11 ms·
Cisco Must Be Held Accountable for Aiding China’s Human Rights Abuses
- x5n1 11y agoOkay hold the US government for aiding in Saudi Arabia's human rights abuses. I don't know whether to cheer for things like this, though I do support works for improving human rights. For the most part they seem to be drops in the ocean of human rights abuse. And I don't know if it's doing anything to stop those abuses or just a control mechanism to make us feel like we are accomplishing something... while the biggest abusers and their supporters continue scot-free.
- newjersey 11y agoWe try to make push backs where we can. You're right though. It does feel futile. It must be so frustrating to work in human rights.
- CurtMonash 11y agoHuman rights theater is better than no attention paid to human rights at all. In particular the Helsinki Accords, which seemed empty when signed, seemed to wind up being influential a decade or so later. I've been sympathetic to human rights theater ever since. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_Accords https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helsinki_Accords
- delinka 11y agoGovernments of the world have to care about human rights abuses before someone with teeth can prosecute. I sincerely doubt anyone in power (elected, appointed, hired) in any government cares at all about random humans at distance. Especially if caring would affect their own quality of life.
- fratlas 11y agoI think you underestimate (some) people's humanity.
- x3n0ph3n3 11y agoNot that you are wrong, but likely you also overestimate people's humanity.
- frozenport 11y agoIts how you sell it, we could claim that it Cisco Systems is selling technology to a hostile government with the aim of subverting American hegemony. Which FYI, is exactly what it did.
- iofj 11y agoYou forget they probably put in a few NSA chips and "bugs" before shipping it. So ...
- voronoff 11y agoThat's an absurd proposition. Even if you have an incredibly cynical view of humanity, it's extremely unlikely to be unable to find someone in a government with power who holds any reasonable common position of the general populace.
- ivuycggc 11y agoThose people seem plenty OK to aide and assist an entity which tortures and commits war crimes, mass murder, genocide, so they have more common with a member of ISIS than they do with any sane human.
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoDelinka very specifically said any person in any position of governmental authority, including ones who were merely hired to do a job. Saying that, I dunno, the office manager at the local agriculture bureau is an insane terrorist and complicit in war crimes and genocide and is kinda stupid.
- delinka 11y agoI did not. I said "...with power." I doubt the office manager at the local agriculture bureau has any.
- guelo 11y agoOK EFF, you convinced me, I'll donate.
- StLCylone 11y agoSo should you since that device you are reading this on was most likely sourced there. Likely sourced by underpaid workers in virtual enslavement to Foxconn or some other component manufacturer. Not to mention living in a toxic environment so we can all have our electronic toys.
- Nutmog 11y agoDo you have a reference for "virtual enslavement" to Foxconn? Last I heard, people were lining up to get jobs there and with enough working hours, the pay was higher than what a university graduate makes. If you call paying people so much they don't want to leave "enslavement" then perhaps that's right, but it also means it's not really bad.
- StLCylone 11y agohttp://www.cnet.com/news/riots-suicides-and-other-issues-in-foxconns-iphone-factories/ http://www.cnet.com/news/riots-suicides-and-other-issues-in-...
- argonaut 11y agoFoxconn employs nearly a million people. You are going to get quite a few suicides no matter what you do. Their suicide rate is below the China population average.
- icebraining 11y agoNot just the Chinese average: during its worst year (2010), the rate was lower than in all 50 US states.
- lukedev 11y agoPurpose built tech provided to the Chinese government used to assist tracking, detainment and torture of individuals.
- icebraining 11y ago
- Nutmog 11y agoWhile I do think human rights are a good idea, the focus seems to be carefully selected to as to make "bad" countries look bad and western countries look good. For the US, it's OK to kill people as long as you do it a bit randomly in a war instead of being too targeted, or as long as you do it to foreigners not your own citizens and you try to kill them quickly instead of using deliberate torture. If you do use torture, it should be psychological (solitary confinement) rather than physical. It's also OK to kill people by leaving them in an unsafe environment surrounded by killers (poor neighborhoods) without providing enough security or enough income to buy their way out. It's also OK to kill them in the name of economic progress by allowing cars to drive at speeds which regularly cause death. Somehow we accept these things as tolerable or even necessary but we don't realize that classic "bad country tortures dissidents" human rights abuses are equally necessary - they do the same thing wars do - secure the positions of governments against people who want to take them over. Even the name "dissident" is misleading - If we called Falun Gong members "traitors", that might make them sound like bad people and engender less public sympathy. Cartoon about our patriotic biases: http://www.washingtonsblog.com/2015/03/glorious-leader-wicked-despot.html http://www.washingtonsblog.com/2015/03/glorious-leader-wicke... That said, it doesn't stop human rights abuses being wrong too.
