5 ms·
Obviously not of the same gravity, but a good part of my childhood was spent being called by my big brother's name. Family, friends, teachers, you name it. It's
by grownseed 11y ago
Obviously not of the same gravity, but a good part of my childhood was spent being called by my big brother's name. Family, friends, teachers, you name it. It's a hard one, because I think my brother is an amazing guy, and evidently so do other people, but it's ultimately belittling.
A math teacher, who had my brother for a single year, called me by his name for the whole three years I knew/had her. By that point, it's not just offending, you just start thinking your identity is just a proxy for the other person's, it's downright depressing.
My brother and I look very much alike, to the point that to the untrained eye we would look like twins at certain points of our lives. Although around my teens, this had some unfortunate consequences, such as girls my age I fancied who would meet my older brother and see a better physical version of me in him, and forget about me. I can't really blame them, but again, not exactly uplifting.
It isn't an issue at all these days, we have very different lives and personalities, we live thousands of miles away, but mostly, my brother is alive and well, and I guess, not famous ; but it's definitely had an effect on me when I was younger.
I guess I came here to relate, but the truth is I can't even begin to imagine the added constant reminder of a deceased relative, no matter how amazing they used to be, or maybe even particularly so. The fact that those reminders are people who, by and large, had nothing remotely resembling a relationship with the person in question, especially not of the kind siblings would, must be incredibly hurtful.
I feel deeply for Noah and I genuinely wish he can affirm his own identity, and that people will make an effort to do so after reading his touching story.
- frogpelt 11y agoThis has happened to me a lot in my life--in fact one of my high school teachers called me my brother's name the entire school year. But I didn't feel belittled. Some people are just bad with names. I've figured out how to break people of the habit: call them the name of their sibling. This fixes it real quick like.
- lotharbot 11y agoOne of my high school teachers had a rule that any time he called a student by a sibling's name, they got a point of extra credit. It happened most class periods to somebody, and that was with him being very deliberate about asking people to point it out and trying very hard not to do it.
- rdtsc 11y ago> just start thinking your identity is just a proxy for the other person's, I think that is why a lot of siblings end up doing opposite things -- ones likes math, the other start painting, one goes into the Army, the other one is anti-military. One likes to wear bright colors, the other likes all black. One goes to school on the East coast, the other goes to the West. Obviously people are different and will do and like different things -- but from my circle of acquintances it goes a bit beyond that when it comes to siblings. I think at some level, that is a way for individuals to define themselves, and that is in relation to their environment -- "I am who I am because I am not ...".
- eklavya 11y agoI guess it's a cultural thing. My sisters all went to the same schools and had mostly the same teachers. The sibling association was never a problem. If anything, it was a good feeling. They felt more connected or something.