3 ms·
It's not the people who provide goods who should be prosecuted but the people who carry out the actual bad who must be held to account. On the other hand, Chi
by mc32 11y ago
It's not the people who provide goods who should be prosecuted but the people who carry out the actual bad who must be held to account.
On the other hand, China [or any country with baddies, perh including our own] is a sovereign government and beside some economic pressure I don't know there is much more we should be able to do. Unless Cisco violated some commercial embargo or egregiously violated export law, etc.
- hyperdunc 11y agoWhen engaging with a prospective customer, why should corporations not make a moral judgement about how their goods and services will be used?
- nitrogen 11y agoIf one is not careful, that idea leads to backwater businesses bringing back racial segregation, etc. Rather, I think human rights should be vigorously protected and clearly defined to avoid such slippery slopes.
- vanattab 11y agoWhat? How does the parents comment, which suggested that corporations should consider moral implementations along side the economic ones when making decisions, lead to racial segregation?
- nitrogen 11y agoThe same moral arguments are used to justify discrimination. Businesses today in the US are refusing to provide healthcare to employees (Hobby Lobby), or refusing to serve certain sexual orientations (various wedding services), and they claim it's because they are morally opposed to whatever group they discriminate against. 60 years ago, the same moral rhetoric justified forced racial segregation in the US. So when we say companies should refuse to serve customers on moral grounds, we have to be sure just which morals we're talking about.
- witty_username 11y agoCorporation feels it is more moral to employ white people and give more pay to them. Or that it isn't moral to allow homosexuals into the company.
- Qwertious 11y agoIt depends on whose morality system you use - some people are racist, and if they hold you accountable for not adhering to their moral practices (which are incompatible with normal moral standards), then you end up with the businesses implementing racist practices too.
- SixSigma 11y agoSo the U.S. should just let anyone export nuclear weapons manufacturing information and these trade restrictions lifted? http://www.state.gov/strategictrade/overview/ http://www.state.gov/strategictrade/overview/
- mc32 11y agoIf the gov't were to lift restrictions, yes. What restrictions against export did Cisco violate? As it is, countries with weapons manufacturers allow their firms to engage in sales to lots of regimes who ate known to engage in all sorts of rights violations. Only occasionally are embargoes or sanctions imposed. I dont see where Cisco violated any international embargo.
- kbart 11y agoThat's how evil things happen. This phenomena is called diffusion of responsibility[0] and lead to some of the most evil actions in human history. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffusion_of_responsibility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffusion_of_responsibility
- mc32 11y agoDo you think the eff should make moral judgments on its donors and only accept donations from morally acceptable people? Maybe it should be their responsibility to ensure their income only comes from people with whom they are morally compatible. And alternatively donors ensure that principals and associates of the eff are also moral.
- kbart 11y agoSorry, I don't see how that's relevant. EFF does no evil (as far as I'm concerned), but let's hypothetically say, if one day we found out that EFF helps some foreign government to repress their people, sure everyone supporting EFF now should feel morally obligated to stop their funding.
- mc32 11y agoYour interpretation is off. I'm asking, what if some of their donations come from people or governments who are misogynists, racists, tax cheats, etc. Should the eff figure out the "dirtiness" of the moneys they receive as the eff is asking Cisco to eval the morality of one of the sources of their income.
- kbart 11y agoI understand where you are aiming, but getting money through (anonymous) donation and actively promoting and selling products that you know (as can be seen on slideshow) will be used persecute people is not the same. To answer your question, if some shady character donates money to EFF without asking anything in return and using it as PR, I don't see anything wrong with that.
- celticninja 11y agowhat happens when the 'bad' cannot be carried out without the goods in question? Aren't the providers of the goods then complicit in the bad, especially when they have knowledge of how their goods are going to be used.