10 ms·
How to access the Darknet. The safe way
- zlatan_todoric 11y agoAnd Whonix atop of Qubes would probably be an overkill atm. https://www.whonix.org/wiki/Qubes https://www.whonix.org/wiki/Qubes
- etiam 11y agoWhy do you think so?
- zlatan_todoric 11y agoI meant an overkill as an excellent solution atm (sorry for not being precise - non-native here ;)
- etiam 11y agoThat's OK. :) Then I believe we agree on this. I think many people would do well to include some overkill, in cases like this, to adjust for the risk of underestimating the difficulty 'killing' the problem. To be fair, Qubes is arguably not really ready to be put into the hands of a casual computer user without specific threats yet. But for those who can handle it it seems like the most accessible option I've heard of for keeping the underlying system safe and preventing unmasking.
- Havoc 11y ago>Your operating system could be infected, or leaking information otherwise. "otherwise"? Is that code for has Windows 10 written on the box?
- TallGuyShort 11y agoLots of things leak information in ways that aren't considered and infection. Tools used to administer corporate infrastructure, for instance. Windows 10 might fit in that category too.
- zanny 11y agoMicrosoft backported a lot of the logging and tracking to Windows 7 and 8 as well. Not all of it, but enough to consider any computer running fully updated Windows to be user-privacy compromised.
- frik 11y agoWhy does MSFT gets away with this. This is so evil. MSFT appearently spends a lot of money on paid commenters and lobbyism in general. Thanks god that XBoxOne, WinPhone are real flops - most aren't that stupid, for end users MSFT & Win are a burned brand names.
- zanny 11y ago> Why does MSFT gets away with this. Go to any store, anywhere. What computers are they selling? Maybe Chromebooks, which are showing to be wildly popular. But they also get returned a lot. Why? Because the user expects X software to run on Y computer, and do not even know what an operating system is because we idled in complacency on Microsofts desktop monopoly for twenty years. Take note of how Walmart sells Ipads but not Macbooks. The only alternative to Windows is ChromeOS. Which is not an alternative for even half of Widows' use cases, since there is no native application support and its app-store restricted. Half of Windows appeal is the lack of application lockdown to a store, albeit MS has tried their hardest with their Windows Store to stop that. OSX is not an alternative, Apple Stores are fairly few and far between, and the cost of a Mac is prohibitive, and it would have the exact same software incompatibility problems as Windows. And modern OSX is code signing applications and is, for consumers, even more restrictive and draconian than Windows is - do you want your potential software users on iOS or OSX? I certainly do not, because that gives Apple absolute power to stop my software at their whim, or never approve it in the first place. Ubuntu (or any desktop Linux) is also not an alternative, because, simply, its not there on the shelf next to Windows or ChromeOS. If Macs are inaccessible due to price and location, Ubuntu does not even exist - and it literally does not, given its market segment size. If Canonical wanted serious desktop adoption they would have to throw ludicrous money getting Ubuntu computers in front of potential users to purchase. So of course MS gets away with this. Nobody is trying to stop them. And I doubt Xbone is a flop - it has sold 15 million units, half of the PS4 but still well on track to outsell the original Xbox in its lifetime, which only moved 24 million units in 5 years. I am insanely against consoles as a platform and pray they die finally and give consumers their hardware back, but that seems like a distant dream as well.
- nvrsummer 11y agoWell at least they didn't give away the real Darknet
- node_gt_go 11y agoCalm down Saville
- nvrsummer 11y agoCute
- secfirstmd 11y agoIf anyone is interested, we (www.secfirst.org) just launched an Android open source app called Umbrella, which has lessons like this, along with a ton of other digital and physical security stuff. Everything from secure email to dealing with kidnap: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.secfirst.umbrella https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.secfirst.u...
- esMazer 11y agolooks interesting which they had an iOS version
- secfirstmd 11y agoWe are hoping to do this in 2016, we currently looking for a non-profit funder to be able to develop it. We decided on Android first as it is dominant on cheap devices etc in the developing world.
- vjvj 11y agowhy does this app require access to my current or saved locations?
