3 ms·

Wow, this is a kinda ballsy ask. I see where Gimlet is going here and as a long listener of Startup I want to support something like this. But it seems like yo

Wow, this is a kinda ballsy ask. I see where Gimlet is going here and as a long listener of Startup I want to support something like this. But it seems like you're making money on a horrifying part of someone's life. All of their hard work and possibly other people's is slipping away and you're going to report that to the world? It was one thing to listen to the episodes about TDR because they had already achieved something great (getting into YC) and if they failed then at least they took a shot - you had something to cheer for. I'm just saying, it's one thing to get the story of someone who failed and what it took out of them. That could be uplifting and educational. But to be in an office where people are getting fired and dreams are being crushed? I'm not sure I'd listen to that. If you were reporting on a startup and they "happened" to fall apart (kind of like the docu The Queen of Versailles) that would be something else entirely.

lukedy 11y ago
First up let me say how much I loved The Queen of Versailles. Such an amazing doco. I hear you, but it is definitely not about us capitalizing on the end of a business and we'd never force ourselves on anyone. We're looking at all different possibilities but don't want to underestimate the weight of being in the room with a company as it's ending versus just asking them after the fact. I agree it's a big ask, but speaking openly about this could be of value to others going through the same situation—as well as the founders and employees of the company itself. But I genuinely appreciate the input. It helps to remind me to be even more mindful of what it is we're asking people to do. Cheers, Luke
- rabidonrails 11y ago
  As I said I'm a huge fan of the Startup podcast (and actually all things Alex B). But if you're looking for new angles, why not find a bootstrapping startup. I bootstrapped a startup and it's a whole different experience that what we heard in season 1 or 2. In both of those seasons, by the time that we "met" the startup they already had crazy awesome connections. When Alex starts pitching Aurelio(!) he starts by pitching Chris Sacca! That's barely representative of any "normal" person who starts a company. And, we're first introduced to Dating Ring once they've already gotten into YC. Most of the people on HN would kill just to have gotten to that level. It's a little like having a show about trying to get a great job. But, the person you've decided to follow is currently in Harvard. I'm not saying YC is all fun and games, but it's hardly representative of the experience of most startups.

lukedy 11y ago

First up let me say how much I loved The Queen of Versailles. Such an amazing doco. I hear you, but it is definitely not about us capitalizing on the end of a business and we'd never force ourselves on anyone. We're looking at all different possibilities but don't want to underestimate the weight of being in the room with a company as it's ending versus just asking them after the fact. I agree it's a big ask, but speaking openly about this could be of value to others going through the same situation—as well as the founders and employees of the company itself. But I genuinely appreciate the input. It helps to remind me to be even more mindful of what it is we're asking people to do. Cheers, Luke

rabidonrails 11y ago
As I said I'm a huge fan of the Startup podcast (and actually all things Alex B). But if you're looking for new angles, why not find a bootstrapping startup. I bootstrapped a startup and it's a whole different experience that what we heard in season 1 or 2. In both of those seasons, by the time that we "met" the startup they already had crazy awesome connections. When Alex starts pitching Aurelio(!) he starts by pitching Chris Sacca! That's barely representative of any "normal" person who starts a company. And, we're first introduced to Dating Ring once they've already gotten into YC. Most of the people on HN would kill just to have gotten to that level. It's a little like having a show about trying to get a great job. But, the person you've decided to follow is currently in Harvard. I'm not saying YC is all fun and games, but it's hardly representative of the experience of most startups.