-I-turn-the-heat-o...
- mattbee 11y agoOh, OK, you don't have that in the US apparently. Why's it necessary?
- HillRat 11y agoAlmost all US central heat and air systems are "forced air" -- gas or electric heaters (furnaces) that blow conditioned air through ducting. Boiler-radiator systems wouldn't work with the standard US thermostat, not least because US thermostats use low-voltage signaling.
- ghaff 11y agoI don't claim to be an expert but I have a forced hot water system (converted at some point from steam) and AFAIK it uses a "standard" thermostat. At least when I upgraded to a Honeywell programmable thermostat 15 years or so ago, I don't remember it being anything unusual. I bought a thermostat at the home improvement store and an electrician who was doing some other work installed it.
- quicklyfrozen 11y agoBoiler + hot water circulation through radiators is also pretty common in US and will also use a low voltage thermostat. The only exception I can think of is older gas-powered steam boilers which may use a millivolt thermostat (which have the advantage of working when the power is out). (Or electric baseboards...but who can afford to heat that way?)
- quesera 11y agoYou must be from a warm part of the U.S. Forced hot water systems are very common in the colder parts, and they use the same thermostat wiring as forced air. Some parts of the U.S. even use diesel fuel for heat (it's called #2 heating oil, but it's really just diesel fuel with pink dye added so they can fine you for using it as a vehicle fuel...it's taxed advantageously). Also, boiler-radiator systems can absolutely work with standard thermostats. The classic design has no electrical control at all, just bimetal valves (like car thermostats) to regulate the flow of heated water. But the modern revision uses the same kind of electrically controlled valves (24VAC, IIRC) that forced hot water does. All low-voltage thermostats with standardized wiring layouts. I didn't know the UK ran high voltage to ordinary thermostats though, that seems crazy if it's just a control circuit. Presumably the full mains voltage? Old U.S. "radiant" (electrical, non-hydronic) heat ran 220/240 VAC to big rheostats in each room, but that was actually the supply to the heating elements. It feels like something that wouldn't meet code today, but it used to be popular in some parts of the country where electricity was inexpensive.
- Aloha 11y agoIt still is popular, even in new construction, in the Pacific Northwest.
- makomk 11y agoYeah, UK central heating systems in homes use the full 240V for all their control wiring. It's worth bearing in mind that this isn't just signalling - the thermostat and timer directly switch the power to the pump and valves.
- jsight 11y agoIt looks like the UK version is a lot different: http://www.cnet.com/news/nest-thermostat-finally-arrives-in-the-uk-for-179-partners-with-npower/ http://www.cnet.com/news/nest-thermostat-finally-arrives-in-... https://nest.com/blog/2014/04/02/the-uk-just-got-a-little-more-comfy/ https://nest.com/blog/2014/04/02/the-uk-just-got-a-little-mo...
- jauer 11y agoUS thermostats usually use low-voltage wiring for signalling to the furnace or boiler. We usually only see line/mains voltage thermostats (that work by limiting current supplied to a electric heater) in cheap apartments. https://nest.com/support/article/How-can-I-tell-if-my-current-thermostat-is-low-voltage https://nest.com/support/article/How-can-I-tell-if-my-curren... The US version won't work with line voltage systems. It looks like the UK version only works with line voltage systems. This also explains why in the US changing a thermostat is something pretty much anyone can do but the UK version requires a Nest Pro to hook up. Nest US: "It's easy to install the Nest Thermostat. Everything you need comes in the box" Nest UK: "A Nest Pro installer should install your Nest Thermostat. They will identify cables from the boiler, zone valve or junction box to connect to the Heat Link."
- jedberg 11y agoThat must be a UK thing or something. I only have a single device. I know because I installed it myself -- there is definitely no manual override button, and I've never even heard of this Heat Link before.
- Animats 11y agoNest could fix this easily by including two fixed-temperature safety thermostats, devices which cost about $0.25 each. One is hard-wired to turn on heat below 55F. One is hard-wired to turn off heat above 80F. With that, no matter how badly they botch the software, the temperature will stay in a safe, if not totally comfortable, range.
- bigchewy 11y agomy a/c bill in AZ would be about $400-500 / mo higher in the summer if they made that move! Most people in AZ put their A/C to 87 or so if they aren't home and actually keep it in the high 70s even when home. Otherwise you're looking at $1K/mo energy bills in the summer
- QuercusMax 11y agoTurn off heat != turn on AC.
- bigchewy 11y agoreasonable point ;)
- trhway 11y agogiving those numbers ( $400+ means like 100KWh/day or more), it sounds like properly insulating your home is the way to go. In Bay Area, my 2/2 townhouse was built in 2004, so it is very well insulated. We have a small dog and thus keep pretty much the same temp 24/7/365. My bill rarely goes higher than $100 in winter / $50 in summer.