6 ms·
The Windows 10 privacy thing is completely overblown. Most of the privacy settings that people are most worried about is tied into Cortana or more specifically
by Someone1234 11y ago
The Windows 10 privacy thing is completely overblown.
Most of the privacy settings that people are most worried about is tied into Cortana or more specifically what you allow Cortana to do on your behalf. You can simply choose not to use Cortana or to disable it entirely. Google Now & Siri support the same functionality but ironically don't give you the settings to disable it, so nobody bats an eyelid.
Beyond that you only really have so called "basic telemetry." Which tells them when you launch a Windows 10 "app" and some basic computer information. But even without that setting/ability the apps themselves could conduct the same reporting (via direct HTTP requests), the only reason it is even a setting is because Microsoft unified it to make developers lives easier and to better aggregate the information their side.
Are people legitimately concerned that when they launch the XBox music app that Microsoft knows you did? Even without the Windows telemetry they could just look at their own server logs since the XBox Music app utilises so many web resources (e.g. images). The same is true with any developer, any app, on any platform.
Ultimately the whole thing is a bunch of noise and no substance. Nobody can actually point to exactly what specific information Microsoft is even taking, and have even less data yet still to back up any claims.
- Karunamon 11y agoThe Windows 10 privacy thing is completely overblown. Not when you consider the fact that they're being so damned sneaky about it. First, the idea that you have to run an enterprise OS to turn off (not "set to basic", but turn OFF) the tracking says volumes. Just by having it default would meet the goals of collecting development/troubleshooting/debugging info since most people won't change the defaults. Next up, there's the fact that Microsoft has gone out of their way to make it hard to turn off anyways by hard coding addresses and ignoring registry keys. The only way for a home user to stop all tracking is to firewall an ever changing list of IPs. Third, you do not know what they are tracking or not tracking. The communications are secure and the application closed source. It's more the attitude these actions belie than the actions themselves, IMO. It's a very quiet, but distinct disdain for the user. "Yes, you paid $100 for our OS, but you didn't think you actually controlled it, did you?" So... minus four in a short amount of time. Would anyone care to explain how I'm incorrect about any of this?
- magicalist 11y ago> Most of the privacy settings that people are most worried about is tied into Cortana or more specifically what you allow Cortana to do on your behalf In all of these discussions on HN, the only ones bringing up "worries" about Cortana features have been people defending Windows 10 (and now Windows 8 and 7) data collection. It's easy to disable and, if you choose not to use it, it won't collect data anyways. The same can't be said of telemetry. > Which tells them when you launch a Windows 10 "app" and some basic computer information Actually it's not clear what else is being collected, because Microsoft won't disclose what's being collected. Is there evidence that only data about usage of Windows store apps is being collected? > But even without that setting/ability the apps themselves could conduct the same reporting Which would be needed to take into account when deciding on if that app should be used. Just to be clear, that means the application I choose to run might be collecting analytics, but my OS is also collecting analytics on the applications I'm choosing to run because it thinks it should. > Nobody can actually point to exactly what specific information Microsoft is even taking Yes, because Microsoft won't tell anyone what it's collecting! > and have even less data yet still to back up any claims As a baseline, you yourself talked about how we know they're collecting information about application usage. That right there is undesirable behavior for many that we have plenty of evidence for.
- sqeaky 11y agoEven if microsoft told, that doesn't mean we should automatically trust it. The could be wrong or lying. I would prefer source code, but someone will eventually do packet captures to figure at least some of it out.
- Someone1234 11y agoGo ahead and provide evidence that they're wrong or lying. People have been drum beating this privacy stuff for over six months now. But they seem to lack specific evidence, so now I invite you to present it.
