4 ms·
Good people working for bad companies have some small ability to change culture. "Is this legal?", "Do I need a warrant to do this intercept?", "Is this compat
by DanBC 11y ago
Good people working for bad companies have some small ability to change culture.
"Is this legal?", "Do I need a warrant to do this intercept?", "Is this compatible with our rules?", "What would our regulators say if they knew we did this?", "How will the oversight and scrutiny committee respond to this action?"
It's not much, but it's about as good as me from the outside writing a letter to my MP which is about all I can do.
EDIT: to expand on this a bit. Imagine you're a mathematician and that you have a neuro-diversity. In the past you may have struggled to get a job because employers sometimes discriminate against neuro-atypicality. GCHQ definitely does not do so - they mention in press releases they recognise the advantages of neuro-diversity. So one option would be something like the Heilbronn Institute for Mathematical Research. As an employer Google gives you 20% time. Heilbronn gives you 50% time, 50% of the time you're doing work directed by GCHQ/CESG, the rest of the time you do what you like. That is potentially interesting maths with interesting people. The money at GCHQ isn't great compared to the SV bubble, but for the UK it's okay, and there other benefits.
http://www.bristol.ac.uk/maths/research/heilbronn/ http://www.bristol.ac.uk/maths/research/heilbronn/
http://web.maths.bris.ac.uk/research/heilbronn_institute/ http://web.maths.bris.ac.uk/research/heilbronn_institute/
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/educationnews/11111584/GCHQ-employs-more-than-100-dyslexic-and-dyspraxic-spies.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/educationnews/11111584/...
- a3n 11y agoA professor in college suggested to me that if good people don't work for defense companies, then only bad people will be working in defense companies.
- forgotpasswd3x 11y agoWith everything revealed in the Snowden leaks, it doesn't seem like the good people are having much of an impact.
- vocatus_gate 11y agoI left the NSA a few months ago after working for them four years for that very reason. I realized nothing I did was going to affect what they were doing, and while I personally couldn't effect any change, I could at least leave and not contribute to it. So I did.
- pvnick 11y agoI just wanted to say that reading your comment was encouraging and made me happy.
- chinathrow 11y agoThanks for posting this.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoDid you consider IAD or one of the defense contractors focused on highly-secure technology? Hell, even groups doing R&D funded by NSF or DARPA on secure systems work. There's a ton of stuff going on out there that either (a) benefits security of government/military or (b) could benefit everyone at some point. I can understand if (a) didn't interest you but being ex-NSA might help with positions doing (b). Not sure how INFOSEC people would react given the climate, though. Wise ones should see a skill and character reference from getting and quiting the job respectively.
- pdkl95 11y agoThank you not only for posting this, but also for refusing to contribute.
- ionised 11y agoI commend you for your decision.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoAt that point, why should there even be private defense companies? Why do we accept that weapons manufacturing is outside of democratic control and civilian restraint?
- a3n 11y agoInteresting question. I have no idea one way or the other, I've never studied economics beyond 101. An exploration of that question might include why the US relied on private industry for WWII military needs, rather than building its own factories or taking over existing ones.
- Zigurd 11y agoThe US effectively commandeered private industry in WWII. They were compensated, but that was nothing like the current military weapons procurements system.
- a3n 11y agoBut they were still private. Under orders, just like individual citizens were under orders, with the draft and rationing. It was arguably an existential threat. But the commandeered private industry was what the current MIC grew from. It wouldn't have happened without WWII.
- ethbro 11y agoIt's not outside of civilian control and democratic restraint in the US. It's just an extremely convoluted route from that to the end product. In fact, we'd probably get a better deal if there were less so. The amount of money wasted on politically-supported but infeasible/impractical systems is mind boggling.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- logicallee 11y agoThis contains a hidden logical error. For example, no good people are working to simulate the original ENIAC at the vacuum tube level on the Apple watch. But no bad people are working on it either.
- late2part 11y agoThat didn't work out so well for Edward Snowden.
- finid 11y ago> That didn't work out so well for Edward Snowden. And that's the whole point of making a sacrifice. Not everything has to work out in your favor. If a man cannot sacrifice even his life and well being for a greater good, what type of person is he?
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"Good people working for bad companies have some small ability to change culture." Let me stop you right there. I see where you're going but I'm going to interject that the nature and incentives an organization matter a lot. Palantir, starting with founders & investors, is set up to provide as much data analysis capability as possible to as many as possible. It's especially going to do this for government given it's aiming at public sector contracts and has In-Q-Tel as an investor. I can't be sure but wouldn't be surprised if the latter prevents them from saying no to benefiting intelligence community. All together, every aspect of how this business is set up will push corporate and government surveillance. Nobody or even a small group of them will change that. It's intrinsic to their business. So, anyone joining will be 99% contributing to that and maybe 1% making a difference... if they're lucky. So, nature of an organization and whether it allows a given change should be considered first. Then, lines of reasoning like yours follow from there. Palantir looks worst than most in this respect.
- rubberstamp 11y agogood people joining bad companies can do nothing about it unless they are going to join as its ceo. good people(those who have high morals) will never work for these kinda company on a matter of principle. some good people with slightly less moral either become complacent in this as the money is good n they will turn a blind eye as each day pass. some others will try to blow whistle n get crushed. the evil people end up running the place. those who have the power to quickly change the attitude of system is the goddamn president
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"good people joining bad companies can do nothing about it unless they are going to join as its ceo." It's worse than that. Even CEO's answer to someone: the owners or the board. So, if those want evil course of action, even most CEOs' hands are going to be tied. The people with the greatest impact are probably the VC's given they can fund what they want to see happen. They can create a lot of good by funding things that are both marketable and positive for society. Anyone below owner has no guarantee of doing anything out of the parameters of the company. It's the nature of capitalism and often business in general.