7 ms·
> The question posed was: should your self-driving car swerve to avoid those kids who just got off the school bus, sacrificing you and the passengers? That str
by digi_owl 11y ago
> The question posed was: should your self-driving car swerve to avoid those kids who just got off the school bus, sacrificing you and the passengers?
That strikes me as seeing the car computer as having the same limitations as a human driver.
More likely the car computer has long since recognized the bus as being, well, a bus, and thus slowed down to provide shorter breaking distance etc.
These are the same exact rules that will be drilled into any driver if they get a sane course before being issued the license.
Keep in mind that right now what is regulating speed limits etc, is human reaction times.
Once held down, breaks can make a car stop very quickly.
But the actual breaking distance is just a fraction of the distance needed for a human driven car to stop.
Most of that distances comes from how long it takes for the human brain to go through the steps of noticing, recognizing, and acting on something.
Likely any computer driven car out there will be the most defensive driver on the road. Frankly more vehicle related deaths comes from driver hubris than anything else.
- hosh 11y agoWhat you say has merit, yet it sidesteps and ignores the deeper, more troubling issues: is it possible to go Asimov Three Laws of Robotics? Is it possible to specify ethical and moral coding precisely, programmatically? That car example is just a stand-in for an entire class of ethical and moral dilemmas coming out of it. Let's look at it from a different angle. There is a hospital in Oregon who are trying to squeeze more profits, so much so that they induced doctors working there to unionize. The hospital promptly dropped their attempt at outsourcing. It won't be last attempt at this. As the pressure for profits increases, and as machine learning technology gets more advanced, there will come a point when it is the AI that makes the judgement call on who lives or dies. Who is going to program that? Are software engineers necessarily all that better in creating systems that computes the optimal outcome that includes both ethics and morals, than say, lawmakers or philosophers? Are you really OK with having moral choices taken out of your hand and given to a computer, assuming that whomever wrote the code actually knew what they were doing and didn't make mistakes? From this frame, what you are suggesting is that a properly designed computer is better at making moral and ethical judgements than humans.
- digi_owl 11y agoI could have sworn that those 3 laws were specifically there to show how damn hard it would be to codify morality. Either by demonstrating how awry things went with strict adherence, or similarly how one could twist things to get around them without violating them.