3 ms·
I have long been wanting this kind of taxation to happen. It seems the most fair as the wealth increase created from ex. owning lots of land or building is most
by ThomPete 11y ago
I have long been wanting this kind of taxation to happen. It seems the most fair as the wealth increase created from ex. owning lots of land or building is mostly done by the rest of society not by the individual purchase of a building.
So basically we should tax money that lazy and give tax breaks to money that are actively working.
This also correlates with how economist normally want the economy to work. When everyone spends money wealth is created. You could say that people who make less money are better citizens from that perspective in that they are more likely to keep the economy going than those who just let it sit and collect in the background.
- norea-armozel 11y agoThe problem is how do you deal with systemically created lazy money? Right now, some banks are just sitting on money since there's not much in terms of opportunities to invest. It seems to me the problem is that money effectively ceased to have any real value in the economy post-2007/8.
- jbssm 11y agoIf it's really that way then you wouldn't oppose that much for a part of it to be taken away from you. After all, it doesn't have "any real value".
- norea-armozel 11y agoIt's not so much my reaction to that sort of action but rather how the people who affect the market would react that matters. Let's say tomorrow all the govts of the world got together and said X amount of dollars in banks will be null and void of value (no taxes, just removed entirely from the market). Can you imagine the economic contraction that would occur? If you think the Great Depression or earlier panics were a problem this hypothetical situation would practically implode a century's worth of growth. The reality is that we're stuck in a disaster of our own making. Partly because money has no value (no commodity backing) and partly because since we decoupled value from money we thought we could print more of it to spur growth. But growth doesn't come from the money, it comes from the labor to produce goods and the goods which save time when we labor. You can't shortcut your way to growth. It comes from those sources and nowhere else. The rest is purely speculation driven or illusory in general. And it gets worse you think about the hard reality that people don't want more things. Consumerism doesn't fix the problem either as private debt keeps ballooning people realize their finite resources (wages from their own labor) is dwarfed by credit payments. So, bing bang boom the whole thing falls down.
- Zach_the_Lizard 11y ago>It seems the most fair as the wealth increase created from ex. owning lots of land If you want to charge people for profiting from land, it seems a land tax would be the best way to do it. It's essentially a property tax, except instead of taxing the land and the improvements, only the unimproved land value is taxed. This allows capturing some of the economic rents by society as a whole in a way that has very little distortion and is essentially avoidable only by moving. Moving would mean not taking advantage of any of the benefits or improvements of the area, so the only way to avoid it would be to give up the benefits. A wealth tax, by contrast, could be avoided by moving wealth to another country. Since a large amount of wealth is tied up in land, a land tax is a sort of wealth tax by proxy, but with virtuous effects of promoting additional development and investment and punishing things like land speculation. It's a progressive tax too.
- ThomPete 11y agoI agree about just moving the money to another country is an issue. But it's one that a globalized world where money can move freely must deal with somehow. I think we will see this shift and that more and more countries will be working together closer and closer. It's going to take time but I think it's unavoidable.