3 ms·
You have GOT to be trolling me. There is no way. The LHC collides TWO protons! The net velocity between them is zero. You seem to know at least some physics,
by ars 11y ago
You have GOT to be trolling me. There is no way.
The LHC collides TWO protons! The net velocity between them is zero.
You seem to know at least some physics, how can you possibly not know this?
But in your black hole scenario there are not two opposite velocities adding up at the horizon.
You can not just directly turn velocity into light, it's not possible, you need another object.
> Electromagnetic energy (heat and light) is a kind of kinetic energy.
Some people define only two kinds of energy: Potential and Kinetic, in that definition electromagnetic energy is a type of kinetic energy, and velocity is a type of kinetic energy.
But it does NOT follow that electromagnetic energy is the same as velocity energy!
It's like an apple is a fruit and an orange is a fruit, but an apple is not an orange.
> They actually think their gadget can convert near-light-speed velocities into many other kinds of energy, including electromagnetic, and the creation of particles from energy and the reverse.
I take it you've never heard of conservation of momentum? You can not just turn the velocity into other things, you have to react it with something else (which is what I said - go back and read it). In this case they react it with a proton going the other way.
They could also react it with the earth, or a slab of metal.
None of these apply to a black hole.
We have also gotten way off topic from time dilation.
- lutusp 11y ago> The LHC collides TWO protons! The net velocity between them is zero. Yes, but only because their original velocity has been converted into other forms of kinetic energy, like heat and light, among other things like Higgs bosons. Here is what you said: > Kinetic energy does not become heat and light. I proved your statement to be false. End of story. Now stop trolling.
- ars 11y agoLOL LOL LOL. You most certain did not. Is this like some kind of contest to you to see if you win? Even if you win, you'll still be wrong. Instead of focusing on that, why not actually learn something? "To make heat and light you need some other process." For example, another proton to crash into. You can't just directly convert the velocity to energy, you need another object take the velocity from you.
- lutusp 11y agoBefore: > Kinetic energy does not become heat and light. Now: > "To make heat and light you need some other process." Translation: "You were right." Apart from the fact that heat and light are kinetic energy. Further reading: http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/gravitational-wave-rumors-in-overdrive/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/gravitational-wave... Quote from the above article: "LIGO's detectors, at their current sensitivity, could pick up only gravitational waves of frequencies well above 10 Hertz. So if they have picked up a signal, they would have captured the final stages of the drama, when the black holes circle more than 10 times per second, speeding up to several thousand times a second just before they merge. Simulations show that the resulting waves, if played as an audible sound, resemble a bird’s ‘chirp’ (http://www.ligo.org/science/GW-Inspiral.php http://www.ligo.org/science/GW-Inspiral.php) (http://www.ligo.org/science/GW-Overview/sounds/chirp40-1300Hz.wav http://www.ligo.org/science/GW-Overview/sounds/chirp40-1300H...)." My original remark from yesterday, to which you ignorantly objected: "... eventually two black holes will merge, which will produce a completely fantastic observation consisting of a rapidly rising frequency (as the two BHs circle each other closer and closer, shedding their orbital energy as gravitational waves), followed by a very loud cosmological pop as the BHs finally collapse into each other."
- ars 11y agoYou clearly have problems reading. I have said exactly the same thing the entire time, only you kept ignoring it. Or, to be charitable, maybe just not understanding it. Just because you don't understand the words I said, doesn't mean I didn't say it. Do you need me to quote myself? Also, I take it you did not ever study physics? If you did you would know this on your own without me telling you. What I said, over and over, is you can not turn velocity into light directly, you have to transfer that velocity to something else. In an event horizon there is nothing to transfer the velocity to, since everything is moving more or less at the same speed. I don't know why you can't seem to absorb this. I really don't. It's basic highschool physics, plus I've said it over and over and over and over. In as many different ways as I can think of. > Apart from the fact that heat and light are kinetic energy. Are you totally incapable of absorbing information? I know that sounds insulting, but I am serious. You keep saying the same wrong thing over and over despite being told different. You are wrong. Period. It's like you have a mental block stopping you from understanding this, I don't get it. > ... eventually two black holes will merge, which will produce a completely fantastic observation consisting of a rapidly rising frequency (as the two BHs circle each other closer and closer, shedding their orbital energy as gravitational waves), followed by a very loud cosmological pop as the BHs finally collapse into each other." Back to this, very nice. The problem is that they won't actually do this - time dilation means it will take infinite time for this to happen, so we'll never see this. Not sure what the point of telling you this is though. If you can't understand Conservation of Momentum there is zero chance you'll understand relativity. Try this - stop arguing with me. Clearly I'm not the teacher for you. Go find some other people - show them this thread if you like. Then have them explain Conservation of Momentum to you. Also ask them to explain the difference between kinetic and electromagnetic energy. Please do that before replying, otherwise we'll just be going in a circle.