6 ms·
We had a gov't for 10 years full of "Calgary-school" (Canada's right-wing ultra free market economic ideologues coming out of the University of Calgary econ/pol
by cmrdporcupine 11y ago
We had a gov't for 10 years full of "Calgary-school" (Canada's right-wing ultra free market economic ideologues coming out of the University of Calgary econ/poli-sci program). They were overwhelmingly driven by an oil and gas agenda. From the gov't down to mutual fund investors, everyone was treating our economy like a one-trick pony, all oil and gas.
If you listened to people talk, Alberta's oil sector was supporting the whole economy. Snarky message board comments from people from out west (where I'm from originally, BTW) making comments about Ontario being a "have-not" province being propped up by the superior entrepreneurial hard-working western oil sector.
Meanwhile through all of this as a % of GDP, exports in manufacturing were _still_ triple those of oil and gas. Ontario's beleaguered auto-sector was still the primary export in the country. Followed by agriculture and other sectors.
I said it at the time, and now it is obvious. They were lying through ideological teeth, and telling a story to the country about resource driven prosperity which was factually incorrect. And it has led to our country as a whole inheriting many of the problems Alberta as a province has been plagued with for decades: highly cyclical, with a political culture verging on corrupt, and environmentally dirty dirty dirty.
And I'm afraid the new gov't is only half-heartedly interested in remedying any of this.
Ontario and Quebec could be the "Germany of North America"; the deliberate assassination of our manufacturing and engineering sectors by everyone from federal gov't officials to fund managers has been disgusting. We have a heavy infrastructure debt, are saddled by decades of ideologically-driven mismanagement, and an ineptitude at actually getting anything done.
- wmil 11y ago> Ontario being a "have-not" province That's because Ontario's government managed to drive out most industry with an energy policy that created high and unstable electricity prices. As a result Ontario became a receiver of federal equalization payments for the first time ever. That's what the jokes were about.
- cmrdporcupine 11y agoThat's a good story that the Fraser institute made a lot of noise about, and made a great headline but in reality Ontario was still contributing more in tax revenues and EI contributions than it got in equalization payments: http://www.thestar.com/opinion/commentary/2013/03/30/money_still_flows_out_of_havenot_ontario.html http://www.thestar.com/opinion/commentary/2013/03/30/money_s...
- nickff 11y ago>"That's a good story that the Fraser institute made a lot of noise about" Please avoid implying that the post you are replying to is a shill unless you have good evidence to that effect. Even well-supported ad hominiem attacks rarely discredit the substance of a post, and your ad-hominem attack is unsupported by any evidence. You also failed to reply to what the post above you actually said, which was that Ontario was doing worse now than ever before (relative to the other provinces). In addition, I don't think this post follows the spirit of the Hacker News guidelines. "Be civil. Don't say things you wouldn't say in a face-to-face conversation. Avoid gratuitous negativity. When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names."
- cmrdporcupine 11y agoI didn't call the poster names or disparage them in any way. I posted an editorial that cited facts pointing out the inaccuracy of the claim that Ontario is a net subsidy recipient. Ontario's net contribution in taxes and EI payments outstrips any transfer payments it receives or has received. That I pointed out that the Fraser institute has made political hay out of the fact that Ontario has received subsidies is completely legitimate. They have been by far the organization that has boosted this line the most. They are a highly partisan ideological organization that in general gets way more uncritical press than they should.
- Sideshow_Boob 11y agostop hurting Frasier's feefees, Tone Policing Guy below is getting an aneurysm...
- dang 11y agoComments like this break the HN guidelines. Please post civilly and substantively or not at all.
- thescriptkiddie 11y ago>a story to the country about resource driven prosperity which was factually incorrect In a way, all stories about resource driven prosperity are incorrect. Natural resources are exported and so is the wealth they bring. You never hear about the prosperity of mining towns because they never have any, and when the resources run out they don't have jobs either.
- SixSigma 11y agoSame for countries exporting agricultural produce. They can't tarrif imports to stimulate local economic development because of WTO & IMF. Kenya will be stuck growing flowers forever!
- green7ea 11y agoI'm from Quebec and I have to agree with you that it could easily be north america's Germany. There is a lot of very talented software developers in Montreal but a lot of them leave to get higher salaries or work for foreign companies that love the very low, government subsidized wages [1]. If the government invested all that money in small to middle sized local companies instead the province would be so much more prosperous. Right now, profits are our biggest export. Not only that but the government insists on propping up big, mismanaged companies like CAE and bombardier time and time again [2] instead of investing in startups. [1] http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/how-far-will-quebec-go-to-nurture-its-video-game-industry/article14645301/ http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/how-far-wi... [2] http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/mark-milke/bombardier-corporate-welfare-trap_b_4705751.html http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/mark-milke/bombardier-corporate...
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoI don't think Quebec gets a free pass here. It was once the financial capital of Canada until all this separatist talk. Toronto then became the financial capital of Canada, with something like 40% of its companies HQ'd there. Montreal now has about a third of the GDP of Toronto, yet Toronto only has 1m more people! It seems like Canada is prone to buying into extremism. Be it separatism or the recent love-affair with Putinist style economics banking soley on oil/gas and expecting there never to be a shake-up in the market when clearly the industrialized West was going full tilt into renewables.
- raverbashing 11y agoI agree It's ridiculous when people (not Quebeckers) can't get a job in Quebec, then they go to other provinces and get a job quickly. This is something I've seen from close Not to mention the big gap between provinces, it seems they're more apart than US states
- btilly 11y agoCheck the timeline. It wasn't separatism that drove companies out, it was Bill 101. (OK, Bill 101 was driven by the same motives as separatism.) Thanks to that bill, you had a population of professionals who had moved to Montreal for good jobs who found that, because they were born in a different province, their children could not be educated in English. These professionals found it less painful to move to Toronto and find new jobs than they did to watch their children be forced into schools that didn't speak their language. Companies found that it was cheaper to relocate headquarters than to lose these employees, and this accelerated the brain drain. Quebec continues to be hostile to anglophone immigration, but most of the damage is now done and permanent.
- dghughes 11y agoOil and gas, conservative but also headed by (Harper) a pretty much far right religious attitude which pushed climate change denial and also anti-science in general.