3 ms·
I appreciate that you refuse to accept an explanation until it completely makes sense to you, but it sounds like you're attached at a gut level to some basic mi
by jessriedel 11y ago
I appreciate that you refuse to accept an explanation until it completely makes sense to you, but it sounds like you're attached at a gut level to some basic misconceptions. (In particular: it's not just that local clocks appear to run at different rates, it's that ticks of two separated clocks do not always have a meaningful one-to-one mapping, so it's often not possible to assign a sensible time that a particular event happens according to a clock held by an outside observer.) Those misconceptions won't be cleared up unless you're staring the math in the face.
Grab an intro GR textbook and work through it. There are free ones online.
- ars 11y agoI did, after I studied it more is when I realized black holes can't form. That's when I found that others have noticed it to, and called it an "eternally collapsing object" (ECO). > so it's often not possible to assign a sensible time that a particular event happens according to a clock held by an outside observer. That's not completely accurate. The two can not assign the SAME time to some event happening - it might happen at different times for the two. But it IS possible to say when the even will happen from ONE of their points of view. It just might not be the same time as what the other one sees.
- daxfohl 11y agoNB I haven't studied it at all, beyond a high school level AP class touching on special relativity 20 years ago. That said, this was spinning in my head last night and now totally makes sense to me. From the faller's perspective time slows down until the black hole evaporates in front of you (Hawking radiation), leaving you in a universe a billion years in the future. Or if the hole is eternal, you get crushed by every particle ever destined for that black hole hitting you at once (since the rest of the universe speeds up from your perspective). Not to mention the inward-facing part of your brain would not be able to send signals to the outward-facing part, so you'd be pretty screwed there too. That said, I doubt physicists would have overlooked this for 100 years when they pretty consistently say you'd fall into the hole unscathed and not even know you'd passed the horizon, so I'm sure this is wrong.
- ars 11y ago> until the black hole evaporates in front of you (Hawking radiation) There would not be Hawking radiation since the black hole has not formed. > That said, I doubt physicists would have overlooked this for 100 years Other people have noticed this too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternally_collapsing_object https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternally_collapsing_object It doesn't seem to get as much attention, I think because there is less interesting math there to do research on.
- daxfohl 11y agoHawking radiation is just spontaneous quantum particle pairs caused by the strong gravitational field, where one reaches escape velocity, reducing the mass of the object. This would still occur, whether you call it Hawking radiation or not.
- jessriedel 11y agoYes, I'm well aware of the reasons to dispute the reality of the manifold patch corresponding to the interior of the BH, which are based directly on the arguments I gave above. But this > But it IS possible to say when the even will happen from ONE of their points of view. It just might not be the same time as what the other one sees is again demonstrating that you don't understand how time coordinates work in GR. There is not a unique way to extent an observer's proper time to a time coordinate on an entire manifold, and different extensions are incompatible. Some of those extensions, as I said, give a finite time for BH formation. I think you're more interested in axe-grinding that teaching or learning, so I'm going to call it quits on this one.