- secfirstmd 11y agoActually it doesn't if you are using the lessons and checklists etc. It only applies if you want to use the feature that allows you to input your location and then pull updated physical security country data feeds from the UN and Centre for Disease Control.
- vjvj 11y agoThanks for clarifying. It was an all or nothing option for me - i.e. if I denied location access I couldn't use the app.
- Sir_Cmpwn 11y agoYou should make this available via F-Droid.
- sarciszewski 11y ago> I see this questioned regularly, and yeah it is generally a good idea. If you have a VPN provider that you trust to not keep logs, it can be a very good addition for your security setup. Therein lies the problem. You can't trust VPN providers. https://gist.github.com/joepie91/5a9909939e6ce7d09e29 https://gist.github.com/joepie91/5a9909939e6ce7d09e29
- warmlagoon 11y agoIMHO Even thought the provider would log it is still better than not using one in a lot of cases. If whoever can see my VPN address, he would otherwise see my real address directly. In that way he has to find a way to get the VPN provider to give out my real address. What might be possible with a lot, but for sure not with all of them. Also think countries, my country does barely have any contracts with other countries for crimes like this. So they would have to use a complicated way to actually force them to give out my data. In most situations we are already way over the realistic damage done in forms of costs to catch the individual.
- Throwaway23412 11y agoYeah, GP is right in that you can't trust VPNs (for example, PIA is probably a massive honeypot for all we know.) However, if you're using a VPN outside of the jurisdiction of the "Fourteen Eyes", you've substantially increased the effort required for anyone outside of that VPN to monitor you.
- Freak_NL 11y ago> for example, PIA is probably a massive honeypot for all we know. Why the 'probably'? Of course, no VPN-provider should be trusted at face value, but do you know of any sources that claim that Private Internet Access is in fact an elaborate honeypot?
- Throwaway23412 11y agoI was just thinking that PIA would be the perfect candidate for a honeypot, especially since it's under USA jurisdiction. Does the "probably" make it sound like I'm making a claim? I can change it if you'd like.
- megraf 11y agoI'd actually recommend a SOCKS5 Proxy over a VPN. > The SOCKS server does not interpret the network traffic between client and server in any way, and is often used because clients are behind a firewall and are not permitted to establish TCP connections to servers outside the firewall unless they do it through the SOCKS server.
- tasqa 11y agoWhile the advice is okay, the title is a huge turn off. There is no such thing as the Darknet. Please stop referring to the TOR network this way. It is harmful to the community and encourages journalists to write about TOR in a negative way!
- aw3c2 11y ago* Tor ;)
- soneca 11y agoI have a negative view of the Tor network, actually the name I use is indeed Darknet (or Deep Web). My take is that it is valuable to use Tor to (try at least) to escape companies tracking and government spying. But to visit any website only available on Tor network is not worth any effort on my part, as I have no doubt (currently) that it is all about illegal porn or illegal drugs and sinister scams. Anyone care to give some counter argument to why this Tor Network deserves a positive light?
- frozenport 11y agoAvoiding the People's Republic of China
- arca_vorago 11y ago"s I have no doubt (currently) that it is all about illegal porn or illegal drugs and sinister scams." You have come to your conclusion based upon nothing more than feeling, because if you had done any searching at all you would understand the answer to your question. Everyone has heard the metaphor about leading a horse to water. In this case, it's more like the horse refuses to even be lead to the water but wants someone to go get a bucket of water and bring it to them. No one should or is gonna do it for you, especially since you have demonstrated a clearly exemplary amount of laziness in both effort and thought... tldr Tor sites != illegality tor != darknet/deep web (eg, the darknet/deep web is much broader than just tor...)
- soneca 11y ago
- kauegimenes 11y agoDont look at the comments in this blog post...
- leoplct 11y agoI have Tried. There are only drugs, underage photos, scams, fake passaports and so on. What's the point of Darknet besides illegal activtities?