- mikerichards 11y agoIt's also OK to kill them in the name of economic progress by allowing cars to drive at speeds which regularly cause death. That's a very bizarre statement, but very telling of why you would defend authoritarian regimes.
- DiabloD3 11y agoIt also completely ignores the fact that local and state governments in the US regularly try to reduce speed limits which often leads to higher accident and fatality rates.
- maffydub 11y agoI'm not disputing your comment, but can you provide a citation for this? I did a quick google but the only reference I could find was a report (editorial?) in the Wall Street Journal called "Highways are safe at any speed".
- tim333 11y agoIt seems clear Cisco knew their systems were going to be used against Falun Gong. Leaked Cisco presentation: "Cisco Confidential 57 © 2002, Cisco Systems The Golden Shield Project: Public Network Information Security Monitor System • Stop the network-related crimes • Guarantee the security and services of public network • Combat “Falun Gong” evil religion and other hostiles [Note: Statement of Government goals from speech government offical Li Runsen]" Then again it's going to be hard to show legally they were doing much more than helping China enforce it's laws. Still at least the embarrassment factor may put companies off from getting involved in this stuff. I hope the EFF case makes them release documents related to it.
- fixermark 11y agoI dunno. People still do business with IBM, and they worked with the German government on the census system that tracked victims of the holocaust during WWII. IBM's existant history didn't put Cisco off of doing business with China.
- csours 11y agoIBM kind of claims that their subsidiary was more or less nationalized during the Nazi period. [1] However squishy and self-serving that claim is, Cisco doesn't even have that defense. War and human rights were going through a discovery period from WWI through the 1970's. In the 2000's there's not really an excuse for not scrutinizing what your products will be used for around the world.
- csours 11y ago1. https://www-03.ibm.com/press/us/en/pressrelease/1388.wss https://www-03.ibm.com/press/us/en/pressrelease/1388.wss (too late to edit original comment, just realized I missed the link)
- cmurf 11y agoIBM did that work before the 1980 Filartiga v. Pena-Irala case, which is what enables the remedy being sought in this case. In the former case, those injuries are a part of history, whereas in the latter case they are on-going so it's also a question of standing.
- iofj 11y agoThe problem there is not the US government. The problem there is religion - a specific religion to be extact. Once we start actually holding islam to the standard of modernity we may make progress here, but as long as we shy away from criticizing and shaming the religion publicly - it will keep doing this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Human_Rights#Islamic_countries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Human... Meanwhile Saudi Arabia is the chair of the meeting that is supposed to oversee implementation of the treaty. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Human_Rights_Council#Saudi_Arabia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Human_Rights_Co... The guy that Saudi Arabia elected for this role has been convicted - multiple times - for abusing and locking up "personal assistants". The problem here is not the US supporting Saudi Arabia. We need to shame islam and take it kicking and screaming into the 20th century. Half of the quran needs to be declared to be toilet paper and nothing more, and then we can talk.
- acdha 11y agoAre all Christians to blame for e.g. Uganda's kill the gays law the same way you seem to believe all Muslims are for Saudi Arabia?
- nitrogen 11y agoThat's not what the commenter said. Don't confuse opposition to bad ideas with hatred of people who hold similar ideas. In some cases it is the idea that shapes the people, and those ideas must be contested.
- acdha 11y agoIt is in fact exactly what the commenter said: “a specific religion”, “holding Islam to the standard of modernity”, rejecting half of the Quran as trash, etc. are blanket references to an entire major world religion. I cannot say whether it was due to bigotry or gross ignorance but neither is helpful to anyone other than groups like ISIS or their fortunately less-successful Christian fundamentalist counterparts who are trying to spin this as a war between religions.
- mc32 11y agoIt's not the people who provide goods who should be prosecuted but the people who carry out the actual bad who must be held to account. On the other hand, China [or any country with baddies, perh including our own] is a sovereign government and beside some economic pressure I don't know there is much more we should be able to do. Unless Cisco violated some commercial embargo or egregiously violated export law, etc.
- hyperdunc 11y agoWhen engaging with a prospective customer, why should corporations not make a moral judgement about how their goods and services will be used?
- nitrogen 11y agoIf one is not careful, that idea leads to backwater businesses bringing back racial segregation, etc. Rather, I think human rights should be vigorously protected and clearly defined to avoid such slippery slopes.
- vanattab 11y agoWhat? How does the parents comment, which suggested that corporations should consider moral implementations along side the economic ones when making decisions, lead to racial segregation?
