4 ms·
> Meanwhile we have actually succeeded in making our discipline a science, and in a remarkably simple way: merely by deciding to call it "computer science." We
by rdtsc 11y ago
> Meanwhile we have actually succeeded in making our discipline a science, and in a remarkably simple way: merely by deciding to call it "computer science."
Well not only that but we actually stuffed two misnomers in there. It is not really a science, and it is not really about computers. Chip design, graphics, storage, input devices is more about computers as such.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- eng_monkey 11y agoOf course CS is a (formal) science.
- rdtsc 11y agoIs it though? It can certainly be formal. But so is logic, so is mathemetics. I am not sure there is a clear consensus if math is a science. I can go with engineering (but licensed engineers might object to that), art or craft perhaps.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoCS is a funny beast. It's the first time we're seriously dealing with machines executing abstract math directly. There's nothing to study via experimentation - computing is pure math, and hardware stuff is pure engineering (since computation is not tied to particular branch of physics - you can make computing run on anything, not just electrons and photons). It's best to conceptually split the two, if we want to stay with the original terminology. But I guess now it's kind of too late - it's the definition of the word 'science' that will get relaxed.
- mpweiher 11y ago> There's nothing to study via experimentation There isn't??
- kevinwang 11y agoWhat part of computer science is experimentation?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mpweiher 11y agoI am tempted to write: "what part isn't?" Seriously, just about everything we do in computer science is experimentation, at least if it involves...physical computers. Every time we run a program, we run an experiment. At least if we have some expectation of what we want the program to do. Every time we write a test, or run a test suite, we are running an experiment. Every time we implement some sort of abstraction, every time we vary a parameter, every time we optimize a program, we are running experiments. At least if we're doing it right. If you're not doing experiments, I have a hard time categorizing what you are doing as computer science.
- ggreer 11y agoYou're describing software engineering, not computer science. CS is big-O, Chomsky hierarchy, finite automata, type theory, and computability classes. It's the study of algorithms & data structures, not their implementations. In other words, CS is a branch of math.
- mpweiher 11y agoYou're describing theoretical computer science: Theoretical computer science is a division or subset of general computer science and mathematics that focuses on more abstract or mathematical aspects of computing and includes the theory of computation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theoretical_computer_science https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theoretical_computer_science
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThat's not the kind of experiment I meant. In physics, we do experiments because we don't know the rules of the natural world. That's the only way we can learn them. In CS/programming, if we're doing any experiments, they're done because we're too stupid to infer the right answer beforehand. Insofar as you're dealing with the theoretical part of the problem, you shouldn't need any experiments, because the results are purely mathematic and should be perfectly predictable. And if you're doing hardware experiments, it's not computer science either - that's electrical engineering or applied physics. Whatever other tests you may be doing to save some time are still the engineering type. The point is, computer science doesn't have any area in which it could use experiments for discovery. It's fair to say then, that it's not really a science. (It's also fair to point out that the line between science and engineering is getting blurry nowadays.)
- majewsky 11y agoI've heard mathematics classified as a "structural science", as opposed to the "natural sciences". Theoretical CS fits into that "structural science" umbrella term very well.
- rdtsc 11y agoOk I can see that. Though I never heard the term "structural science". At least in US I most people talk about Science and Math. Math is explicitly not included in the "Science" category because it is mentioned separately. Otherwise it would be like saying "Engineering and Chemical Engineering".
- crimsonalucard 11y ago>Chip design, graphics, storage Actually all these things are studied in "computer science." At least, I did at my school.
- rdtsc 11y agoWell not in mine. Computer engineering and hardware design were in a separate college even.
- Munksgaard 11y agoPeter Naur (who unfortunately passed away recently) suggested the term "datalogy", to indicate that computer science doesn't necessarily have anything to do with computers, but instead is about the treatment of data[0]. The term "datalogi" is actually used in Denmark instead of "computer science". 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_science#Name_of_the_field https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_science#Name_of_the_f...
- randomsearch 11y agoHow does this fit with, say, designing an ergonomic phone interface? Or constructing quantum computers using optics? I think this is another example of one person calling Computer Science what they would like it to be, because of their background.
- majewsky 11y agoDesigning an ergonomic phone interface can be grouped under communication design, thus art. Constructing a quantum computer using optics clearly falls into the physics department, at least until physics spins off an engineering department for quantum stuff, like it spun off mechanics and electronics in earlier centuries. I consider the term "computer science" historically motivated and anachronistic. Similar to how old people would stereotypically describe their child's job as "something with computers", we muddled subtopics of various sciences together just because they're doing "something with computers". With computing technology and methodology now permeating nearly all areas of science, art, and engineering, maybe it's time to tear down the computer science departments and reintegrate their pieces back into the appropriate departments. Or maybe we shouldn't, for we would lose the extremely diverse curriculum that a CS degree includes.