- hluska 11y agoThis is a very poor answer and, while I'm pretty sure that you're just trolling, Tor is important enough that your 'claim' really needs to be rebutted. Consider a service like SecureDrop. Armed with SecureDrop, journalists and dissidents/whistleblowers can communicate in a more secure way. Or, consider a publication like Propublica. They set up a hidden service so that they could talk about censorship in China...and hopefully allow Chinese citizens to read it without ending up in serious legal trouble. Statements like yours are the problem and I seriously hope that you take the time to educate yourself. Ignorance may be funny to you, but it makes it more dangerous for legitimate activists and journalists to use Tor.
- delecti 11y agoI've always interpreted "darknet" to mean the content itself, rather than Tor. That would make the parent comment's question entirely reasonable, without saying anything about the usefulness of Tor.
- hluska 11y agoThat's a good interpretation and I'd do well to keep that possibility in mind. Sorry if I came across as too aggressive. Based on the context, I assumed that the parent was talking about needing Tor to access the Darknet. If that's the case, the parent would be talking about Tor hidden services. While there are some really shitty hidden services, there are also some amazing applications - SecureDrop is one example.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ikeboy 11y agoWhy is a hidden service needed? If someone can access onion websites, they can access any site. All Propublica would need to do is make sure they don't block tor exit nodes (some CDNs like cloudlfare will). I don't see what benefits there are of having a hidden service if you don't need to hide. The only thing would be encouraging/enforcing safe usage, but that doesn't enable anything, only forces people to use security that was already available. (To be clear, I'm only talking about hidden services, not tor in general.)
- CptThrowawy 11y agoNation state agencies just go to upstream providers and grab traffic metadata there, your VPS/VPN not keeping logs won't help against a targeted investigation. Even just downloading Tor or Tails gets your IP "task queued" according to Snowden leaks. You would want to both obtain and use Tor nowhere near your meatspace identity, pref with different hardware than you usually use, and leave your phone at home if protection from tracking is your highest priority.
- herbst 11y agoNot everybody is living in the US tho. Most countries can barely force any other country to give out consumer data from local companies. If you do not live in a five eyes state we can safely assume that nobody will target you that way for Tor browsing.
- sidcool 11y agoQuite a let down article.
- sandworm101 11y agoAccessing Tor "safely" is something over and above accessing the normal internet safely. Advice like "don't open PDFs" isn't very helpful. Nor is "don't use javascript" or "don't log into social media." Such inactions don't help you access anything safely, they help you not access things in the first place. (1) Use a secure OS. Unless you are security guru, that should be some flavour of linux. A liveUSB of Tails is pretty idiot proof. It worked for Snowden. (2) Don't run any web browser, tor or otherwise, under any sort of elevated privilege (ie not while admin). (3) Understand how to verify a website's certificates. You can indeed log into social media safely via tor (ie your password won't be harvested by the exit node) if you know how to verify the website. (4) Don't take anonymity casually. Understand why you are using Tor, what you are protecting, who your adversary is, and develop relevant procedures. Don't rely on easy checklists you find at Tor-for-Dummies.com.
- birdperson 11y ago> Use a secure OS... A liveUSB of Tails is pretty idiot proof. That implies Tails is very secure. Why is that? Is it because it has never been hacked before or has Tails been shown to be virtually hacker-proof? As someone non-technical I might be misunderstanding something. If so, can you clarify that? Thanks.
- jarboot 11y agoTails is intended to be run on a USB drive. This means you can take nearly any computer, boot to usb, and have a operating system designed for security running in the computer's RAM. Many claim that this does not leave a trace of your activity in the computer itself. It also comes with tor browser, electrum bitcoin wallet, and some GPG utilities preinstalled.
- sandworm101 11y agoTails works well enough for the average noob. It isn't perfect, but a far cry better than them running torbrowser on their everyday windows machine.
- simonebrunozzi 11y agoThis article has several mistakes and typos. I find it actually hard to enjoy reading it, and it also seems very superficial. Am I the only one to feel this way?
- herbst 11y agoThank you for this feedback. I usually dont write, it is just a topic where i felt that could need some noob friendly coverage and just started writing. If i even proceed i will look into someone that proof reads my blabber. It is also not my first language. (i am actually even surprised about the interest)