- nitrogen 11y agoThe same moral arguments are used to justify discrimination. Businesses today in the US are refusing to provide healthcare to employees (Hobby Lobby), or refusing to serve certain sexual orientations (various wedding services), and they claim it's because they are morally opposed to whatever group they discriminate against. 60 years ago, the same moral rhetoric justified forced racial segregation in the US. So when we say companies should refuse to serve customers on moral grounds, we have to be sure just which morals we're talking about.
- 11y ago
- ommunist 11y agoDon't blame the sword, blame the holder.
- hyperdunc 11y agoSwords cannot think. Cisco executives can.
- ivanca 11y agoIf you create a bomb that can destroy the universe, are you really gonna blame who pulls the trigger? Scale.
- SixSigma 11y agoIf holding swords is illegal, shouldn't we prosecute sword makers ?
- darkr 11y agoIf the sword makers design a sword specifically to kill members of a persecuted minority, then yes..
- Nutmog 11y agoCommon criminals also constitute a persecuted minority. What kind of criminal do you consider worthy of protection and what kind should get persecuted? Perhaps people should follow the law of the country they're in to avoid persecution. Don't publish state secrets in the US, don't have sex with other men in Saudi Arabia and don't broadcast anti-state messages in China.
- Aandre 11y agoUnexplained Mysteries....Must read http://goo.gl/1VBTyy http://goo.gl/1VBTyy
- mtgx 11y agoGlad this is finally coming to light. Every time I would mention it here that Cisco has built backdoors in its routers specifically to aid the Chinese government and later other governments as well, I would get downvoted. Cisco standardized the "lawful intercept" protocol for routers at the IETF, people! What did you think that meant?! The US government (hopefully after it elects a saner president) and other supposedly democratic countries as well, need to come together and 1) make it clear that you can't sell tools which you know are being used for mass censorship and mass surveillance that then leads to torture or assassinations and whatnot (I know, this definition will need to be cleaned up a bit), and 2) punish the companies that still disobey those rules severely. It's time for the democratic countries to act the way they say they are.
- Frqy3 11y agoThose 'democratic' countries you mention are using the same features themselves.
- SixSigma 11y agoObama is insane now ?
- Swannie 11y agoStop conflating backdoors and lawful intercept. Lawful intercept is a specific method of viewing traffic passing through a network device. It would be straightforward to build something, without it being a standard feature of vendor network devices, using a different standard feature of literally any enterprise level network device: port mirroring. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Port_mirroring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Port_mirroring Port mirroring exists for many reasons and is widely available on switches for things like IDS, troubleshooting, and performance monitoring (e.g. generating netflow on an different device than the switch). To use Cisco lawful intercept, you must already hold the highest admin privileges on the device. Cisco almost certainly built this feature for the US agencies. The ones it has been supplying internet routers to since the commercialisation of routers, a short time after the creation of the internet by... US agencies.
- pjmlp 11y agoIt is in cases like this that I remember all those stupid code of conduct trainings that companies like Cisco make their employees go through.
- EGreg 11y agoI can't believe this is happening today. I know that ideologies use humans to build organizations and do battle with each other, but I thought we were past the Stalinist purges and atheist totalitarianism. This makes anything the US does to Muslims pale in comparison. How does China grant freedom of religion to five religions only?
- faddat 11y agoI'm strongly in support of holding cisco accountable for this in any way, shape or form possible. ....but if we do that, where will we get routers with backdoors for us.gov from?
- Rasell 11y agoLionel Messi wins 5th time Ballon d’Or trophy http://goo.gl/IM6ikr http://goo.gl/IM6ikr
- nefitty 11y agowho the fuck are you EFF, why are you stirring up so much trouble, and who pays you?
- georgeek 11y agoI donate to them, as do many people who believe that they are doing good work overall.
- icebraining 11y agoReference: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10861391 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10861391
- k_sze 11y agoI'm Chinese and I have no idea what "douzhung" means. (It doesn't even seem to be valid pinyin.) Can somebody enlighten me and tell what the Chinese characters are?
- schuke 11y agoBernard Williams in his criticism of Utilitarianism imagined a scenario where a scientist is torn between feeding his family by helping develop an evil weapon, and refusing the offer knowing full well that the place will be filled by someone else anyway. Even if Cisco walked away from such deals, there would Chinese companies willing to fill their place. The Party developed hydrogen bombs and spaceships to stay in power. There seems to be little reason why they wouldn't do this themselves, if Cisco didn't play along. Actually, I would rather a company like Cisco that's partially under US jurisdiction and media scrutiny to do all the nasty work for the Party than an anonymous Chinese company doing the same thing.
- vithlani 11y agoWow! Cisco must be held accountable. And they will be, right after Tibet is free! Also after Bush and Co. are held accountable for the middle Easter mess.. oh wait... that doesn't apply. The EFF does not care about real criminals in their own country, only technical ones. The naivety of it....