5 ms·
This is actually an interesting question, IMO. But, I think you can quickly see the situation is not inherently symmetric, so the answer can't be either. Just
by dahart 11y ago
This is actually an interesting question, IMO. But, I think you can quickly see the situation is not inherently symmetric, so the answer can't be either.
Just one example - giving employees open access to company materials affects the privacy rights of other people, not just the company. So in order to protect the privacy rights you do have vs the company, they will have to restrict other people's access to your information.
The title of this article is misleading in the sense that the decision was that companies may inspect employees' PMs that originate from company computers. They did not make a blanket decision that the company may monitor personal phones or personal computers.
That highlights how the situation is not symmetric in the sense that you haven't loaned your computers to the company in order to produce their personnel files.
- p4wnc6 11y agoI agree with you that it wouldn't be perfectly symmetric and a number of difficult follow-on issues would arise. But, I see a lot of emphasis being placed on the fact that it was a company-owned machine and that it was ostensibly being used for company purposes. These two facts seem to underpin a lot of what everyone says. But ownership and mode of use are not the only kinds of resources or properties to think of. For example, at least in the US we have the concept of "company time" which covers the time periods during which you are performing an action sanctioned by a company. Could this be used to demand the ability to monitor employees during time periods when they are on company time? Likewise, there are a lot of gray areas going in the reverse direction -- from employee to employer. For example, it is true that HR records (say, for example, performance reviews written by my boss about solely me) are electronic files that are the property of the company, just like a computer workstation is property of the company. But, just as a computer workstation could be misused for personal use, and thus needs to be inspectable for compliance, so also the HR files could be misused for personal use (making jokes, talking about non-professional aspects of me, conspiring to deny a promotion simply due to personal preference, etc.) -- so why aren't such files open for inspection? Yet another interesting aspect of all of this is why we believe that not only must the workstation be made available for inspection, but further that it is the employer who gets to perform the inspection. Why isn't such inspection required to be handled by a third-party arbiter, much the way that tax and official records are required to be kept by a certified firm specializing in it. We don't trust companies to say, "Yep, these are my taxes and records, I swear I didn't lie or hide any money." We at least require some third-party to attest to that and stake a reputation on it (subverted though it may be). Yet with issues of inspection, we just sort of capitulate to this idea that the employer not only gets to raise the issue of suspicion about misuse, but also gets to be the authority on the investigation of whether or not misuse occurred, and to what extent employee privacy must be invaded to get all the relevant info.
- dahart 11y agoFor better or worse, companies do generally have the right to monitor you when you're on company time. All companies that I have personal experience with, large and small, recognize that doing so aggressively may lead to lower morale, employee mistrust, or lower productivity. So, they choose how they monitor carefully. Your primary agreement with the company is a trade of your time and skills in return for money, and the symmetric right you have is that you definitely do have the right to monitor and verify that you've been given the proper amount of money. > HR files could be misused [...] so why aren't such files open for inspection? In some places, they are open for inspection. There are laws in at least some US states that the company must show you your own personnel file, if you request it.
- p4wnc6 11y ago> Your primary agreement with the company is a trade of your time and skills in return for money Not really. The tradeoff is not just for money but for a spectrum of compensation, which could be equity (which could confer voting or board rights to you to monitor certain things about the company financial health), vacation time, conference attendance, foosball table access, etc. Often these things are negotiable, at least if the employer values talent. So why couldn't we negotiate that part of compensation is some sort of verifiable transparency and mutual respect in terms of monitoring the appropriateness of company activities (whether on behalf of the employer or employee)? I don't see any fundamental reason why these couldn't be negotiated as part of an employment agreement. Instead, what I see is that most employees either don't know or don't care about these items, and, more importantly, that employers actively collude and engage in e.g. regulatory capture specifically to deny workers the opportunity to be able to negotiate these things.
- dahart 11y ago> The tradeoff [...] could be equity (which could confer voting or board rights to you to monitor certain things about the company financial health) If you have that, then you have significantly elevated access to the information you were talking about, and you're already landing on the side of protecting the company. The issues you raised don't really apply here. > [...] vacation time, conference attendance, foosball table access, etc. If you value those on par with your salary, then I have a job for you! ;) > I don't see any fundamental reason why these couldn't be negotiated as part of an employment agreement. You're right, there is no reason. You can and should negotiate these things. Negotiate away! Just recognize that you may have multiple conflicting interests within yourself. If you want access to confidential company information about others, you're implicitly requesting that they have access to confidential information about you. Most of us wouldn't mind knowing everyone else's salary, and most of us don't want others to know ours. Most of us would love access to the personnel reviews of our co-workers, and most of us would be mortified to let them read ours.
- zepto 11y ago'Just one example - giving employees open access to company materials affects the privacy rights of other people, not just the company. So in order to protect the privacy rights you do have vs the company, they will have to restrict other people's access to your information." I'm not sure this is a good example. Bear in mind that 'the company' is just other employees. I am not aware of any particular set of 'rights' limiting which employees have access to your information - just policy which is entirely decided by the power hierarchy.