3 ms·
> eventually two black holes will merge ... as the two BHs circle each other closer and closer I've heard this so many times, and I still don't see how it's po
by ars 11y ago
> eventually two black holes will merge ... as the two BHs circle each other closer and closer
I've heard this so many times, and I still don't see how it's possible! Because of time dilation this merger will take infinite time.
No one has ever explained this satisfactorily to me. Why do people just seem to completely ignore relativity when dealing with black holes?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- NolF 11y agoAs I understand it, time only "slows" from the BH frame. From an observer POV it would happen as described.
- ars 11y agoOther way around actually.
- daxfohl 11y agoIt would take infinite time to an observer outside the horizon. It would probably look something like a cell dividing, in reverse, over infinite time, such that the end result is indistinguishable from a single hole.
- jessriedel 11y agoThis is the exact same conceptual issue as the formation of a single black hole (BH). Consider a spherical shell of matter (i.e. GR dust) collapsing inwards to form a BH. As the dust particles get closer and closer together, one can roughly say that time slows down for them and that none of the particles ever pass through their mutual horizon. Rather, the argument goes, the particles just becomes exponentially close to where that horizon would form. From the outside, this is indistinguishable from a BH for all practical purposes, since the only way to isolate the still-free dust particles is to zoom exponentially close to the horizon and then drag yourself out (which requires an exponential amount of energy). The problem with this argument is that there is no preferred global time coordinate with respect to which you declare that "the BH has formed". Rather, the spacetime events corresponding to "each dust particle crosses their mutual horizon" (i.e., "the formation of the BH"), along with the rest of the interior of the BH, comprise an additional spacetime region you can choose to attach to your manifold or not. This is a free choice because causality flows one-way across the boundary; no experiments outside the BH can be sensitive to whether the region "really" exists. There are multiple ways to extend the normal time coordinates (at infinity) into the interior of the BH, and a natural choice is the proper time of in-falling particles/observers. In that case, the BH definitely forms at a finite values of that time coordinate. Merging two existing BHs doesn't introduce new fundamental issues. Quantum mechanics does introduce new fundamental issues, but formally the jury is still out on whether it resolves this question. The majority opinion is that the interior of the BH exists just as much as regions beyond your cosmological horizon (in an expanding cosmology) exist, from which you are likewise causally disconnected
- ars 11y ago> This is the exact same conceptual issue as the formation of a single black hole (BH). I know. No one has ever explained how those can form either. > From the outside, this is indistinguishable from a BH for all practical purposes Except without the physics breaking properties of black holes. So not the same at all. > The problem with this argument is that there is no preferred global time coordinate with respect to which you declare that "the BH has formed". I don't need a global time, my own time frame is perfectly fine with me. If a black hole can never form, as viewed by me, then black holes don't exist. > This is a free choice because causality flows one-way across the boundary This presupposes the black hole exists already, but we have not gotten there yet. First it has to form, and it can not. > and a natural choice is the proper time of in-falling particles/observers. In that case, the BH definitely forms at a finite values of that time coordinate. It gets interesting here - what does happen from the POV of that particle? I suspect it never sees a black hole. This particle is moving exponentially close to the speed of light, relative to the center of mass of the forming black hole. This means that time is stopped for the center of mass of the black hole from the POV of the particle, which means the center of mass can never form a black hole since it can never do anything at all (since time is stopped for it).
- lutusp 11y ago> If a black hole can never form, as viewed by me, then black holes don't exist. But they do -- the evidence is copious: http://www.galacticcenter.astro.ucla.edu/animations.html http://www.galacticcenter.astro.ucla.edu/animations.html Arguing that, because the event horizon collapses the time dimension (from the perspective of a distant observer), therefore BHs aren't real, is like saying that sum(2^-n,(n,1,oo)) can't equal 1 because it's an infinite series and an infinity of additions takes too long. Think of black holes as objects of great mass, that have very bright accretion disks, surrounding an event horizon that is perpetually almost forming a singularity but never quite completes it (from the perspective of someone far from the horizon). > This means that time is stopped for the center of mass of the black hole ... From the perspective of a distant observer, the time horizon is located at the event horizon.
- 11y ago
- lutusp 11y ago> Why do people just seem to completely ignore relativity when dealing with black holes? It's true that, at and below the event horizon, spacetime curvature is such that time hasn't its usual meaning, but this doesn't mean two BHs cannot orbit closer and closer and eventually merge. Such events take place primarily outside the event horizon. This video -- http://www.galacticcenter.astro.ucla.edu/animations.html http://www.galacticcenter.astro.ucla.edu/animations.html -- diagrams stars orbiting close to the BH said to be at the center of our galaxy (in fact these orbits give us an estimate of the BH's mass). So if stars can orbit a BH, then a BH can orbit a BH, and the latter would orbit in normal spacetime, at least until the merger. > Because of time dilation this merger will take infinite time. Only from the perspective of the event horizon and below. Remember that "above" the event horizon, time still has its usual meaning, even though it's greatly modified compared to time on Earth's surface (which is also slightly dilated in GR).
- ars 11y agoThey can orbit, yes. But they will take infinite time to actually merge though. > Remember that "above" the event horizon, time still has its usual meaning The closer they get to that event horizon the slower time goes, so they will take longer and longer to orbit.
- lutusp 11y ago> But they will take infinite time to actually merge though. Yes, from the perspective of a distant observer. From the perspective of an observer falling into the BH, time will pass in the usual way, indeed it must. > The closer they get to that event horizon the slower time goes, so they will take longer and longer to orbit. Only from the perspective of a distant observer. This might explain why black holes last as long as they do, from the perspective of a distant observer. For all we know, they all blow up in short order from the perspective of an observer falling into one.
- ars 11y agoI am speaking about the distant observer though. I am speaking the search for gravity waves. If, us, that distant observer, never see the black holes merge, then what does that mean for the gravity waves?