- DoubleMalt 11y agoIt would be easy to dispel the accusations by open sourcing windows [/troll]
- ksk 11y agoIt is not overblown. I'm very happy that Microsoft is getting bad press. Hopefully this drives people away from Windows. This is the only way Microsoft "listens". When their revenue takes a hit. The primary issue with Windows 10 is how Microsoft is forcing people to upgrade to it. The secondary issue is with the lack of controls given to users. I don't want certain Win 7 machines that I own/maintain to ever upgrade to Windows 10. Didn't ask for it. Don't want it. Just go away and let me do my job. Microsoft provides me no official way to disable that horrendous popup. I expect that shit from shady browser toolbars, and bundled crapware, not Microsoft. Microsoft seems to think the users can't be trusted with options to disable Updates, Telemetry, and other BS services. I absolutely HATE having to ever reboot my windows machine. It is extremely critical for me to have my dev box be rock stable and running 24/7. I frequently used to go months without ever rebooting it. Also, with Win 7 I could just set the Update behavior to "don't call us, we'll call you". With Windows 10 I'm forced to muck around with services and group policy just to get my machine to update and reboot on my schedule, rather than Microsoft's. As a customer of MS, I despise these methods, as I continue to use their OS, because there simply isn't any other alternative. All I can hope for is people who don't specifically need Windows to switch to other OSs en masse. At this point I could be swayed into thinking that its a good idea to support anti-microsoft efforts even if they are not based in facts (as you point out, nobody has shown exactly what they collect), just to obtain the result that you want.
- k33n 11y ago> As a customer of MS, I despise these methods, as I continue to use their OS, because there simply isn't any other alternative. There are many alternatives to using Windows as your host OS.
- ksk 11y agoYes, and they're appropriate for many use-cases, just not mine.
- tracker1 11y agoIf worm trending and huge botnets are any indication, for the most part, users can't be trusted to disable updates and telemetry data.
- criddell 11y agoA lot of small medical and dental practices operate on one or two PCs. Windows doing things like uploading your calendar and address books could end up being a HIPAA violation. Enterprise customers are fine because they have controls for everything, but small offices running Windows 10 Pro aren't so lucky.
- Someone1234 11y agoOn all versions of Windows 10 you can disable OneDrive, and thus it will not upload locally stored calendars or address books.
- abrookewood 11y agoIt's actually REALLY HARD to disable OneDrive. I've tried about 3 separate methods and the damn thing keeps re-appearing. From what I read, it looks like Group Policy might work, but I don't have AD in our environment and haven't been able to test it.
- Someone1234 11y agoYou don't need AD to set the local security policy. Just type "gpedit.msc" into run. Then follow this[0]. [0] https://support.office.com/en-US/article/Turn-off-or-uninstall-OneDrive-f32a17ce-3336-40fe-9c38-6efb09f944b0 https://support.office.com/en-US/article/Turn-off-or-uninsta...
- criddell 11y agoThat makes me terribly uncomfortable because Microsoft is likely to just silently turn it back on in the future. I used Powershell scripts to uninstall a bunch of the bloatware (XBox Music, Money, etc...) and they just come back. It's very frustrating.
- abrookewood 11y agoSame thing happened to me. Drives me crazy.
- gbanfalvi 11y ago> You can simply choose not to use Cortana or to disable it entirely. Google Now & Siri support the same functionality but ironically don't give you the settings to disable it, so nobody bats an eyelid. Siri can be disabled. Location tracking to improve contextual understanding can be disabled separately if you don't want to disable Siri completely. If you disable Siri, all data is deleted. You're also informed of exactly what data is uploaded. > Beyond that you only really have so called "basic telemetry." Which tells them when you launch a Windows 10 "app" and some basic computer information. But even without that setting/ability the apps themselves could conduct the same reporting (via direct HTTP requests), the only reason it is even a setting is because Microsoft unified it to make developers lives easier and to better aggregate the information their side. Does Microsoft let you disable this? Apple offers you a prompt like this one http://imgur.com/aBzTNsV http://imgur.com/aBzTNsV on every major (x.y) update, and shows you what data is being uploaded (as well as letting you disable it) in settings.
- hackuser 11y agoSome factual background: "Microsoft Builds Trove From Windows 10 User Data To Support Bing, Cortana" http://www.mediapost.com/publications/article/266374/ http://www.mediapost.com/publications/article/266374/
- rohmish 11y agoI am fine if they collect basic anonymous telemetry data to track user patterns and find out system stability and such only if they specifically state all the parameters they collect. Plus them collecting data from windows 8(.1) and 7 users without any proper warning/message to user is wrong.