4 ms·
If the government invested all that money in small to middle sized local companies instead the province would be so much more prosperous. How exactly is anyone
by btilly 11y ago
If the government invested all that money in small to middle sized local companies instead the province would be so much more prosperous.
How exactly is anyone helped by money taking a round trip through the government rather than the same thing happening through free markets? You've made the cycle slower, you've made the recipients dependent on government bureaucratic decisions (who are not well-incentivized to decide well), and have reduced incentives for efficiency. And you've gained nothing.
Don't get me wrong. Government has important roles to play in our economy and society. We need government to create basic infrastructure, create regulations encouraging public goods, provide a stable system of law, and so on. But unless you are serving some legitimate purpose, channeling daily economic activity through the government is a net loss compared to doing the same through private enterprise.
Quebec being full of people who believe that the economy should go through the government seems to be its second largest economic mistake, and one it is still making on a large scale. People like you complain about the predictable results of this mistake, but don't see that it is a mistake.
Quebec's largest mistake was, of course, Bill 101. That made your province so hostile to anglophones that 1/3 of them "voluntarily emmigrated" within a few years. (The ones I know are inclined to dispute how voluntary that emmigration was...) They took with them the headquarters of many major companies, the associated jobs, and the general economic activity that would have come from those professionals spending locally. This is why, for example, The Bank of Montreal is now headquartered in Toronto.
There is a collective blind spot in Quebec to the true cost of this for your society. Major companies need to have a stream of professionals moving to their headquarters from elsewhere because that is how you move up in the hierarchy. If you have made professionals unwilling to move to Quebec (for instance by forcing their children to receive education in a language they don't speak), companies have to choose between moving headquarters or losing their most valued employees to competitors.
It proved to be cheaper to move headquarters. And they did. Quebec's economy has never recovered from this. (Though you did adjust your ethnic ratio by enough that you nearly managed to get a 50% vote to secede in the 90s...)
- guiomie 11y ago"Quebec's largest mistake was, of course, Bill 101" ... I thought it was the almost won referendum that drove this exile, not Bill 101. My impression is that if you lowered the income tax in Quebec (much higher then Ontario), most probably more professionals would be willing to work there, english or french or any other language. I agree with your statement of "Quebec being full of people who believe that the economy should go through the government".
- btilly 11y agoI thought it was the almost won referendum that drove this exile, not Bill 101. Nope. The almost won referendum was in 1995. The referendum that wasn't close was 1980. Bill 101 was 1977. The Bank of Montreal announced its move in 1977. (I'm aware of this because I had several classmates in high school whose families had moved from Quebec. They were extremely clear that they moved because of Bill 101, not because of the referendum.)
- dmix 11y agoI moved to Montreal from Toronto because of the great urban environment which I found (and still believe to be) superior to Toronto. The rents were cheap and salaries were lower, which made me believe running a startup there would be much easier. From the outside I wondered why everyone from Toronto wasn't moving there to build companies. But after a year living there I left - 100% due to the hostility to strictly English-speaking people. I hoped my lack of french-speaking ability would only be a minor hurdle that I could slowly overcome as I grasped the language over the years. But every single store you go into requires that they start speaking in french first (a bylaw). I watched three major street protests while walking downtown against stores who didn't change their globally-recognized retail brand names to french versions. Plus I felt a large cliquey nature to the Montreal tech scene. I felt like a foreigner in my own country. I was happy to go back to Toronto where multiculturalism is actually fully embraced. Where almost everyone still speaks their native language first, often remaining in cultural divided in neighbourhoods, and despite this mixing at bars and events is never an uncomfortable experience. Quebec's greatest economic problem is their obsession with cultural homogeneity.
- herge 11y ago> Quebec's largest mistake was, of course, Bill 101. No, no, Quebec's largest mistake was accepting confederation. If we'd just joined up with the Americans instead, and batter down all laws protecting our culture and laguage, we would have gotten assimilated anyway, but at least we'd have a stronger economy. Also, we wouldn't have to deal with the RoC...
- btilly 11y agoGoing back farther, the USA fought a war to get you in 1812... That said it is worth reflecting that most of the natural resources that Quebec has is on land that was added post-Confederation. Quebec received control of that land under a number of requirements, including that they take care of the natives. The natives do not believe that this requirement has been met, which is why for example the Cree voted over 95% for seceding from Quebec if Quebec seceded from Canada, by force if necessary. While the Quebecois were mixed on whether to secede, they had very strong opinions that Quebec was an indivisible whole. Including land given post-Confederation. It would have been interesting to see what would have happened with this land if the 1995 referendum had gone through. I'm quite sure that nobody outside of Quebec would have agreed with the reasoning that "Canada is divisible but Quebec is not". So how would Canada have handled the question of how to handle the economically valuable parts of Quebec that wanted back into Canada? See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partition_of_Quebec https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partition_of_Quebec for more on this.