4 ms·
That's not what the commenter said. Don't confuse opposition to bad ideas with hatred of people who hold similar ideas. In some cases it is the idea that shap
by nitrogen 11y ago
That's not what the commenter said. Don't confuse opposition to bad ideas with hatred of people who hold similar ideas.
In some cases it is the idea that shapes the people, and those ideas must be contested.
- acdha 11y agoIt is in fact exactly what the commenter said: “a specific religion”, “holding Islam to the standard of modernity”, rejecting half of the Quran as trash, etc. are blanket references to an entire major world religion. I cannot say whether it was due to bigotry or gross ignorance but neither is helpful to anyone other than groups like ISIS or their fortunately less-successful Christian fundamentalist counterparts who are trying to spin this as a war between religions.
- nitrogen 11y agoThe comment said "Islam", but you said "Muslims". There's a difference in this case. I think the meta point behind that comment is that cultures, philosophies, and religions need to excise harmful ideologies from themselves for human rights to progress. Some forms of Christianity need to remove their hatred of gays or other races. Some forms of American culture need to value non-American life more highly. Some forms of Islam need to discard their love of theocracy, male superiority, and jihad. Though you've probably heard plenty of Muslim bashing and "Christians vs. Muslims" idiocy, that's far from what's going on here in this discussion. It needs to be possible for us to separate people and ideas in our minds, so we can elevate people while dismissing the harmful ideas that motivate harmful behavior.
- acdha 11y agoThat's all fine and dandy but none of that nuance is in the comment you're defending so I'm not sure why you're trying to retcon it in now. That's what made it so strikingly offensive: it's trying to portray 1.6 billion people in many countries around the world as a uniform group with a single belief.